• Corpus ID: 14726671

Relativity without tears

  title={Relativity without tears},
  author={Zurab K. Silagadze},
  journal={arXiv: Physics Education},
  • Z. Silagadze
  • Published 7 August 2007
  • Physics
  • arXiv: Physics Education
Special relativity is no longer a new revolutionary theory but a firmly established cornerstone of modern physics. The teaching of special relativity, however, still follows its presentation as it unfolded historically, trying to convince the audience of this teaching that Newtonian physics is natural but incorrect and special relativity is its paradoxical but correct amendment. I argue in this article in favor of logical instead of historical trend in teaching of relativity and that special… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Special relativity in the 21st century *
This paper, which is meant to be a tribute to Minkowski's geometrical insight, rests on the idea that the basic observed symmetries of spacetime homogeneity and of isotropy of space, which are
Special relativity in the 21st century
This paper, which is meant to be a tribute to Minkowski's geometrical insight, rests on the idea that the basic observed symmetries of spacetime homogeneity and of isotropy of space, which are
Voigt transformations in retrospect: missed opportunities?
The teaching of modern physics often uses the history of physics as a didactic tool. However, as in this process the history of physics is not something studied but used, there is a danger that the
One more essay on the Einstein-Poincaré priority dispute
It is not surprising that reading today a paper written more than a hundred years ago, we can extract much more of it than was actually thought or dreamed by the author himself. We demonstrate this
Relativity without Light: A Further Suggestion
The role of the light postulate in special relativity is reexamined. The existing theory of relativity without light shows that one can deduce Lorentz-like transformations with an undetermined
Relativistic mass and modern physics
At first sight, arguments for and against the notion of relativistic mass look like a notorious intra-Lilliputian quarrel between Big-Endians (those who broke their eggs at the larger end) and
Foundations of anisotropic relativistic mechanics
We lay down the foundations of particle dynamics in mechanical theories that satisfy the relativity principle and whose kinematics can be formulated employing reference frames of the type usually
Conserved quantities for the Sitter particles
Recent observations of the luminosity-red shift relation of distant type Ia supernovae established the fact that the expansion of the universe is accelerated. This is interpreted by saying that there
Thomas rotation and Mocanu paradox -- not at all paradoxical
Non-commutativity of the Einstein velocity addition, in case of non-collinear velocities, seemingly gives rise to a conflict with reciprocity principle. However, Thomas rotation comes at a rescue and
Ternary relative velocity; astonishing conflict of the Lorentz group with relativity
We are proving that the Lorentz boost entails the relative velocity to be ternary: ternary relative velocity is a velocity of a body with respect to an interior observer as seen by a preferred


Relativity: Special, General, and Cosmological
Wolfgang Rindler is known as a writer of exceptional clarity. This quality is evident in this book as it explores in depth first special relativity, then general relativity, and finally relativistic
Nothing but relativity, redux
A previous paper demonstrated that spacetime transformations consistent with the principle of relativity could be derived without assuming explicitly the constancy of the speed of light. Here, we
A Cosmic Archipelago: Multiverse Scenarios in the History of Modern Cosmology
Multiverse scenarios are common place in contemporary high energy physics and cosmology, although many consider them simply as bold speculations. In any case there is nothing like a single theory or
Reflections on Gravity
A pedagogical description of a simple ungeometrical approach to General Relativity is given, which follows the pattern of well understood field theories, such as electrodynamics. This leads quickly
The teaching of special relativity
Changes in our way of life during this century have made older presentations of special relativity out of date, and allow one to use far less difficult methods. In particular, familiarity with smooth
Minkowski, Mathematicians, and the Mathematical Theory of Relativity
T HE IMPORTANCE OF THE THEORY OF RELATIVITY for twentieth-century physics, and the appearance of the Gottingen mathematician Hermann Minkowski at a turning point in its history have both attracted
How Galileo could have derived the special theory of relativity
The kinematic results of the special theory of relativity are derived using only the first (Galilean) postulate and the results of one simple thought experiment. Our method is mathematically simple
A modification of Popper's tetradic schema and the special relativity theory
SummaryThe present paper constitutes an elaboration of a previous work by one of us which, among other things, proposed some modifications of Popper's tetradic schema. Here, in the first part, we
Nothing but relativity
We deduce the most general space–time transformation laws consistent with the principle of relativity. Thus, our result contains the results of both Galilean and Einsteinian relativity. The velocity
Is there an Æther?
IN the last century, the idea of a universal and all-pervading æther was popular as a foundation on which to build the theory of electromagnetic phenomena. The situation was profoundly influenced in