• Corpus ID: 17716440

Rethinking Critical Editions of Fragmentary Texts by Ontologies

@inproceedings{Berti2009RethinkingCE,
  title={Rethinking Critical Editions of Fragmentary Texts by Ontologies},
  author={Monica Berti and Federico Boschetti and Gregory R. Crane and Matteo Romanello and Alison Babeu},
  booktitle={ELPUB},
  year={2009}
}
This paper discusses the main issues encountered in the design of a domain ontology to represent ancient literary texts that survive only in fragments, i.e. through quotations embedded in other texts. The design approach presented in the paper combines a knowledge domain analysis conducted through semantic spaces with the integration of well established ontologies and the application of ontology design patterns. After briefy describing the specifc meaning of “fragment” in a literary context… 

Figures from this paper

Citations and annotations in classics: old problems and new perspectives
TLDR
HuCit is presented, an ontology that models in depth the semantics of canonical citations, and how HuCit's machine-generated citation data can be expressed as annotations by using the Open Annotation Collaboration (OAC) ontology, to the aim of increasing reuse and semantic interoperability.
Presenting Fragments as Quotations or Quotations as Fragments
In this paper, we shall present some reflections on issues that arise when scholars prepare new editions of fragmentarily preserved works from antiquity. Our focus will be on those fragments that are
Editorializing the Greek Anthology: The palatin manuscript as a collective imaginary
TLDR
This project aims to further develop this edition of the Palatine Anthology, thereby demonstrating the philological, editorial and pedagogic challenges involved in compiling the diverse fragments of this collection of Greek epigrams and shed light on the many ways to engage with textual objects.
Why are there no comprehensively digital scholarly editions of classical texts
1. By a “comprehensively digital” scholarly edition, I mean here one based (1) on a complete digital transcription of all primary sources and (2) on an automated collation of those transcriptions –
DHQ: Digital Humanities Quarterly
The Palatine Anthology (PA) Project, coordinated by the Canada Research Chair on digital textualities directed by Marcello Vitali-Rosati, collaborates with several international partners, including
Works, Documents, Texts and Related Resources for Everyone
TLDR
This paper reports on a scheme prepared by the authors, designed to provide a solution to the problems proposed in both interoperability and encoding, and to advance interoperability, long a problem area in electronic texts.
The Corpus of the Greek Medical Papyri and a New Concept of Digital Critical Edition
TLDR
A digital critical edition is defined as the digital output of a philological work, aimed at reproducing the original text as most exactly as possible, or, in other terms, as the fixed representation of a scholar's more or less trustable opinion on that text.
Digital Philology: : New Thoughts on Old Questions
Currently, no ‘canonical’ classical text with a multi-testimonial tradition has a digital scholarly edition based on a complete digital transcription of all primary sources, and on the automated
The Digital Critical Edition of Fragments : Theoretical Problems and Technical Solutions
The process of creating a digital critical edition of fragmentary texts is also a valuable op- portunity to look at the nature of such texts under a new light. This paper contains some reflections
Marcus Antonius’ Funeral Oration for Iulius Caesar: Fragments and Testimonies in Classical Literature: Modes of Citation and Representation
Marcus Antonius' lost works serve as instructive case studies to review ancient citing practices. His eulogy in honour of Iulius Caesar, the exchange of political invective with Cicero, and the war
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 38 REFERENCES
ScholOnto: an ontology-based digital library server for research documents and discourse
TLDR
The design rationale and implementation of ScholOnto is described, an ontology-based digital library server to support scholarly interpretation and discourse that enables researchers to describe and debate via a semantic network the contributions a document makes, and its relationship to the literature.
Capturing knowledge about philosophy
TLDR
The design of the ontology is described, in particular focusing on the solutions the authors have devised to address the modelling problems and natural language ambiguities, which occur when capturing knowledge in a domain as complex as that of philosophy.
Semantic Interoperability in Archaeological Datasets: Data Mapping and Extraction Via the CIDOC CRM
TLDR
A semi-automatic mapping/extraction tool proved an essential component and the viability of the approach is demonstrated by web services and a client application on an integrated data and concept network.
Ontology Learning from Text: Methods, Evaluation and Applications
TLDR
This volume presents current research in ontology learning, addressing three perspectives, including methodologies that have been proposed to automatically extract information from texts and to give a structured organization to such knowledge, including approaches based on machine learning techniques.
Collecting fragmentary authors in a digital library
TLDR
Initial work to represent, in a digital library of classical sources, authors whose works themselves are lost and who survive only where surviving authors quote, paraphrase or allude to them is described.
Integrating data from The Perseus Project and Arachne using the CIDOC CRM An Examination from a Software Developer ’ s Perspective
In a joint effort The Perseus Project, a digital library project hosted at Tufts University and Arachne, the central database for archaeological objects of the German Archaeological Institute (DAI)
Talia: A Framework for Philosophy Scholars
TLDR
Talia is a novel implementation of a semantic digital web library system which uses computational ontologies for the organisation of knowledge and enables data interoperability and new paradigms for information enrichment, data-retrieval and navigation.
Methods to extend Greek and Latin corpora with variants and conjectures Mapping critical apparatuses onto reference text Dr
The principal corpora currently available in classical literature, while quite thorough, are based on authoritative editions without critical apparatuses. However, philologists need to deal with
Content Ontology Design Patterns as Practical Building Blocks for Web Ontologies
TLDR
This paper exemplifies the described techniques with respect to the extraction of two content ontology design patterns from the DOLCE+DnS Ultra Lite ontology by showing the design of a simplified ontology for the music industry domain.
A Semantic Web Powered Distributed Digital Library System
TLDR
Talia is a innovative distributed semantic digital library, annotation and publishing system, which is specifically designed for the needs of scholarly research in humanities, strictly based on standard Semantic Web technologies and uses ontologies for the organization of knowledge.
...
...