Relativism and the Ontological Turn within Anthropology

@article{Palecek2013RelativismAT,
  title={Relativism and the Ontological Turn within Anthropology},
  author={Martin Palecek and Mark Risjord},
  journal={Philosophy of the Social Sciences},
  year={2013},
  volume={43},
  pages={23 - 3}
}
The “ontological turn” is a recent movement within cultural anthropology. Its proponents want to move beyond a representationalist framework, where cultures are treated as systems of belief (concepts, etc.) that provide different perspectives on a single world. Authors who write in this vein move from talk of many cultures to many “worlds,” thus appearing to affirm a form of relativism. We argue that, unlike earlier forms of relativism, the ontological turn in anthropology is not only immune to… 
View on SAGE
lms.ff.uhk.cz
108 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
5
Background Citations
29
Methods Citations
2
Results Citations
1

108 Citations

The Predicament of Ontology

  • R. Preucel
  • Philosophy
    Cambridge Archaeological Journal
  • 2021
This paper will examine the nature of the ontological turn and offer a critical review of its use in archaeology.

The Shape of Things to Come? Reflections on the Ontological Turn in Anthropology

Martin Paleček and Mark Risjord have recently put forward a critical evaluation of the ontological turn in anthropological theory. According to this philosophically informed theory of ethnographic…

Ways to Be Understood: The Ontological Turn and Interpretive Social Science

The ontological turn in anthropological methodology, at least in its conceptualization-oriented formulation, aims to turn away from the concepts and objects found within one’s own social setting in…

Towards a pragmatist anthropology: Objectivity, relativism, ethnocentrism, and intropathy

In this article, I discuss central concerns that have run throughout the history of anthropology since the beginning of the twentieth century, culminating in the recent ontological turn. These are…

Toward a new humanism: An approach from philosophical anthropology

In this introduction to the special section, we revisit the case of humanism, including some challenges to its outworn and problematic metaphysical assumptions. We suggest that a new kind of humanism…

Practical Ontology : Worlds in STS and Anthropology

The following considerations are written in response to a debate among Danish anthropologists concerning the ontological question—whether we inhabit multiple worlds. On the one hand, as we argue…

GOD AND THE ANTHROPOLOGIST

The article aims to be theoretical, and to consider the impact of the word «ontology» in anthropology. I will start from an observation of religious worship, in which at least humans, various objects…

‘Being in Being’: Contesting the Ontopolitics of Indigeneity

Abstract This article critiques the shift towards valorizing indigeneity in western thought and contemporary practice. This shift in approach to indigenous ways of knowing and being, historically…

A meaning holistic (dis)solution of subject–object dualism – its implications for the human sciences

This article presents and analyses a social-practice contextualist version of meaning holism, whose main root lies in American pragmatism. Proposing that beliefs depend on systems of language-use in…

Transforming translations (part I)

  • A. Salmond
  • Sociology
    HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory
  • 2013
Recent writing associated with anthropology's “ontological turn” has worked to transform the familiar trope of ethnography as a mode of translation. In place of popular conceptions of social…
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 25 REFERENCES

On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme

Philosophers of many persuasions are prone to talk of conceptual schemes. Conceptual schemes, we are told, are ways of organizing experience; they are systems of categories that give form to the data…

Writing culture : the poetics and politics of ethnography : a School of American Research advanced seminar

In these new essays, a group of experienced ethnographers, a literary critic, and a historian of anthropology, all known for advanced analytic work on ethnographic writing, place ethnography at the…

The Naturalness of Religious Ideas: A Cognitive Theory of Religion

Why do people have religious ideas? And why thosereligious ideas? The main theme of Pascal Boyer's work is that important aspects of religious representations are constrained by universal properties…

In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion

This book discusses the evolution of religion, the nature of belief, and the role of religion in the development of modern society.

Three Varieties of Knowledge

  • D. Davidson
  • Philosophy
    Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement
  • 1991
I know, for the most part, what I think, want, and intend, and what my sensations are. In addition, I know a great deal about the world around me. I also sometimes know what goes on in other people's…

Inquiries Into Truth and Interpretation

1. THEORIES OF MEANING AND LEARNABLE LANGUAGES (1965) 6. QUOTATION (1979) 9. RADICAL INTERPRETATION (1973) 13. ON THE VERY IDEA OF A CONCEPTUAL SCHEME (1974) 17. WHAT METAPHORS MEAN (1978)

Natural-Born Cyborgs?

Cognitive technologies are best understood as deep and integral parts of the problem-solving systems the authors identify as human intelligence, as well as the dense, reciprocal patterns of causal and co-evolutionary influence that run between them.

The Interpretation of Cultures

THE INTERPRETATION OF CULTURES CLIFFORD GEERTZ PDF Are you searching for THE INTERPRETATION OF CULTURES CLIFFORD GEERTZ Books files? Now, you will be happy that at this time THE INTERPRETATION OF…

Basic Color Terms: Their Universality and Evolution

Preface Introduction 1. The data, hypothesis, and general findings 2. Evolution of basic color terms 3. The data 4. Summary of results and some speculations Appendix I Appendix II Appendix III…

The Myth of the Subjective