Relationships Among Rivals (RAR): A Framework for Analyzing Contending Hypotheses in Process Tracing

@article{Zaks2017RelationshipsAR,
  title={Relationships Among Rivals (RAR): A Framework for Analyzing Contending Hypotheses in Process Tracing},
  author={Sherry Zaks},
  journal={Political Analysis},
  year={2017},
  volume={25},
  pages={344 - 362}
}
  • Sherry Zaks
  • Published 1 July 2017
  • Sociology
  • Political Analysis
Methodologists and substantive scholars alike agree that one of process tracing’s foremost contributions to qualitative research is its capacity to adjudicate among competing explanations of a phenomenon. Existing approaches, however, only provide explicit guidance on dealing with mutually exclusive explanations, which are exceedingly rare in social science research. I develop a tripartite solution to this problem. The Relationships among Rivals (RAR) framework (1) introduces a typology of… Expand
Status Matters in World Politics
This article explores the burgeoning literature on status in world politics. Toward that end, it reviews three recently published books. The three books are representative of the differentExpand
Process Tracing and the Problem of Missing Data
TLDR
This article conceptualizes “missingness” as it relates to process tracing, describes different scenarios in which it is pervasive, and presents three ways of addressing the problem. Expand
Updating Bayesian(s): A Critical Evaluation of Bayesian Process Tracing
Given the increasing quantity and impressive placement of work on Bayesian process tracing, this approach has quickly become a frontier of qualitative research methods. Moreover, it has dominated theExpand
Evil Within: Effects of Gray Zone Coercion on Foreign Policy
  • Chi Fang
  • Political Science
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • 2019
Why do states fail to stand firm against coercers? Considerable literature ascribes the failure to the shortage of domestic cohesion and alliance credibility, seldom have scholars investigatedExpand
Epistemological and Ontological Priors: Varieties of Explicitness and Research Integrity
The original DA-RT transparency agenda aspired to be "epistemically neutral," hoping that open and explicit practices would promote "cross-border understanding" among research traditions, as LupiaExpand
Understanding Bayesianism: Fundamentals for Process Tracers
TLDR
This work focuses on clarifying issues involving mutual exclusivity of hypotheses, evidentiary import, adjudicating among more than two hypotheses, and the logic of iterative research, with the goal of elucidating how Bayesian analysis operates and pushing the field forward. Expand
Return to the Scene of the Crime: Revisiting Process Tracing, Bayesianism, and Murder
In a recent article, I argued that the Bayesian process tracing literature exhibits a persistent disconnect between principle and practice. In their response, Bennett, Fairfield, and Charman raiseExpand
Defending Hierarchy from the Moon to the Indian Ocean: Symbolic Capital and Political Dominance in Early Modern China and the Cold War
Abstract Why do leading actors invest in costly projects that they expect will not yield appreciable military or economic benefits? We identify a causal process in which concerns about legitimacyExpand
Integración metodológica como herramienta de investigación para las relaciones internacionales
This article is intended to bring the reader to the application of methods in the study of International Relations science with special emphasis on methodological integration. With this in mind,Expand
The Structure of Description: Evaluating Descriptive Inferences and Conceptualizations
Explanation presumes description. Description explores the who, when, where, and how, and its answers furnish the raw material for theorizing and explaining. This connection between description andExpand
...
1
2
3
4
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 40 REFERENCES
Systematic process analysis: when and how to use it
TLDR
It is argued that the intensive examination of a small number of cases can be an appropriate research design for testing such inferences and against conceptions of the ‘comparative method’ which imply that small-n case-studies provide weak grounds for causal inference. Expand
Systematic Process Analysis: when and how to use it
Challenging the contention that statistical methods applied to large numbers of cases invariably provide better grounds for causal inference, this article explores the value of a method of systematicExpand
Comparative Hypothesis Testing Via Process Tracing
Causal inference via process tracing has received increasing attention during recent years. A 2 × 2 typology of hypothesis tests takes a central place in this debate. A discussion of the typologyExpand
Process Tracing and Causal Inference
How should we judge competing explanatory claims in social science research? How can we make inferences about which alternative explanations are more convincing, in what ways, and to what degree?Expand
The Logic of Process Tracing Tests in the Social Sciences
This article discusses process tracing as a methodology for testing hypotheses in the social sciences. With process tracing tests, the analyst combines preexisting generalizations with specificExpand
What Can Causal Process Tracing Offer to Policy Studies? A Review of the Literature
Causal process tracing (CPT) has emerged as an important method of causal inference in qualitative social science research, most notably in case study research designs. There is now a considerableExpand
The Logic of Historical Explanation in the Social Sciences
Historical explanations seek to identify the causes of outcomes in particular cases. Although social scientists commonly develop historical explanations, they lack criteria for distinguishingExpand
Understanding Process Tracing
  • D. Collier
  • Sociology
  • PS: Political Science & Politics
  • 2011
Abstract Process tracing is a fundamental tool of qualitative analysis. This method is often invoked by scholars who carry out within-case analysis based on qualitative data, yet frequently it isExpand
A Tale of Two Cultures: Contrasting Quantitative and Qualitative Research
The quantitative and qualitative research traditions can be thought of as distinct cultures marked by different values, beliefs, and norms. In this essay, we adopt this metaphor toward the end ofExpand
Process-Tracing Methods: Foundations and Guidelines
TLDR
The authors develop the underlying logic of process-tracing, including how one should understand causal mechanisms and how Bayesian logic enables strong within-case inferences. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
...