Response to Pulvermüller: the syntax of actions and other metaphors

@article{Moro2014ResponseTP,
  title={Response to Pulverm{\"u}ller: the syntax of actions and other metaphors},
  author={Andrea Moro},
  journal={Trends in Cognitive Sciences},
  year={2014},
  volume={18}
}
  • A. Moro
  • Published 1 May 2014
  • Linguistics
  • Trends in Cognitive Sciences
Syntactic theory is also a metaphor
TLDR
It is fair to say that Pulvermuller's proposal for the action-syntax analog in full scale, while promising in its spirit, is not rigorously argued, given the elusive relation between action and syntax which underlies the inquiry.
Syntax in language and music: what is the right level of comparison?
TLDR
This paper suggests that a fruitful comparison between the two domains could benefit from taking the grammar of action into account, and suggests that what is called “syntax” can be investigated in terms of goal of action, action planning, motor control, and sensory-motor integration.
Word Order, Action, and the Brain: A Reply to Arbib
In a recent paper in this journal, I argued that the crosslinguistic prevalence of subject-object-verb and subject-verb-object word orders reflects the sequential and hierarchical representation of
The integration hypothesis of human language evolution and the nature of contemporary languages
TLDR
Empirical evidence is provided by showing that certain processes found in contemporary languages that have been characterized as non-finite state in nature can in fact be shown to be finite-state.
Syntax in Action Has Priority over Movement Selection in Piano Playing: An ERP Study
TLDR
The current data support the hypothesis that motor plans operate at the level of musical syntax and are incrementally translated to lower levels of movement selection.
Why only us: Recent questions and answers
Neanderthal Language
Did Neanderthals have language, and if so, what was it like? Scientists agree overall that the behaviour and cognition of Neanderthals resemble that of early modern humans in important ways. However,
The Ontogenesis of Action Syntax
TLDR
It is elaborate on the claim that adding an ontogenetic approach will help to obtain a comprehensive picture about both the interplay between language and action and its development, and to answer the question whether the underlying mechanisms of detecting syntactic violations of action sequences are similar to or different from the processing of language Syntactic violations.
Distinct brain signatures of content and structure violation during action observation
...
1
2
3
4
...

References

SHOWING 1-9 OF 9 REFERENCES
Three models for the description of language
TLDR
It is found that no finite-state Markov process that produces symbols with transition from state to state can serve as an English grammar, and the particular subclass of such processes that produce n -order statistical approximations to English do not come closer, with increasing n, to matching the output of anEnglish grammar.
The Equilibrium of Human Syntax: Symmetries in the Brain
TLDR
Part 1: Symmetry (Breaking) in Syntax: Toward a Unified theory of copular sentences; part 2: The Boundaries of Babel: How the Brain Shapes Grammars.
Finitary models of language users
TLDR
It is proposed to describe talkers and listeners to describe the users of language rather than the language itself, just as the authors' knowledge of arithmetic is not merely the collection of their arithmetic responses, habits, or dispositions.
The Boundaries of Babel: The Brain and the Enigma of Impossible Languages
TLDR
This second edition of The Boundaries of Babel includes a new chapter in which Andrea Moro extends the exploration of the boundaries of Babel in search of the source of order with which all human languages are endowed.
Evolution, brain, and the nature of language