Reports, politics, and intelligence failures: The case of Iraq

@article{Jervis12006ReportsPA,
  title={Reports, politics, and intelligence failures: The case of Iraq},
  author={Robert Jervis 1},
  journal={Journal of Strategic Studies},
  year={2006},
  volume={29},
  pages={3 - 52}
}
  • Robert Jervis 1
  • Published 1 February 2006
  • Political Science
  • Journal of Strategic Studies
Abstract The intelligence failure concerning Iraqi weapons of mass destruction (WMD) has been the center of political controversy and official investigations in three countries. This article reviews the Report on the U.S. Intelligence Community's Prewar Intelligence Assessments on Iraq, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, 7 July 2004, Review of Intelligence on Weapons of Mass Destruction, a Report of a Committee of Privy Councillors to the House of Commons, 14 July 2004 (the Butler Report… 
16 Citations
Politics is not everything: New perspectives on the public disclosure of intelligence by states
  • Ofek Riemer
  • Political Science
    Contemporary Security Policy
  • 2021
ABSTRACT Why do states deliberately disclose hard-earned intelligence? For political and operational reasons, Official Public Intelligence Disclosure (OPID) is often considered counterintuitive and
‘Remember Iraq!’ Learning theory and the 2013 non-decision on air strikes against Syria
Statesmen sometimes seek to legitimize contemporary foreign policy decisions by referring to a ‘historical lesson’, derived from an allegedly analogous situation in the past. According to foreign
Red Team or Red Herring? Lessons Learned from the Policy Counter Terrorism Evaluation Group
  • John P. Moran
  • Political Science
    The International Journal of Intelligence, Security, and Public Affairs
  • 2021
ABSTRACT This article examines the activities and controversies of the Policy Counter Terrorism Evaluation Group (PCTEG) within the context of the 1976 “B Team” competitive analysis exercise. While
Conspiracy theories in Russian security thinking
ABSTRACT Based on an analysis of around 500 texts from security-affiliated Russian academic journals and one newspaper over a ten-year period, this article details how conspiratorial ideas are
Waiting for advice that is beyond doubt: uncertainty as Australia’s reason to join the invasion of Iraq
ABSTRACT A dominant theme across examinations of the intelligence used to justify invading Iraq in 2003 is that political decision-makers amplified the clarity of their evidence. What has been missed
Separating isotope facts from fallacies: nuclear weapons proliferation in the eyes of three intelligence communities
ABSTRACT Separating Isotope Facts from Fallacies compares how intelligence agencies have performed in assessing the nuclear proliferation intentions of other countries. Using original archival and
Post factum clarity: failure to identify spontaneous threats
  • Rotem Dvir
  • Political Science
    Intelligence and National Security
  • 2018
ABSTRACT This study explores an information interpretation explanation of strategic surprises using a non-traditional national security threat: a popular uprising. To explain why this type of
Detecting the need for change: How the British Army adapted to warfare on the Western Front and in the Southern Cameroons
Abstract This article addresses a gap in the literature on military adaptation by focusing on the first step in the adaptive process: detecting failure. We argue that institutionalised feedback loops
The Role of Strategic Intelligence in the Post-Everything Age
  • José-Miguel Palacios
  • Computer Science
    The International Journal of Intelligence, Security, and Public Affairs
  • 2018
TLDR
Intelligence, in general, and strategic intelligence, in particular, are having difficulties to adapt to a new world where objectives are different and the rules of the game are continuously changing.
The “analysis of competing hypotheses” in intelligence analysis
The intelligence community uses "structured analytic techniques" to help analysts think critically and avoid cognitive bias. However, little evidence exists of how techniques are applied and whether
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 99 REFERENCES
Knowing Your Friends : Intelligence Inside Alliances and Coalitions from 1914 to the Cold War
Foreign Affairs, Vol. 78, No. 2 "[An] excellent collection of articles from Intelligence and National Security, the premier journal of intelligence studies." Military Review -" These essays are far
Still a Matter of Trust: Post–9/11 British Intelligence and Political Culture
Historically, the British public’s attitude toward the United Kingdom’s intelligence services has been marked by a pronounced ambivalence. Popular culture has fed into and had an impact on this
The 9/11 Commission Report: A Review Essay
National Commission on Terrorist Attacks upon the United States (New York: W.W. Norton, 2004) Nine days after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Lt. Gen. Walter Short, the U.S. Army commander in
Inside CIA's private world : declassified articles from the agency's internal journal, 1955-1992
TLDR
This book discusses the history of intelligence analysis in the United States, as well as current issues such as the "not-So-Secret war, or How State-CIA Squabbling Hurts US Intelligence Assessing DDO Human Source Reporting".
A weak pillar for American national security: The CIA's dismal performance against WMD threats
American preemptive or preventive military action against WMD-armed adversaries in the future will simply not be feasible without high-quality and timely intelligence. But is American intelligence up
Analyzing Israel's Intelligence Failures
Intelligence failures are common phenomena among intelligence communities. Not surprisingly, the Israeli intelligence community has frequently failed in its strategic assessments as well as in its
The Perils of Shallow Theory: Intelligence Reform and the 9/11 Commission
Despite its unique influence on the current reorganization of American intelligence, the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks on the United States (the 9=11 Commission) got it wrong. In examining
Intelligence culture and intelligence failure in Britain and the United States
This article argues for the value of a theory of ‘intelligence culture’ in understanding not only how national intelligence systems work but also how intelligence failures occur in those systems. A
Perception and misperception in international politics
This study of perception and misperception in foreign policy was a landmark in the application of cognitive psychology to political decision making. The New York Times called it, in an article
Intelligence Science: Reverse Peer Review?
TLDR
This space was occupied by a discussion of “inspection science” given the slow application of detection technologies by the inspection team and the prospects for new methods, the status of inspection science seemed to argue for a delay in beginning hostilities, giving us time to answer the question of whether Iraq harbored weapons of mass destruction (WMD).
...
...