Resistance of personal risk perceptions to debiasing interventions.

@article{Weinstein1995ResistanceOP,
  title={Resistance of personal risk perceptions to debiasing interventions.},
  author={Neil D. Weinstein and William M. P. Klein},
  journal={Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association},
  year={1995},
  volume={14 2},
  pages={
          132-40
        }
}
  • N. Weinstein, W. Klein
  • Published 1995
  • Medicine
  • Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association
The tendency to believe that one's own risk is less than that of others may reduce interest in health-protective behaviors. This article describes 4 attempts to reduce such optimistic biases. In Study 1, New Jersey residents (N = 222) were provided with lists of risk factors for several health problems. This manipulation was strengthened in Study 2 by presenting risk factors in such a way that participants (164 undergraduates) might see their own standing as inferior to that of others. In Study… Expand

Topics from this paper

MAINTAINING SELF-SERVING SOCIAL COMPARISONS: ATTENUATING THE PERCEIVED SIGNIFICANCE OF RISK-INCREASING BEHAVIORS
Unrealistic optimism about future events is due in part to the belief that one’s behavior is less risky than that of one’s peers. The current investigation explores strategies that people use toExpand
Personal Fable: Optimistic Bias in Cigarette Smokers
TLDR
It is hypothesized that smokers develop optimistic illusions, able to facilitate the adoption and the maintenance over time of the unhealthy lifestyles, such as cigarette smoking, and the former smokers could acquire a belief system centered on own responsibility. Expand
On Being More Amenable to Threatening Risk Messages Concerning Close Others (vis-à-vis the Self)
TLDR
Whether people are more amenable to risk messages impugning a close other’s behavior is explored, and participants learned how being overweight could influence their own cancer risk or that of an opposite-sex close other. Expand
Pessimistic Bias in Comparative Evaluations: A Case of Perceived Vulnerability to the Effects of Negative Life Events
This study tested the hypothesis that unrealistic pessimism characterizes comparative estimates of coping ability. Participants rated their ability to adjust to a range of negative life events inExpand
Resisting Good News: Reactions to Breast Cancer Risk Communication
TLDR
Why comparison anchors might be important in risk feedback situations is discussed and recommendations for professionals who wish to provide accurate risk information and have patients adopt that information are recommended. Expand
The impact of a 'looming vulnerability' manipulation on perceptions of risk, intentions and behaviour among harmful drinkers
Overview This thesis explores the effectiveness of attempts to increase risk perceptions among at-risk groups. Part one provides a meta-analytic review examining the efficacy of manipulations aimedExpand
Correlates of unrealistic risk beliefs in a nationally representative sample
TLDR
Factors associated with unrealistic optimism (UO) and unrealistic pessimism (UP) about breast cancer were characterized and population segments that are already vulnerable to negative health outcomes displayed more UP than less vulnerable populations. Expand
Use of correlational data to examine the effects of risk perceptions on precautionary behavior
Abstract The idea that perceptions of high personal risk lead people to adopt precautionary behavior (the “motivational hypothesis”) is mainly tested with correlational data. A review of studies fromExpand
A Uniqueness to Personal Threat (UPT) Hypothesis: How Similarity Affects Perceptions of Susceptibility and Severity in Risk Assessment
TLDR
Questions are asked how perceptions of relative severity/susceptibility differ as a function of perceived similarity between oneself and a referent and how this affects individuals' assessment of overall risk and personal identity. Expand
Self-esteem and the relation between risk behavior and perceptions of vulnerability to unplanned pregnancy in college women.
This article reports 2 studies testing the hypothesis that individuals with high self-esteem are more likely than those with low self-esteem to interpret information about their personalExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 1,147 REFERENCES
Effects of reviewing risk-relevant behavior on perceived vulnerability among women marines.
  • M. Gerrard, F. Gibbons, T. Warner
  • Medicine
  • Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association
  • 1991
TLDR
The results indicated that review of pregnancy-related behaviors decreased perceived vulnerability among two groups of subjects: those who considered unplanned pregnancy to be most undesirable and those who had the most confidence in the efficacy of their contraceptive behavior. Expand
A Better World or a Shattered Vision? Changes in Life Perspectives Following Victimization
Previous research has separately documented positive (Taylor, 1983) and negative (Janoff-Bulman, 1989) changes in beliefs following victimization. An integration of these literatures is proposed,Expand
Absolute and Relative Biases in Estimations of Personal Risk
Two studies examined the accuracy of personal risk estimates, as determined by comparing mean estimates made by college students with population statistics for college-educated individuals. Study 1Expand
Egocentrism as a Source of Unrealistic Optimism
People tend to expect misfortunes to happen to others, not to themselves. College students (n = 76) who compared their own chances of experiencing 6 negative events with the chances of theirExpand
Maintaining Self-Serving Social Comparisons: Biased Reconstruction of One's Past Behaviors
People believe that they perform fewer health-threatening behaviors than their average peer Men such beliefs were challenged by information about the actual average behavior frequencies reported byExpand
What Risks Are People Concerned About
An unusual questionnaire was used to explore what risks concern laypeople. It asked respondents to list, in their own words, as many risks of personal concern as they could. They then selected theExpand
Perceptions of Vulnerability to Pregnancy and the Use of Effective Contraception
A study was conducted to determine (a) whether the lower pregnancy risk that sexually active college women attribute to themselves relative to "average"others results from underestimating their ownExpand
Increasing Women's Calcium Intake: The Role of Health Beliefs, Intentions, and Health Value1
Undergraduate women who varied in how much they valued health were exposed to written communications persuading them of their vulnerability to osteoporosis and of the effectiveness of a recommendedExpand
Unrealistic optimism about future life events
Two studies investigated the tendency of people to be unrealistically optimistic about future life events. In Study 1, 258 college students estimated how much their own chances of experiencing 42Expand
It Could Be Worse: Selective Evaluation as a Response to Victimization
A theory of victims' responses to their victimization, termed Selective Evaluation, is proposed. It is maintained that the perception that one is a victim and the belief that others perceive one as aExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...