Reply to 'The three-box paradox revisited' by T Ravon and L Vaidman

  title={Reply to 'The three-box paradox revisited' by T Ravon and L Vaidman},
  author={K. Kirkpatrick},
  journal={Journal of Physics A},
I reply to Ravon and Vaidman's criticism (2007 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40 2873 (this issue)) of my classical implementation of a three-box system as a card-game. 
Path integrals, the ABL rule and the three-box paradox
Abstract The three-box problem is analysed in terms of virtual pathways, interference between which is destroyed by a number of intermediate measurements. The Aharonov–Bergmann–Lebowitz (ABL) rule isExpand
Detectability, Invasiveness and the Quantum Three Box Paradox
Quantum preand post-selection (PPS) paradoxes occur when counterfactual inferences are made about different measurements that might have been performed, between two measurements that are actuallyExpand
Causal reappraisal of the quantum three box paradox
Quantum three box paradox is a prototypical example of some bizarre predictions for intermediate measurements made on preand post-selected systems. Although in principle those effects can beExpand
Measurements, disturbances and the quantum three box paradox
Abstract A quantum pre- and post-selection paradox involves making measurements at two separate times on a quantum system, and making inferences about the state of the system at an intermediate time,Expand
The Two-State Vector Formalism: An Updated Review
The two-state vector formalism of quantum mechanics is a time-symmetrized approach to standard quantum theory particularly helpful for the analysis of experiments performed on preand post-selectedExpand
The rule of conditional probability is valid in quantum theory [Comment on Gelman & Yao's "Holes in Bayesian statistics"]
In a recent manuscript, Gelman & Yao (2020) claim that "the usual rules of conditional probability fail in the quantum realm" and that "probability theory isn't true (quantum physics)" and purport toExpand


What is paradoxical about the "Three-box paradox"?
This paper is a comment on quant-ph/0606067 by Ravon and Vaidman, in which they defend the position that the ``three-box paradox'' is indeed paradoxical.
Classical three-box 'paradox'
A simple classical probabilistic system (a simple card game) classically exemplifies Aharonov and Vaidman's 'three-box 'paradox'' (1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315), implying that the three-boxExpand
The three-box paradox revisited
The classical three-box paradox of Kirkpatrick (2003 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 36 4891) is compared to the original quantum three-box paradox of Aharonov and Vaidman (1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24Expand
Translation of Lueders'"Uber die Zustandsanderung durch den Messprozess"
A translation and discussion of G. Luders, Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 8 322-328 (1951).
The Three-Box “Paradox” and Other Reasons to Reject the Counterfactual Usage of the ABL Rule
An apparent paradox proposed by Aharonov and Vaidman in which a single particle can be found with certainty in two (or more) boxes is analyzed by way of a simple thought experiment. It is found thatExpand
The Meaning of Elements of Reality and Quantum Counterfactuals: Reply to Kastner
This paper is an answer to the preceding paper by Kastner, in which she continued the criticism of the counterfactual usage of the Aharonov-Bergman-Lebowitz rule in the framework of theExpand
Logical Pre- and Post-Selection Paradoxes, Measurement-Disturbance and Contextuality
Many seemingly paradoxical effects are known in the predictions for outcomes of measurements made on pre- and post-selected quantum systems. A class of such effects, which we call ‘`logical pre- andExpand
“Quantal” Behavior in Classical Probability
A number of phenomena generally believed characteristic of quantum mechanics and seen as interpretively problematic—the incompatibility and value-indeterminateness of variables, the non-existence ofExpand
Time-Symmetrized Counterfactuals in Quantum Theory
Counterfactuals in quantum theory are briefly reviewed and it is argued that they are very different from counterfactuals considered in the general philosophical literature. The issue of timeExpand
Shutters, Boxes, but No Paradoxes: Time Symmetry Puzzles in Quantum Theory
The “N‐box experiment” is a much‐discussed thought experiment in quantum mechanics. It is claimed by some authors that a single particle prepared in a superposition of N+1 box locations and which isExpand