# Reply to Comment on"Discrete Time Crystals: Rigidity Criticality and Realizations"

@inproceedings{Yao2021ReplyTC, title={Reply to Comment on"Discrete Time Crystals: Rigidity Criticality and Realizations"}, author={Norman Y. Yao and Andrew C. Potter and Ionut-Dragos Potirniche and Ashvin Vishwanath}, year={2021} }

This is a reply to the comment from Khemani, Moessner and Sondhi (KMS) [arXiv:2109.00551] on our manuscript [Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 030401 (2017)]. The main new claim in KMS is that the short-ranged model does not support an MBL DTC phase. We show that, even for the parameter values they consider and the system sizes they study, the claim is an artifact of an unusual choice of range for the crucial plots. Conducting a standard finite-size scaling analysis on the same data strongly suggests that… Expand

#### References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 25 REFERENCES

A comment on"Discrete time crystals: rigidity, criticality, and realizations"

- Physics
- 2021

The Letter by N. Y. Yao et. al. [1, 2] presents three models for realizing a many-body localized discrete time-crystal (MBL DTC): a short-ranged model [1], its revised version [2], as well as a… Expand

Exploration of the stability of many-body localization in
d>1

- Physics, Mathematics
- Physical Review B
- 2019

Recent work by De Roeck et al. [Phys. Rev. B 95, 155129 (2017)] has argued that many-body localization (MBL) is unstable in two and higher dimensions due to a thermalization avalanche triggered by… Expand

Stability and instability towards delocalization in many-body localization systems

- Physics
- 2017

We propose a theory that describes quantitatively the (in)stability of fully many-body localization (MBL) systems due to ergodic, i.e., delocalized, grains, that can be, for example, due to disorder… Expand

Discrete Time Crystals: Rigidity, Criticality, and Realizations.

- Physics, Medicine
- Physical review letters
- 2017

A simple model for a one-dimensional discrete time crystal which explicitly reveals the rigidity of the emergent oscillations as the drive is varied is considered and a blueprint based upon a one dimensional chain of trapped ions is proposed. Expand

A Brief History of Time Crystals.

- Physics
- 2019

The idea of breaking time-translation symmetry has fascinated humanity at least since ancient proposals of the perpetuum mobile. Unlike the breaking of other symmetries, such as spatial translation… Expand

Prethermal strong zero modes and topological qubits

- Physics, Mathematics
- 2017

We prove that quantum information encoded in some topological excitations, including certain Majorana zero modes, is protected in closed systems for a time scale exponentially long in system… Expand

Discrete Time Crystals

- Physics
- 2019

Experimental advances have allowed for the exploration of nearly isolated quantum many-body systems whose coupling to an external bath is very weak. A particularly interesting class of such systems… Expand

Observation of a discrete time crystal

- Physics, Medicine
- Nature
- 2017

The experimental observation of a discrete time crystal, in an interacting spin chain of trapped atomic ions, is presented, which opens the door to the study of systems with long-range spatio-temporal correlations and novel phases of matter that emerge under intrinsically non-equilibrium conditions. Expand

Pre-thermal phases of matter protected by time-translation symmetry

- Physics, Mathematics
- 2016

In a periodically driven (Floquet) system, there is the possibility for new phases of matter, not present in stationary systems, protected by discrete time-translation symmetry. This includes… Expand

Colloquium
: Many-body localization, thermalization, and entanglement

- Physics
- Reviews of Modern Physics
- 2019

Thermalizing quantum systems are conventionallydescribed by statistical mechanics at equilib-rium. However, not all systems fall into this category, with many-body localization providinga generic… Expand