• Corpus ID: 16520406

Revisiting the Dynamical Hypothesis

  title={Revisiting the Dynamical Hypothesis},
  author={Timothy van Gelder},
" There is a familiar trio of reactions by scientists to a purportedly radical hypothesis: (a) " You must be our of your mind! " , (b) " What else is new? Everybody knows that! " , and, later—if the hypothesis is still standing—(c) " Hmm. You might be on to something! " ((Dennett, 1995) p. 283) 

Figures from this paper

1. A NATURAL AFFINITY? The application of concepts from dynamical systems theory to issues in cognitive science is a growing and, I think, laudable project. Such usage has been extended from the
A Critical Reappraisal of the Dynamical Approach to Cognition
The notion of "cognition as it could be" is introduced and argued for and its value is shown in analysing the dynamicists' account of time.
Explanation in Dynamical Cognitive Science
  • J. Walmsley
  • Computer Science, Psychology
    Minds and Machines
  • 2008
First, dynamical cognitive science’s explanatory style may strengthen its links to the so-called “situated” approach to cognition, but, secondly, it may also undermine the widespread intuition that dynamics is related to emergentism in the philosophy of mind.
Emergence and reduction in dynamical cognitive science
Abstract This paper examines the widespread intuition that the dynamical approach to cognitive science is importantly related to emergentism about the mind. The explanatory practices adopted by
Questions For The Dynamicist: The Use of Dynamical Systems Theory in the Philosophy of Cognition
The main points to be addressed involve the reductive tendencies inherent in Dynamical Systems Theory, its somewhat muddled position relative to connectionism, the metaphorical nature DST-C exhibits which hinders its explanatory potential, and D ST-C's problematic account of causality.
Appraisal of certain methodologies in cognitive science based on Lakatos’s methodology of scientific research programmes
Attempts to apply the mathematical tools of dynamical systems theory to cognition in a systematic way has been well under way since the early 90s and has been recognised as a “third contender” to
Explaining the Mind: The Embodied Cognition Challenge
This thesis looks at a relatively new line of research in Cognitive Science – embodied cognition. Its relation to the computational-representational paradigm, primarily symbolicism, is extensively
Stepping off the pendulum: Why only an action-based approach can transcend the nativist–empiricist debate
Abstract We argue that the nativist–empiricist debate in developmental psychology is distorted, both theoretically and methodologically, by a shared framework of assumptions concerning the nature of
Anticipation in cybernetic systems: a case against mindless anti-representationalism
  • Lambert Schomaker
  • Computer Science
    2004 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics (IEEE Cat. No.04CH37583)
  • 2004
A review of neural representation mechanisms are given, looking at perception and motor control in biological systems, and it is illustrated that already in simple animal behaviors, simple 'representation-less' reactivity does not suffice.
From Foundations to Current Work in a One Quarter Course on Artificial Intelligence
This course provides a solid introduction to search and logic, combined with a philosophical review of classical AI, and introduces major tools and applications, including knowledge representation, reasoning under uncertainty and several forms of machine learning including neural networks.


The dynamical hypothesis in cognitive science.
According to the dominant computational approach in cognitive science, cognitive agents are digital computers; according to the alternative approach, they are dynamical systems. This target article
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
A good book may have the power to change the way we see the world, but a great book actually becomes part of our daily consciousness, pervading our thinking to the point that we take it for granted,
Cognitive dynamics: A psychological perspective
Although cognitive psychology is still dominated by computational theories, there is an emerging emphasis on dynamical aspects of cognition. Examples are provided supporting the increased use of
Cognition poised at the edge of chaos: A complex alternative to a symbolic mind
It is argued that a brain operating at the edge of chaos could generate high‐complexity cognition in this way, and if this hypothesis is correct, then the symbolic processing methodology in cognitive science faces serious obstacles.
Computer science as empirical inquiry: symbols and search
Computer science is the study of the phenomena surrounding computers; the machine—not just the hardware, but the programmed, living machine—is the organism the authors study.
Disentangling dynamics, computation, and cognition
Framing the debate between computational and dynamical approaches to cognition
  • Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • 1998
More boulders of confusion
  • Behavioral and Brain Sciences
forthcoming) More boulders of confusion
  • Behavioral and Brain Sciences