Rehabilitating Duverger’s Theory

  title={Rehabilitating Duverger’s Theory},
  author={William Roberts Clark and Matt Golder},
  journal={Comparative Political Studies},
  pages={679 - 708}
Although Duverger is traditionally seen as synonymous with the institution-list approach to party systems, this article shows that he believed social pressures were the driving force behind the multiplication of parties. Electoral institutions are important, but only because they determine the extent to which social forces are translated into political parties. Although the literature has finally come to realize that social and institutional forces interact to shape party systems, scholars… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

The political context and Duverger's theory: Evidence at the district level
Abstract A central tenet of electoral systems' research is that more parties should get votes in districts with large magnitudes than in districts with smaller magnitudes. This proposition is largely
Is Duverger’s law valid?
I show that, contrary to Duverger’s law, three or four parties receive at least 5 per cent of the votes in most districts in British and Canadian elections. This is so because the voters and the
Mechanical and Psychological Effects of Electoral Reform
Duverger (1954) noted that changes in electoral systems will have two types of effects: mechanical effects, and reactions of political agents in anticipation of these, which he referred to as
Testing Duvergerʼs law: strategic voting in Mongolian elections, 1996–2004
Abstract Recent empirical research on voting in single-member districts, based on extensive data-sets of election results, has demonstrated the general (although not universal) validity of Duverger’s
In defiance of Duverger: The class cleavage and the emergence of district-level multiparty systems in western Europe
At its core, Duverger’s Law, which holds that the number of viable parties in first-past-the-post systems should not exceed two, applies primarily at the district level. While the number of parties
Ideological Congruence and Electoral Institutions
Although the literature examining the relationship between ideological congruence and electoral rules is quite large, relatively little attention has been paid to how congruence should be
Duverger's Law in mixed legislative systems: the impact of national electoral rules on district competition
How do institutional factors shape district competition in mixed legislative systems? Preliminary evidence suggests the distinction between sub-types of mixed systems alone poorly explains variation
Introduction: Rethinking party system institutionalization in Asia
Political parties are often the weakest link in democracies, both young and old. This is the conclusion of a large number of scholars, policy consultants, and political practitioners. From Peru to
Increasing irrationality? The equilibrium relationship between electoral and legislative party system size, 1950–2005
Institutional theories of party system size tell us that voters and parties should anticipate the mechanical effects of electoral systems and adjust their behaviour accordingly. If these expectations
Decision period and Duverger's psychological effect in FPTP elections: Evidence from India
Abstract The plurality rule creates incentives that can divert the vote from the third parties. I argue that the process that converts such Duvergerian incentives into the Duvergerian outcomes has a


The Two-party System and Duverger's Law: An Essay on the History of Political Science
Science involves the accumulation of knowledge, which means not only the formulation of new sentences about discoveries but also the reformulation of empirically falsified or theoretically
Electoral institutions,cleavage structures,and the number of parties
Theory: A classic question in political science concerns what determines the number of parties that compete in a given polity. Broadly speaking, there are two approaches to answering this question,
Ethnic Heterogeneity, District Magnitude, and the Number of Parties
Recent events leading to the importation of democratic ideas and ideals by previously totalitarian states increase our interest in the ways in which electoral institutions influence party systems.
Democratic electoral systems around the world , 1946 – 2000 q
This article describes a new data set that covers the electoral institutions used in all of the democratic legislative and presidential elections in 199 countries between 1946 (or independence) and
Party Fragmentation and Presidential Elections in Post-Communist Democracies
Despite its controversial status as a stable governmental form, many of today's societies attempting to make the transition to democracy have or will, for a variety of reasons, choose
Electoral Systems and the Number of Parties in Postcommunist States
Scholars studying electoral systems have consistently found that single-member plurality elections tend to constrain the number of parties operating in a polity to a much greater extent than
Public Opinion and Political Parties in France.
To any observer the French party system is bewildering. On the one hand, he sees that ten parliamentary groups are officially established in the National Assembly (not including the Overseas
The Gubernatorial Coattails Effect: Federalism and Congressional Elections in Brazil
Competition for executive-level offices can influence competition for legislative office, and federal institutions can provide an "opportunity structure" that shapes partisan competition. In Brazil,
Presidential Election Laws and Multipartism in Latin America
This article examines the interaction between the rules governing presidential elections and multipartism in Latin America. Data from 16 Latin American systems are examined through the use of a
Electoral Institutions, Ethnopolitical Cleavages, and Party Systems in Africa's Emerging Democracies
Do electoral institutions and ethnopolitical cleavages shape the structure of party systems separately or jointly? We examine the independent, additive, and interactive effects on the number of