Reply to commentary by Moore and Haggard

  title={Reply to commentary by Moore and Haggard},
  author={Lars Hall and Petter Johansson and Sverker Sikstr{\"o}m and Betty T{\"a}rning and Andreas Gonçalves Lind},
  journal={Consciousness and Cognition},
We are very happy to see that Moore and Haggard (2006) welcome the introduction of CBP as a usefulexperimental method for investigating introspection and intentionality, but while they urge caution in theextent of the application of our method, we can do nothing but energetically encourage its use. When Mooreand Haggard write ‘‘in line with Nisbett and Wilson’s hypothesis, the CBP suggests that our introspections areconfabulatory’’, they are not entirely correct. The results of the studies we… 
The apparent action causation: Using a magician forcing technique to investigate our illusory sense of agency over the outcome of our choices
The Criss-Cross force is used to study whether people can tell the difference between an action which had an impact on the outcome they get and one which has no impact, and the psychological processes that underpin the success of this force are investigated.
Interpretivism, First-Person Authority, and Confabulation
Psychological experiments allegedly show that people have a tendency to confabulate explanations of their behavior, because their conscious selves do not know why they do what they do, and therefore
How to Improve on Heterophenomenology: The Self-Measurement Methodology of First-Person Data1
Heterophenomenology is a third-person methodology proposed by Daniel Dennett for using first-person reports as scientific evidence. I argue that heterophenomenology can be improved by making six
Manipulation Detection and Preference Alterations in a Choice Blindness Paradigm
Preference alterations were altered in the direction that subjects were led to believe they selected, and clear short-term modulation of preferences in both manipulated and non-manipulated explanation trials compared to choice-only trials (with opposite directions of effect).
Choice Blindness, Confabulatory Introspection, and Obsessive- Compulsive Symptoms: A New Area of Investigation
The current study is the first to investigate confabulatory introspection in relation to clinical psychological symptoms utilizing the Choice Blindness Paradigm (CBP). It was hypothesized that those
Self-Knowledge, Choice Blindness, and Confabulation
......................................................................................................... vi LIST OF FIGURES


Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes.
Evidence is reviewed which suggests that there may be little or no direct introspective access to higher order cognitive processes. Subjects are sometimes (a) unaware of the existence of a stimulus
The intentional stance
How are we able to understand and anticipate each other in everyday life, in our daily interactions? Through the use of such "folk" concepts as belief, desire, intention, and expectation, asserts
The Illusion of Conscious Will
Do we consciously cause our actions, or do they happen to us? Philosophers, psychologists, neuroscientists, theologians, and lawyers have long debated the existence of free will versus determinism.
Intentional action: Conscious experience and neural prediction
An experiment in which normal subjects judged the perceived time of either intentional actions, involuntary movements, or subsequent effects (auditory tones) of these found that the subject's intention to produce the auditory tone produced an intentional binding between the perceived times of thesubject's action and the tone.
On Measuring the Perceived Onsets of Spontaneous Actions
It is argued that the timing method of Libet et al. (1983) is problematic, because the measuring process affects the neural representations of action and thus also the perceived onsets that the method is designed to measure.
Failure to Detect Mismatches Between Intention and Outcome in a Simple Decision Task
This work investigated the relation between intention, choice, and introspection, and found that participants failed to notice conspicuous mismatches between their intended choice and the outcome they were presented with, while nevertheless offering introspectively derived reasons for why they chose the way they did.
The emulation theory of representation: Motor control, imagery, and perception
  • R. Grush
  • Psychology, Computer Science
    Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • 2004
The emulation theory of representation is developed and explored as a framework that can revealingly synthesize a wide variety of representational functions of the brain, including reasoning, theory of mind phenomena, and language.
Manipulating the Experienced Onset of Intention after Action Execution
The perceived onset of intention depends, at least in part, on neural activity that takes place after the execution of action, and this effect is time-limited, specific to modality, and also specific to the anatomical site of stimulation.
Voluntary action and conscious awareness
It is concluded that the CNS applies a specific neural mechanism to produce intentional binding of actions and their effects in conscious awareness.
Conscious intention and motor cognition
  • P. Haggard
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Trends in Cognitive Sciences
  • 2005
Findings suggest that the conscious experience of intending to act arises from preparation for action in frontal and parietal brain areas, which involves a strong sense of agency in the external world.