Resist the negation reflex: Minimizing reactance in psychotherapy of delusions

  title={Resist the negation reflex: Minimizing reactance in psychotherapy of delusions},
  author={Kyle Arnold and J. Vakhrusheva},
  pages={166 - 175}
It is widely believed that it is countertherapeutic to confront delusions, but the underlying reasons why have not been clearly conceptualized. The present paper endeavors to clarify both (1) why confronting delusions is countertherapeutic, and (2) why therapists can feel tempted to do so. People experiencing delusions can elicit an automatic reaction in the disbelieving therapist that can be termed the negation reflex. The therapist may feel compelled to negate or disconfirm the patient’s… Expand
Is delusional imperviousness a backfire effect of being disbelieved?
A central problem of delusions is their imperviousness to counterargument. Although several existing theories account for aspects of delusional imperviousness, they omit the context of socialExpand
A 50-Year Review of Psychological Reactance Theory: Do Not Read This Article
Psychological reactance theory (PRT; Brehm, 1966) posits that when something threatens or eliminates people’s freedom of behavior, they experience psychological reactance, a motivational state thatExpand
How is paranoia experienced in a student population? A qualitative study of students scoring highly on a paranoia measure
Key aspects of the findings discussed in the context of the literature include paranoia as a threat heuristic; the role of internal and external dialogues; the influence of gender on content; and the importance of meaning in life as a coping resource. Expand
Should Trackable Pill Technologies Be Used to Facilitate Adherence Among Patients Without Insight?
The use of "trackable" pills and other "smart" drugs or nanodrugs assumes renewed importance given that physicians are responsible for determining patients' decision-making capacity and informed consent for such nanoddrugs. Expand


A cognitive investigation of schizophrenic delusions.
The following investigation was motivated by a desire to understand more clearly how some overtly delusional patients come to lose their delusions during the course of treatment for schizophrenia. Expand
Cognitive therapy of delusional beliefs.
The adaptation of cognitive therapy to the treatment of delusions is described, with special attention to the following issues: special problems in collaboration; difficulties in obtaining conviction ratings; how to avoid and reduce confrontation through the Socratic method; the collaborative design of homework experiments; interpersonal relationship issues; and the necessity to identify and explore the emotions associated with the various delusions. Expand
Confrontation vs. belief modification in persistently deluded patients.
Examining the effects of two contrasting types of verbal intervention in a larger sample of persistently deluded patients predicted that both interventions will reduce the strength of delusions and confrontation will produce less change in delusions and any associated behavioural abnormalities than belief modification. Expand
Developing Treatments of Persistent Persecutory Delusions: The Impact of an Emotional Processing and Metacognitive Awareness Intervention
Preliminary findings suggest that simply encouraging patients to talk, in the right way, about their delusions can be beneficial, and that enhancing emotional processing of paranoid experiences will reduce distress. Expand
Cognitive Therapy for Delusions, Voices and Paranoia
PAUL CHADWICK, MAX BIRCHWOOD, AND PETER TROWER: Cognitive Therapy for Delusions, Voices and Paranoia. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, England, 1996, 210 pp., $55.00, ISBN 0-471-93888-2. It may seemExpand
Reasoning, emotions, and delusional conviction in psychosis.
There was evidence that belief inflexibility mediated the relationship between jumping to conclusions and delusional conviction, and anxiety, but not depression, made an independent contribution to delusional conviction. Expand
Vulnerable self, poor understanding of others' minds, threat anticipation and cognitive biases as triggers for delusional experience in schizophrenia: a theoretical model.
An analysis of the literature is offered, illustrated with clinical observations, suggesting that persecutory delusions are triggered during stressful intersubjective transactions by the interactions of an alteration in empathetic perspective taking and in pragmatic understanding of others' minds. Expand
The self, attributional processes and abnormal beliefs: towards a model of persecutory delusions.
An integrative model is proposed to account for findings that it is hypothesized that, in deluded patients, activation of self/ideal discrepancies by threat-related information triggers defensive explanatory biases, which have the function of reducing the self/Ideal discrepancies but result in persecutory ideation. Expand
The effect of state anxiety on paranoid ideation and jumping to conclusions. An experimental investigation.
Evidence is provided for an interaction of anxiety and reasoning biases in the development of paranoid beliefs and a combination of meta-cognitive training directed at reasoning biases and promoting emotion regulation skills might prove beneficial in preventing symptoms. Expand
Countertransference in Defense Enactments
  • F. Busch
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association
  • 2006
A clinical term is introduced to capture a defense that develops with the patient's deepening but fleeting awareness of painful transference feelings, and an attempt is made to distinguish defense enactments from other types of defenses, and to differentiate the analyst's countertransference reaction to this type of defense fromcountertransference reactions that might appear similar. Expand