Sampling bias in climate–conflict research

  title={Sampling bias in climate–conflict research},
  author={Courtland Adams and Tobias Ide and Jon Barnett and Adrien Detges},
  journal={Nature Climate Change},
Critics have argued that the evidence of an association between climate change and conflict is flawed because the research relies on a dependent variable sampling strategy1–4. Similarly, it has been hypothesized that convenience of access biases the sample of cases studied (the ‘streetlight effect’5). This also gives rise to claims that the climate–conflict literature stigmatizes some places as being more ‘naturally’ violent6–8. Yet there has been no proof of such sampling patterns. Here we… Expand

Figures and Tables from this paper

Reassessing Sampling Bias in Climate-Conflict Research
Is research into the links between climate change and conflict biased, and does this bias undermine our ability to draw conclusions about climate-conflict links? Adams et al. (2018, henceforth AIBD)Expand
Sampling bias does not exaggerate climate–conflict claims
  • M. Levy
  • Sociology
  • Nature Climate Change
  • 2018
To the Editor — In a recent Letter, Adams and colleagues1 argue that claims regarding climate–conflict links are overstated because of sampling bias. However, this conclusion rests on logicalExpand
Reply to ‘Sampling bias does not exaggerate climate–conflict claims’
To the Editor — In a recent Letter, Adams and colleagues1 argue that claims regarding climate–conflict links are overstated because of sampling bias. However, this conclusion rests on logicalExpand
Climate has contrasting direct and indirect effects on armed conflicts
There is an active debate regarding the influence that climate has on the risk of armed 15 conflict, which stems from challenges in assembling unbiased datasets, competing 16 hypotheses on theExpand
The Moderating Effect of Democracy on Climate-Induced Social Conflict: Evidence from Indian Districts
Do political institutions moderate the effect of environmental stress on social conflict? We posit that while the frequency of social conflict in developing agrarian states can increase duringExpand
Scenarios and Decision Support for Security and Conflict Risks in the Context of Climate Change
  • V. Schweizer
  • Political Science
  • Current Climate Change Reports
  • 2019
Purpose of ReviewConcerns about conflict induced by climate change have captured the attention of policymakers, but the scientific foundations for these claims are contested. This review brieflyExpand
Natural resources and conflict: A meta-analysis of the empirical literature
Abstract The link between natural resources and conflict has been extensively analysed by the empirical literature. Yet, there is disagreement on both the existence and the type of relationshipExpand
Security implications of climate change: The climate-conflict nexus
Abstract The physical consequences of climate change that is projected for the coming years will affect and interact with a range of social processes in affected societies. The burden of climateExpand
Exploring the relationship between climate change and violent conflict
ABSTRACT Does climate change lead to violent conflict? This article reviews the existing literature connecting climatic conditions to conflict. It finds that the existing literature has not detectedExpand
Climate security and a vulnerability model for conflict prevention: a systematic literature review focusing on African agriculture
BackgroundClimate change poses credible threats to the livelihoods of many. This paper addresses how climate change adaptation can help counter the increased risk of violent conflict that isExpand


Climate change and conflict: Making sense of disparate findings
Abstract This introduction to the special issues starts with a general overview of the literature. The relationship between climate, climate change, and conflict has been empirically tested in a wideExpand
Positivist Climate Conflict Research: A Critique
In recent years a large body of work has emerged that uses a positivist epistemology and quantitative methods to assess the likely conflict impacts of global climate change. This article advances aExpand
Research methods for exploring the links between climate change and conflict
The potential links between climate change and conflict have received much attention in recent years, but there is little consensus on the issue in the relevant literature. So far, few methodologicalExpand
On exposure, vulnerability and violence: Spatial distribution of risk factors for climate change and violent conflict across Kenya and Uganda
Abstract Recent studies discuss the link between climate change and violent conflict, especially for East Africa. While there is extensive literature on the question whether climate change increasesExpand
Climate clashes? Weather variability, land pressure, and organized violence in Kenya, 1989–2004
The evidence of coming climate change has generated catastrophe-like statements of a future where a warmer, wetter, and wilder climate leads to a surge in migrant streams and gives rise to new wars.Expand
Quantifying the Influence of Climate on Human Conflict
There is more agreement across studies regarding the influence of climate on human conflict than has been recognized previously and warmer temperatures or extremes of rainfall can be causally associated with changes in interpersonal violence and in civil war. Expand
Armed Conflict and The Environment: A Critique of the Literature
Conflict over scarce resources, such as minerals, fish, water, and particularly territory, is a traditional source of armed struggle. Recently, wideranging claims have been made to the effect thatExpand
One effect to rule them all? A comment on climate and conflict
A recent Climatic Change review article reports a remarkable convergence of scientific evidence for a link between climatic events and violent intergroup conflict, thus departing markedly from otherExpand
Violent climate or climate of violence? Concepts and relations with focus on Kenya and Sudan
Addressing deficits of current research on the link between climate change and violent conflict, this article aims to contribute to a more systematic understanding of the violence concept in theExpand
Climate–conflict research: some reflections on the way forward
A decade of systematic research on climate change and armed conflict has revealed a number of interesting patterns but few results that are robust across studies. This essay takes stock of theExpand