Sacrifice and Stigma: Reducing Free-riding in Cults, Communes, and Other Collectives

  title={Sacrifice and Stigma: Reducing Free-riding in Cults, Communes, and Other Collectives},
  author={Laurence R. Iannaccone},
  journal={Journal of Political Economy},
  pages={271 - 291}
  • L. Iannaccone
  • Published 1 April 1992
  • Economics, Political Science
  • Journal of Political Economy
This paper presents an economic analysis of religious behavior that accounts for the continuing success of groups with strange requirements and seemingly inefficient prohibitions. The analysis does not presuppose any special motives for religious activity. Rather, religion is modeled as a club good that displays positive returns to "participatory crowding." The analysis demonstrates that efficient religions with perfectly rational members may benefit from stigma, self-sacrifice, and bizarre… 
Salvation as a Selective Incentive
As club goods, religions face the problem of free riding. Smaller religious clubs, such as cults or sects, can often surmount this problem through communal pressures or by requiring their members to
Salvation as a Selective Incentive: An Olsonian Analysis of the Faith vs. Works Cleavage
As club goods, religions face the problem of free riding. Smaller religious clubs, such as cults or sects, can often surmount this problem through communal pressures or by requiring their members to
Religious extremism: The good, the bad, and the deadly
This paper challenges conventional views of violent religious extremism, particularly those that emphasize militant theology. We offer an alternative analysis that helps explain the persistent demand
Why churches need free-riders: Religious capital formation and religious group survival
Prevailing theory claims that churches thrive when they overcome the free-rider problem. However, this paper argues that religious organizations need free-riders in a dynamic setting. If individuals’
Revisiting sacrifice and stigma: Why older churches become more liberal
Abstract This paper revisits the concept of ‘Sacrifice and Stigma’ first introduced in the seminal model of Iannaccone, published in 1992. Iannaccone provides an explanation for the rise of strict
Economic and Religious Choice: A Case-Study from Early Christian Communities
The aim of this paper is to elaborate an evaluative framework of religious choice within the early Christian communities reconstructed through the narrative of a New Testament Epistle, 2Peter, based
Violence, Self-Worth, Solidarity and Stigma: How a Dissident, Far-Right Group Solves the Collective Action Problem
How do dissident, far-right groups overcome the collective action problem inherent to political organisation in order to recruit sufficient activists willing to bear the costs of participation and
The Economics of Religious Indulgences
We model the Catholic Church as a heterogeneous club managed by a specialized agency that pursues the enlargement of the club within given constraints. Religious indulgences induce the self selection
Religion and Intragroup Cooperation: Preliminary Results of a Comparative Analysis of Utopian Communities
Several authors have argued that religious beliefs are a way of communicating commitment and loyalty to other group members. The advantage of commitment signals is that they can promote intragroup
Substitution and Stigma: Evidence on Religious Competition from the Catholic Sex-Abuse Scandal
This paper considers substituting one charitable activity for another in the context of religious practice. I examine the impact of the Catholic Church sex-abuse scandal on both Catholic and


A Formal Model of Church and Sect
The sociology of religion is an area rich in generalizations but poor in theory. Against this background, economic models offer the hope of better theory and more precise predictions. Previous work
The future of religion: Secularization, revival, and cult formation
Religion is alive and well in the modern world, and the social-scientific study of religion is undergoing a renaissance. For much of this century, respected social theorists predicted the death of
American Mainline Religion: Its Changing Shape and Future
Wade Clark Roof and William McKinney argue that a new voluntarism is slowly eroding the old social and economic boundaries that once defined and separated religious groups and is opening new
Cults, Converts and Charisma: The Sociology of New Religious Movements
Recent decades have seen an apparent increase in the number and vitality of new religious movements throughout the world. They have also been marked by evident social conflict over the activities of
Commitment and Community: Communes and Utopias in Sociological Perspective
Part One: The Utopian Faith * A Refuge and a Hope * Society's Maternal Bed: Idealizations of Communal Life Part Two: Lessons of the Past * Commitment: The Problem and the Theory * Live in Love and
Household Allocation of Time and Church Attendance
This paper presents the first systematic attempt by economists to analyze the determinants of individuals' participation in religious activities. A multiperiod utility-maximizing model of household
The Rise of a New World Faith
This essay suggests the unique opportunity the Mormons present to sociologists of religion: a chance to watch an extraordinarily rare event, the rise of a new world faith. Patterns of Mormon growth
Turning Pews Into People: Estimating 19th Century Church Membership
data on religious affiliation. In this essay we use census data on churches to reconstruct detailed membership estimates for 1850, 1860, and 1870 by means of weighted least squares equations. We then
Gifts as Economic Signals and Social Symbols
Gift-giving has often puzzled economists, especially because efficient grifts-like cash or giving exactly what a person asks for-seem crass or inappropriate. It is shown in a formal game-theoretic
Marketing Signaling: Informational Transfer in Hiring and Related Screening Processes.
In introducing his theory of human capital, Gary Becker offered the following claim: "[the theory] offers a unified explanation of a wide range of empirical phenomena," (Humian Capital, p. 7). A.