Scaling Up: From Individual Design to Collaborative Design to Collective Design

  title={Scaling Up: From Individual Design to Collaborative Design to Collective Design},
  author={Mary Lou Maher and Mercedes Paulini and Paul Murty},
  booktitle={Data Compression Conference},
This paper presents a conceptual space for collective design to facilitate development of design environments that encourage large-scale participation in the next generation of challenging design tasks. Developing successful collective design starts by understanding how individual and collaborative design are supported with computing technology and then goes beyond collaborative design to structure and organize the design tasks so that people are motivated to participate. The analysis in this… 

Design processes in collective innovation communities: a study of communication

A framework is defined for structuring and understanding the management of collective innovation processes and the roles of participants, and mechanisms were identified which describe ways in which collective innovation produces successful solutions shaped by community input.

ArchiBrain: A Conceptual Platform for the Visualization of Collaborative Design

This evaluation study provides the first indications that this visualization platform is able to increase the intrinsic motivation for designers to contribute in a collaborative manner, provides a clear overview over the design process, and can help directing collaborative efforts by highlighting the most popular design proposals.

The role of collective intelligence in design: A protocol study of online design communication

This analysis shows that a design process that includes collective intelligence shares processes of ideation and evaluation with individual and team design, and also includes a significant amount of social networking.

Design Creativity Research: From the Individual to the Crowd

Research in design creativity has focused on individual creativity and on creativity in a collaborative or organizational setting. Collective design and crowdsourcing creativity differ from

A Process Model for Crowdsourcing Design: A Case Study in Citizen Science

A model for crowdsourcing experience design is presented and a case study of how it has been deployed and adapted to a citizen science project where nature preserve visitors can participate in the design of a system called NatureNet.

Computational Schema as a Facilitator for Crowdsourcing in a “Social‐Motive” Model of Design

By exploiting the concept of the parametric schema as a common representational formalism, the wisdom of the crowd can potentially be integrated to inform processes of digital design generation, adaptation and change in the various phases of design in order to improve design.

Collective Design: Remixing and Visibility

Creative work can be performed by thousands of people who interact through collective design systems. The designers modify and combine each other’s work in a process called remixing. Remixing can social design innovation for homeless families: collective design creativity

Design Creativity has largely been explored as an individual expression of design cognition rather than as the collective manifestation of interaction in context. Recent approaches to design with an

Crowdsourcing: theoretical framework, computational environments and design scenarios

This article develops the concepts and issues associated with the possibility of crowdsourcing design as well as discussing its relationship to prior developments of media environments for collaborative design.

Instruments for Collective Design in a Professional Context: Digital Format or New Processes ?

The diversity of typologies of collective activity is shown, the main factors of collaboration are identified, the needs for the instrumentation of professional practice are concluded, and the needs of agencies are highlighted.



Co-creating external design representations: Comparing face-to-face sketching to designing in virtual environments

An experiment was conducted to identify similarities and differences between co-located collaborative designing using sketches as the external representation and remote collaborative designing sessions using sketches and 3-D models.

Supporting creativity in distributed scientific communities

Three design implications to support creativity in CSCW are proposed: integrate support for individual, dyadic, and group brainstorming, leverage cognitive conflict by preserving and reflecting on minority dissent, and support flexibility in granularity of planning.

The impact of tangible user interfaces on spatial cognition during collaborative design

Co-evolution as a computational and cognitive model of design

The study shows that co-evolutionary design is a good cognitive model of design and highlights the similarities and differences between the computational model and the cognitive model.

Ewall: A Visual Analytics Environment for Collaborative Sense-Making

EWall is designed to enable individual users to navigate vast amounts of shared information effectively and help remotely dispersed team members combine their contributions, work independently without diverting from common objectives, and minimize the necessary amount of verbal communication.

Collective knowledge systems: Where the Social Web meets the Semantic Web

Collective Intelligence and its Implementation on the Web: Algorithms to Develop a Collective Mental Map

The creation of a network of pheromone trails by ant colonies points to some basic mechanisms of CMM development: averaging of individual preferences, amplification of weak links by positive feedback, and integration of specialised subnetworks through division of labor.

What motivates Wikipedians?

In order to increase and enhance user-generated content contributions, it is important to understand the factors that lead people to freely share their time and knowledge with others.

Harnessing Crowds: Mapping the Genome of Collective Intelligence

This article identifies the underlying building blocks - to use a biological metaphor, the "genes" - at the heart of collective intelligence systems and shows how combinations of genes comprise a "genome" that characterizes each collective intelligence system.

Understanding and assessing the motivations of volunteers: a functional approach.

Evidence for predictive validity is provided by a laboratory study in which VFI motivations predicted the persuasive appeal of messages better when message and motivation were matched than mismatched, and by field studies in which the extent to which volunteers' experiences matched their motivations predicted satisfaction.