Roadblock to Innovation: The Role of Patent Litigation in Corporate R&D

  title={Roadblock to Innovation: The Role of Patent Litigation in Corporate R\&D},
  author={Filippo Mezzanotti},
The recent spike in patent litigation raises concerns about the ability of the current intellectual property system to effectively promote innovation. Using a difference-in-difference design around the 2006 Supreme Court decision ?eBay vs. MercExchange,? I examine how patent enforcement can reduce the negative effects of litigation on firms? innovation. This ruling was intended to curb abusive patent lawsuits by providing more flexibility in the way courts remedy patent violations. I estimate… Expand
Courting innovation: The effects of litigation risk on corporate innovation
  • M. Kabir Hassan, R. Houston, M. Sydul Karim
  • Business
  • Journal of Corporate Finance
  • 2021
Abstract In this study, we examine the impact of class action litigation shocks on corporate innovation. Our experimental design is based on an unanticipated court ruling that reduces the risk ofExpand
Do firms profit from patent litigation? The contingent roles of diversification and intangible assets
Abstract Prior research suggests that firms’ ability to benefit from their technologies is determined by the strength of intellectual property (IP) laws and the inimitability of their technologies.Expand
Patent policy and American innovation after eBay: An empirical examination
Abstract The 2006 Supreme Court ruling in eBay vs. MercExchange removed the presumption of injunctive relief from infringement and marked a sea change in U.S. patent policy. Subsequent legal andExpand
Patent Policy and American Innovation after eBay: An Empirical Examination
The 2006 Supreme Court ruling in eBay vs. MercExchange marked a sea change in U.S. patent policy. The eBay decision removed the presumption of injunctive relief. Subsequent legal and policy changesExpand
Innovation and Firm Dynamics with Patent Wars
I study the role of asymmetric intellectual property protection (IPP) investments, such as patent portfolios and legal teams, in shaping innovation and entry barriers. I develop a framework whichExpand
Patent wars or copycat threats? Protecting innovation & market power with patent litigation
Patents and intellectual property protection (IPP) activities vary systematically across firms and are a source of market power. I develop a tractable Schumpeterian growth model with firm dynamicsExpand
Dynamic Patent Portfolio Management
I propose a tractable model integrating dynamic internal capital allocation with imperfect patent protection, thereby endogenizing patent war as well as financing constraints. I emphasize the centralExpand
Litigating Innovation: Evidence from Securities Class Action Lawsuits
Low-quality securities class action lawsuits disproportionally target firms with valuable innovation output and lead to substantial shareholder-value losses. We establish this fact using data onExpand
Incentive Effects of Social Insurance Law on Corporate Innovation: Theory and Evidence
Whether and how the design and enforcement of laws exerts a profound influence on innovation activities has been the central subject of study in a wide spectrum of disciplines. This paper examinesExpand
Do Patents Work? Thickets, Trolls and Antibiotic Resistance
This paper connects ideas from recent literature on the economics of intellectual property (IP) to address the question: Did the strengthening and broadening of IP rights from important patent policyExpand


Does Patent Litigation Reduce Corporate R&D? An Analysis of US Public Firms
This study investigates if firms' involvement in patent litigation as alleged infringers hinders their innovation. I develop a simple model that predicts a decrease in innovation following patentExpand
Patents and Cumulative Innovation: Causal Evidence from the Courts
Cumulative innovation is central to economic growth. Do patent rights facilitate or impede follow-on innovation? We study the causal effect of removing patent rights by court invalidation onExpand
The Effect of Patent Litigation and Patent Assertion Entities on Entrepreneurial Activity
This paper empirically investigates the statistical relationship between levels of patent litigation and venture capital investment in the U.S. We find that VC investment, a major funding source forExpand
The growing problem of patent trolling
New, large-sample evidence is discussed adding to a growing literature that suggests that NPEs—in particular, large patent aggregators—on average, act as “patent trolls,” suing cash-rich firms seemingly irrespective of actual patent infringement, which has a negative impact on innovation activity at targeted firms. Expand
Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History
What is the optimal system of intellectual property rights to encourage innovation? Empirical evidence from economic history can help to inform important policy questions that have been difficult toExpand
Characteristics of patent litigation: a window on competition
We examine the patenting behavior of firms in an industry characterized by rapid technological change and cumulative innovation. Recent survey evidence suggests that semiconductor firms do not relyExpand
The Empirical Impact of Intellectual Property Rights on Innovation: Puzzles and Clues
Economists have long seen the patent system as a crucial lever through which policymak ers affect the speed and nature of innovation in the economy. It is not surprising, then, that the profoundExpand
Bankruptcy Codes and Innovation
Do legal institutions governing financial contracts affect the nature of real investments in the economy? We develop a simple model and provide evidence that the answer to this question is yes. WeExpand
Patent Protection and Innovation Over 150 Years
The paper seeks to understand the impact of the patent system on innovation by examining shifts in the strength of patent protection across sixty countries and a 150-year period. An examination ofExpand
Trolls on State Street?: The Litigation of Financial Patents, 1976-2005
This paper examines the litigation of business method patents, contrasting suggestions from the theoretical law-and-economics literature with the suggestion that entrepreneurs are obtaining and thenExpand