Rushton's racial comparisons: An ecological critique of theory and method.

@article{Anderson1991RushtonsRC,
  title={Rushton's racial comparisons: An ecological critique of theory and method.},
  author={Judith L. Anderson},
  journal={Canadian Psychology},
  year={1991},
  volume={32},
  pages={51-62}
}
Many scientists have criticized Rushton's application of a hypothesis about rand K-selection to putative human racial differences (e.g., Cain & Vanderwolf, 1990; Lynn, 1989a, 1989b; Silverman, 1990; Weizmann, Wiener, Wiesenthal, & Ziegler, 1990; Zuckerman & Brody, 1988). The criticisms of Rushton's theoretical approach by Weizmann et al. are certainly appropriate, but they were not sufficiently forceful in asserting the fact that Rushton's approach misses the point of rand K-selection: It… Expand

Tables from this paper

Lack of racial differences in behavior: A quantitative replication of Rushton's (1988) review and an independent meta-analysis
Rushton (Personality and Individual Differences, 9, 1009–1024, 1988) hypothesized that racial group differences exist across a range of behaviors from intelligence to social organization. SuchExpand
On the Similarities of American Blacks and Whites
The history of science teaches us that many ambitious racists attempted to manufacture scientific evidence for their beliefs. Sooner or later, their charlatan style methodology (e.g., the use ofExpand
A working example of Biaggio and Bittner's proposed collaboration between psychology and optometry.
both in and among countries. On a per capita basis, for example, Black Caribbeans are now known to have as big an AIDS problem as do Africans and Black Americans (Rushton, 1990a). Finally, a wordExpand
Psychopathic personality and racial/ethnic differences reconsidered: a reply to Lynn (2002)
Abstract Lynn (2002) argued that psychopathic personality is distributed disproportionately across racial and ethnic groups, and that these putative group differences were likely attributable toExpand
DEFINING SELF IN A MULTICULTURAL CONTEXT: AN EXPLORATION OF SOME COGNITIVE IMPLICATIONS
The Canadian multicultural social context formed the backdrop of the present study which was aimed at investigating the dynamics of ethno-cultural self-definitions, race, and comparisons between selfExpand
Substance, History, and Politics
  • C. Black, A. Figueredo, W. J. Jacobs
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Evolutionary psychology : an international journal of evolutionary approaches to psychology and behavior
  • 2017
TLDR
The history and relations between biodemographic and psychological measures of LH, which remain murky at best, are examined to catalyze an explicit discussion among LH researchers and to provoke novel research avenues that combine the strengths each approach brings to this burgeoning field. Expand
Africanist archaeology and ancient IQ: racial science and cultural evolution in the twenty-first century
Abstract Over the last two decades, a number of psychometric researchers have claimed that very substantial differences in intelligence exist among modern human racial groups, as these groups areExpand
"RACE," SEX AND SOCIAL CLASS DIFFERENCES IN COGNITIVE ABILITY: TOWARDS A CONTEXTUAL RATHER THAN GENETIC EXPLANATION
Are "race," sex and social class differences in cognitive ability a matter of brain size or genes? Some researchers answer with an unequivocal "yes" to this question. The aim of our review is toExpand
Do human ‘life history strategies’ exist?
Abstract Interest in incorporating life history research from evolutionary biology into the human sciences has grown rapidly in recent years. Two core features of this research have the potential toExpand
Global behavioral variation: A test of differential-K
Despite Rushton’s path-breaking work into evolutionary forces affecting life history traits, not many attempts at operationalizing the differential-K spectrum at the level of countries or racialExpand
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 32 REFERENCES
Differential K theory and racial hierarchies.
Rushton's Differential K theory, derived from the r/K model of evolutionary selection, purportedly explains racial differences in sexual practices and anatomy, fertility, 1Q, and criminality. TheseExpand
Oysters, rabbits and people: A critique of “race differences in behaviour” by J.P. Rushton
Abstract Rushton's article is criticized for its logic, the credibility of some of its sources, selectivity from the literature and from data within studies, failing to consider diversity inExpand
Criticisms of an evolutionary hypothesis about race differences: A rebuttal to Rushton's reply
Abstract Rushton's (1989) response failed to address many of my criticisms, cited the relevant literature in a biased manner, and misrepresented both theory and data. His hypothesis about raceExpand
The r/K theory of human individual differences: Scientific and social issues
Abstract This is a commentary on Rushton's papers on r/K theory and the criticisms they have generated. In contrast to Rushton's critics, we conclude that the r/K concept may be heuristically appliedExpand
RESTITUTION OF r- AND K-SELECTION AS A MODEL OF DENSITY-DEPENDENT NATURAL SELECTION
TLDR
It is argued that rand K-selection may have important ramifications for the understanding of life history evolution, but for the model to be useful, it must be interpreted strictly as it was originally formulated: as a model of density-dependent natural selection. Expand
Race differences in sexuality and their correlates: Another look and physiological models
Abstract Lynn (1989) rejects the r K theory of race differences, claiming that (a) r K analyses do not apply to large mammals like man; (b) the races do not really differ on attributes such asExpand
A critique of Rushton on race, brain size and intelligence
Abstract A critique is presented of that portion of Rushton's theory on the role of race in heritable behavior that deals with race, brain size, and intelligence. The critique is based on anExpand
The reality of racial differences: A rejoinder with new evidence
Abstract The criticisms of my race differences paper are considered within the following questions: (1) Do the racial differences exist as described or are they due entirely to faulty measurement orExpand
Race Differences in Sexual Behavior: A Critique of Rushton and Bogaert’s Evolutionary Hypothesis
Rushton and Bogaert (1987) presented evidence of race differences in sexual behavior, sex-related physical characteristics, and sex-related physiological processes. They argued that these dataExpand
DO r-K STRATEGIES UNDERLIE HUMAN RACE DIFFERENCES? A REPLY TO WEIZMANN ET AL.
Data are tabulated showing that on diverse traits including brain size and intelligence, maturational delay, sexual restraint, quiescent temperament, and social organization, the Caucasoid averageExpand
...
1
2
3
4
...