Resampling measures of group support: a reply to Grant and Kluge

@article{Ramirez2005ResamplingMO,
  title={Resampling measures of group support: a reply to Grant and Kluge},
  author={Martina Ramirez},
  journal={Cladistics},
  year={2005},
  volume={21}
}
Grant and Kluge (2003) associated resampling measures of group support with the aim of evaluating statistical stability, confidence, or the probability of recovering a true phylogenetic group. This interpretation is not necessary to methods such as jackknifing or bootstrapping, which are better interpreted as measures of support from the current dataset. Grant and Kluge only accepted the absolute Bremer value as a measure of group support, and considered resampling methods as irrelevant to… Expand
Clade support measures and their adequacy
In addition to hypothesis optimality, the evaluation of clade (group, edge, split, node) support is an important aspect of phylogenetic analysis. Here we clarify the logical relationship betweenExpand
Behaviour of resampling methods under different weighting schemes, measures and variable resampling strengths
We compared general behaviour trends of resampling methods (bootstrap, bootstrap with Poisson distribution, jackknife, and jackknife with symmetric resampling) and different ways to summarize theExpand
Why some clades have low bootstrap frequencies and high Bayesian posterior probabilities
Bayesian posterior probabilities are wrongly considered by many systematists as indicative of character support, and equivalent to non-parametric bootstrap frequencies. Here I argue against thisExpand
Why some clades have low bootstrap frequencies and high Bayesian posterior probabilities
Bayesian posterior probabilities are wrongly considered by many systematists as indicative of character support, and equivalent to non-parametric bootstrap frequencies. Here I argue against thisExpand
Phylogenetic relationships of yellowjackets inferred from nine loci (Hymenoptera: Vespidae, Vespinae, Vespula and Dolichovespula).
TLDR
The results agree with previous studies regarding the monophyly of the Vespula vulgaris group and the sister relationship between the V. rufa and V. squamosa groups, and indicate that a yellowjacket clade is either weakly supported (parsimony) or rejected (Bayesian inference). Expand
Total evidence and sensitivity phylogenetic analyses of egg‐brooding frogs (Anura: Hemiphractidae)
We study the phylogenetic relationships of egg‐brooding frogs, a group of 118 neotropical species, unique among anurans by having embryos with large bell‐shaped gills and females carrying their eggsExpand
Vastly underestimated species richness of Amazonian salamanders (Plethodontidae: Bolitoglossa) and implications about plethodontid diversification.
TLDR
The results revealed a clade including almost all Amazonian salamanders, with a topology incompatible with just the currently recognized nine species, which suggested a stepping-stone colonization of the Amazonian lowlands from Central America through the Chocó and the Andes, with several late dispersals from Amazonia back into the AndES. Expand
A revision of the New World eximius lineage of Anelosimus (Araneae, Theridiidae) and a phylogenetic analysis using worldwide exemplars
TLDR
A revision of the New World ‘eximius lineage’ containing the most intensely studied Anelosimus species, and a phylogenetic study including worldwide exemplars, corroborate previous findings of convergent evolution of permanent sociality in the genus. Expand
Integrative taxonomy reveals a new but common Neotropical treefrog, hidden under the name Boana xerophylla.
TLDR
This study is an empirical example regarding false negatives behind genetic thresholds for species discovery, appraising the use of integrative taxonomic approaches and naming and describing Boana platanera sp. Expand
Phylogenetics And Molecular Evolution Of Highly Eusocial Wasps
TLDR
The findings of this study challenge the predominant understanding of evolutionary relationships in the Vespinae and show that yellowjacket genera are not sister lineages, instead recovering Dolichovespula as more closely related to the hornets, and placing Vespula as sister to all other vespine genera. Expand
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 19 REFERENCES
Data exploration in phylogenetic inference: scientific, heuristic, or neither
TLDR
It is concluded that undue emphasis has been placed on data exploration in phylogenetic inference, and phylogeneticists are urged to consider more carefully the relevance of the methods that they employ. Expand
Improvements to resampling measures of group support
Several aspects of current resampling methods to assess group support are reviewed. When the characters have different prior weights or some state transformation costs are different, the frequenciesExpand
Assessing progress in systematics with continuous jackknife function analysis.
TLDR
Convergence of data on a reference tree does not guarantee historical accuracy, but it does predict that the accumulation of further data under the sampling model will not lead to rapid changes in the hypothesis. Expand
RASA Attributes Highly Significant Structure to Randomized Data
TLDR
The claim that RASA is a deductive procedure is unfounded and seems to have been used as part of a strategy for avoiding tests of the method. Expand
Sophisticated falsification and research cycles: Consequences for differential character weighting in phylogenetic systematics
TLDR
On balance, phylogenetic systematics appears to achieve greater coherence and generality as a result of focusing on the foundations for claiming increased knowledge and avoiding efforts to differentially weight characters. Expand
Methods for Quick Consensus Estimation
A method that allows estimating consensus trees without exhaustive searches is described. The method consists of comparing the results of different independent superficial searches. The results ofExpand
Long‐Branch Abstractions
TLDR
It is asserted, long‐branch attraction cannot explain the presence of nematocysts in Myxozoa and halteres in Strepsiptera, and it is suggested that maximum likelihood methods are extremely sensitive to taxon and character sampling and that these data sets are demonstrative of the long-branch repulsion problem. Expand
BRANCH SUPPORT AND TREE STABILITY
Abstract— Branch support is quantified as the extra length needed to lose a branch in the consensus of near‐most‐parsimonious trees. This approach is based solely on the original data, as opposed toExpand
THE SPIDER SUBFAMILY AMAUROBIOIDINAE (ARANEAE, ANYPHAENIDAE): A PHYLOGENETIC REVISION AT THE GENERIC LEVEL
TLDR
A cladistic phylogenetic analysis at generic level of the subfamily Amaurobioidinae is presented, based on a dataset of 93 representative species scored for one behavioral and 199 morphological characters. Expand
Distinguishing “or” from “and” and the case for historical identification
The adequacy of a probabilistic interpretation must be judged according to the nature of the event, or thing, being inferred. For example, conditional (frequency) probability is not admissible in theExpand
...
1
2
...