Resistance to Ohm's Law

@article{Schagrin1963ResistanceTO,
  title={Resistance to Ohm's Law},
  author={Morton L. Schagrin},
  journal={American Journal of Physics},
  year={1963},
  volume={31},
  pages={536-547}
}
  • M. Schagrin
  • Published 1 July 1963
  • Education
  • American Journal of Physics
It is argued that the usual account of the discovery and subsequent rejection, or criticism, of Ohm's law is both a misleading and an inadequate explanation. A close logical examination of Ohm's experimental work reveals a conceptual structure quite different from that of the electrical science of his time. As a result of this analysis, it is claimed that the conceptual shift in Ohm's experimental work was the basis for the reaction of his contemporaries. 
View via Publisher
physics.rutgers.edu
30 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
1
Background Citations
4

30 Citations

Georg Simon Ohm and Ohm's Law
TLDR
A short biographical sketch of Ohm and a discussion of his experimental and theoretical work on electrical conduction in metals is given and the law is examined from a modern viewpoint.
From successful measurement to the birth of a law: Disentangling coordination in Ohm's scientific practice.
  • M. Luchetti
  • Philosophy
    Studies in history and philosophy of science
  • 2020
A Law of Physics in the Classroom: The Case of Ohm’s Law
Difficulties in learning Ohm’s Law suggest a need to refocus it from the law for a part of the circuit to the law for the whole circuit. Such a revision may improve understanding of Ohm’s Law and its…
Laboratory Notes, Laboratory Experiences, and Conceptual Analysis: Understanding the Making of Ohm's First Law in Electricity.
TLDR
The conceptual background of Ohm's work is discussed, concluding that he was significantly influenced by French studies in the field of electricity, most notably the ones by Charles Augustin Coulomb.
Modern analogue of Ohm’s historical experiment
Students receive a more complete conception of scientific cognition methods if they reproduce fundamentally important historical investigations on their own. Ohm’s investigation realized in 1826 is…
Theory Choice and Resistance to Change
  • A. Lugg
  • Philosophy
    Philosophy of Science
  • 1980
The object of this paper is twofold: to show that resistance to scientific change on the part of scientists need signal neither irrationality nor the presence of extra-scientific influences; and to…
Electrical and Electrochemical Studies
The first decade of the nineteenth century saw the physical sciences permeated by the entirely new field of research stimulated by the discovery of the Voltaic battery. In those same years Avogadro,…
Errors in Science and their Treatment in Teaching Science
This paper analyses the real origin and nature of scientific errors against claims of science critics, by examining a number of examples from the history of electricity and optics. This analysis…
Didactic Problems in the Concept of Electric Potential Difference and an Analysis of its Philogenesis
This paper makes an analysis of the different didactic problems to come from the fact that electric charge is inseparable from the mass, the impossibility of its direct observation (only its effects)…
Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge: Reflections on my Critics
1. Introduction. 2. Methodology: the role of history and sociology . 3. Normal Science: its nature and functions . 4. Normal Science: its retrieval from history . 5. Irrationality and Theory-Choice .…
...
...