Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: Could Participant Self-Selection Have Led to the Cruelty?

@article{Carnahan2007RevisitingTS,
  title={Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: Could Participant Self-Selection Have Led to the Cruelty?},
  author={Thomas J. Carnahan and Sam G McFarland},
  journal={Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin},
  year={2007},
  volume={33},
  pages={603 - 614}
}
The authors investigated whether students who selectively volunteer for a study of prison life possess dispositions associated with behaving abusively. Students were recruited for a psychological study of prison life using a virtually identical newspaper ad as used in the Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE; Haney, Banks & Zimbardo, 1973) or for a psychological study, an identical ad minus the words of prison life. Volunteers for the prison study scored significantly higher on measures of the abuse… 

Tables from this paper

Revisiting the Stanford prison experiment, again: Examining demand characteristics in the guard orientation
  • J. Bartels
  • Psychology
    The Journal of social psychology
  • 2019
TLDR
The present results provide empirical support for speculation that the language of the guard orientation in the Stanford prison experiment sanctioned abuse among guards.
Rethinking the nature of cruelty: The role of identity leadership in the Stanford Prison Experiment.
TLDR
Through examination of material in the SPE archive, comprehensive evidence is presented that, rather than guards conforming to role of their own accord, experimenters directly encouraged them to adopt roles and act tough in a manner consistent with tenets of identity leadership.
Debunking the Stanford Prison Experiment.
TLDR
Data collected from a thorough investigation of the SPE archives and interviews with 15 of the participants in the experiment further question the study's scientific merit, including the biased and incomplete collection of data and the fact that participants were almost never completely immersed by the situation.
Debunking the Stanford Prison Experiment.
The Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE) is one of psychology's most famous studies. It has been criticized on many grounds, and yet a majority of textbook authors have ignored these criticisms in their
Beyond the Banality of Evil: Three Dynamics of an Interactionist Social Psychology of Tyranny
TLDR
The case is made for an interactionist approach to tyranny that explains how people are initially drawn to extreme and oppressive groups, transformed by membership in those groups, and able to gain influence over others and hence normalize oppression.
Persistent Dispositionalism in Interactionist Clothing: Fundamental Attribution Error in Explaining Prison Abuse
TLDR
The authors renew and reaffirm their original interpretation of the results and apply this perspective to some recent socially and politically significant events.
Prison, Perceptions, and Policy: Authoritarianism and Attitudes toward Sexual Assault Victims in U.S. Correctional Facilities
iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iv LIST OF TABLES vi CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 1 Prevalence of Sexual Victimization in Prisons 1 Defining Sexual Assault in Prison 2 Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA) of 2003 4
Coverage of the Stanford Prison Experiment in Introductory Psychology Courses
The present study examined the coverage of Stanford prison experiment (SPE), including criticisms of the study, in introductory psychology courses through an online survey of introductory psychology
Perceptions of Evil from Abu Ghraib:Female Prison Guards and Sexual Violence
In 2003, the world was presented with images of sexual torture from Abu Ghraib, a U.S. military prison in Iraq. For many people, part of the shock of the images was the fact that several of the
Coverage of the Stanford Prison Experiment in Introductory Psychology Textbooks
Zimbardo’s 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE), one of the most famous studies in psychology, is discussed in most introductory textbooks. The present study is concerned with the nature of this
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 76 REFERENCES
Interpersonal Dynamics in a Simulated Prison
Abstract : Interpersonal dynamics in a prison environment were studied experimentally by designing a functional simulation of a prison in which subjects role-played prisoners and guards for an
Evidence of codependency in women with an alcoholic parent: helping out Mr. Wrong.
TLDR
A conceptualization of codependency and its development, which is based largely on the writings of Karen Horney, is presented, and it was hypothesized that women with alcoholic parents would be more helpful to an experimenter portrayed as exploitive than to one portrayed as nurturant.
On rethinking the psychology of tyranny: The BBC prison study
This commentary offers a critical evaluation of the scientific legitimacy of research generated by television programming interests. It challenges the validity of claims advanced by these researchers
On rethinking the psychology of tyranny: the BBC prison study.
  • P. Zimbardo
  • Psychology
    The British journal of social psychology
  • 2006
TLDR
This commentary offers a critical evaluation of the scientific legitimacy of research generated by television programming interests and highlights the biases, fallacies and distortions in this study conducted for BBC-TV that attempted a partial replication of my earlier experiment.
Threatened egotism, narcissism, self-esteem, and direct and displaced aggression: does self-love or self-hate lead to violence?
Profiting from controversy. Lessons from the person-situation debate.
TLDR
Seven hypotheses that arose during the course of the person-situation debate, ranging from most to least pessimistic about the existence of consensual, discriminative personality traits are examined.
Understanding behavior in the Milgram obedience experiment: The role of personality, situations, and their interactions.
Among the far-reaching implications that have been drawn from Milgram's obedience research is that situations powerfully override personal dispositions as determinants of social behavior. A focused
The Altruistic Personality
The last few years have seen an increasing diversity of approaches to altruism and prosocial behavior. Numerous books have documented this healthy growth in both the English-speaking and
Debating the psychology of tyranny: fundamental issues of theory, perspective and science.
TLDR
The rejoinder focuses on responding to Zimbardo's criticisms, which turn broad discussion about the psychology of tyranny into narrow questions about the replication of prison conditions.
Trait Sympathy and Perceived Control as Predictors of Entering Sympathy-Arousing Situations
Two studies provide evidence that dispositional sympathy and perceived control interact to predict choices for and against situations likely to elicit sympathy. Sympathetic persons choosing among
...
...