Revisiting Francis Galton's Forecasting Competition

  title={Revisiting Francis Galton's Forecasting Competition},
  author={Kenneth Frank Wallis},
  journal={arXiv: Methodology},
  • K. Wallis
  • Published 1 August 2014
  • Economics
  • arXiv: Methodology
This note reexamines the data from a weight-judging competition described in an article by Francis Galton published in 1907. Following the correction of some errors, it is shown that this forecasting competition is an interesting precursor of two more recent developments in the statistical forecasting literature. One is forecast combination, with the mean forecast here exactly coinciding with the outcome, and the second is the use of two-piece frequency and probability distributions to describe… 

Figures from this paper

Combining expert‐adjusted forecasts

It is shown that combined expert-adjusted model forecasts can improve on combined model forecasts, in the case when the individual expert- adjusted forecasts are not better than their associated model-based forecasts.

On the efficacy of the wisdom of crowds to forecast economic indicators

The interest in the wisdom of crowds stems mainly from the possibility of combining independent forecasts from experts in the hope that many expert minds are better than a few. Hence the relevant

Wisdom of crowds: much ado about nothing

The federal reserve bank of Philadelphia’s survey of professional forecasters database is used to confront the statistical and psychophysical explanations of the wisdom of crowds, finding that the data do not support any of the proposed explanations.

Prediction diversity and selective attention in the wisdom of crowds

The results of three experiments are reported to probe the current understanding of the wisdom of crowds, namely, the estimates of the number of candies in a jar, the length of a paper strip and thenumber of pages of a book, finding that the collective estimate is better than the majority of the individual estimates in all three experiments.

Forecasting AI Progress: Evidence from a Survey of Machine Learning Researchers

A large survey of AI and machine learning (ML) researchers on their beliefs about progress in AI shows that, in aggregate, AI/ML researchers surveyed placed a 50% likelihood of human-level machine intelligence being achieved by 2060, suggesting more optimism about AI progress.

Why Model Averaging

Model averaging is a means of allowing for model uncertainty in estimation which can provide better estimates and more reliable confidence intervals than model selection. We illustrate its use via

General Equilibrium Theory with Incomplete Information: The Wisdom of Crowds and Efficient Markets

I study general equilibrium theory with incomplete information. When agents are not fully informed, they can end up purchasing a bundle of goods that is far from optimal. General equilibrium theory

Does Permitting Uncertain Estimates Help or Hinder the Wisdom of Crowds?

This paper adds to a growing body of research into the practical utility of using interval-valued (IV) response modes to efficiently capture richer quantitative data from people— e.g., through



Darwin, Galton and the Statistical Enlightenment

Summary.  On September 10th, 1885, Francis Galton ushered in a new era of Statistical Enlightenment with an address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science in Aberdeen. In the

The Combination of Forecasts

Two separate sets of forecasts of airline passenger data have been combined to form a composite set of forecasts. The main conclusion is that the composite set of forecasts can yield lower

Galton's Two Papers on Voting as Robust Estimation

The relationship between voting and robust estimation was discussed by Francis Galton in 1907. His two papers in Nature are discussed and reprinted.

A Generalized Asymmetric Student-t Distribution with Application to Financial Econometrics

This paper proposes a new class of asymmetric Student-t (AST) distributions, and investigates its properties, gives procedures for estimation, and indicates applications in financial econometrics. We

The Two-Piece Normal, Binormal, or Double Gaussian Distribution: Its Origin and Rediscoveries

This paper traces the history of the two-piece normal distribution from its origin in the posthumous Kollektivmasslehre (1897) of Gustav Theodor Fechner to its rediscoveries and generalisations. The

The History of Statistics: The Measurement of Uncertainty before 1900

Introduction PART 1: The Development of Mathematical Statistics in Astronomy and Geodesy before 1827 1. Least Squares and the Combination of Observations Legendre in 1805 Cotes's Rule Tobias Mayer

Measuring Skewness with Respect to the Mode

Abstract There are several measures employed to quantify the degree of skewness of a distribution. These have been based on the expectations or medians of the distributions considered. In 1964, van

Vox Populi

IN these democratic days, any investigation into the the trustworthiness and peculiarities of popular judgments is of interest. The material about to be discussed refers to a small matter, but is

Memories of My Life

THOSE who are interested in the history of the growth of science in this country and in the men who participated in its development will thank Dr. Galton for having provided them with a

The Wisdom of Crowds