Reframing Asperger syndrome: lessons from other challenges to the Diagnostic and statistical manual and ICIDH approaches

  title={Reframing Asperger syndrome: lessons from other challenges to the Diagnostic and statistical manual and ICIDH approaches},
  author={Sarah L. Allred},
  journal={Disability \& Society},
  pages={343 - 355}
  • S. Allred
  • Published 2009
  • Psychology
  • Disability & Society
The medical approach to Asperger syndrome (AS) classifies it as a mental disorder. This paper critically examines the concept of mental illness as specified by the Diagnostic and statistical manual (DSM) in the light of published assessments and accounts of AS provided by a variety of sources. Taken together, these accounts provide further support for reframing AS as a socially constructed human difference rather than a pathology. The demedicalization of homosexuality is offered as one… Expand
Syndrome or difference: a critical review of medical conceptualisations of Asperger’s syndrome
We live in a world of vast social differences. People of different ages, cultures, religions, gender and sexual orientation have, and indeed are expected to have, distinct differences in theirExpand
‘DSM-V is taking away our identity’: The reaction of the online community to the proposed changes in the diagnosis of Asperger’s disorder
It is argued that a powerful lay and scientific culture has evolved around the concept of Asperger’s disorder, which has found a particularly compelling voice over the last decade in the online Aspergers community, with websites such as Wrong Planet recruiting tens of thousands of members. Expand
The End of Asperger’s: An Analysis of the Decision to Remove Asperger’s Disorder from the DSM-5
Since first formally classified in 1994, Asperger’s disorder (AD) has been a highly controversial diagnosis. Some researchers have argued that it is indistinguishable from high-functioning autism;Expand
DSM Proposed Changes, Part I: Criticisms and Influences on Changes
  • J. Flaskerud
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Issues in mental health nursing
  • 2010
There have been frequent news media reports lately of proposed changes to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSMV) of the APA due out in May 2013, including re-categorizing pediatric bipolar disorder and Asperger’s syndrome, and adding to the manual (in already established categories) hypersexual disorder, binge eating, and behavioral addictions. Expand
Dictating the boundaries of ab/normality: a critical discourse analysis of the diagnostic criteria for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and hyperkinetic disorder
Abstract In this article we report the findings of a critical discourse analysis of the diagnostic criteria for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and hyperkinetic disorder (HD) in twoExpand
What Can Stutterers Learn from the Neurodiversity Movement?
The history of neurodiversity and its key ideas are looked at, including the disagreements surrounding issues of intervention and cure, and it is concluded that therapy should focus on subject's well‐being and not normalization of superficial behaviors. Expand
Social and Tertiary Health Identities as Argument in the DSM-V Asperger's/Autism Debate
This study rhetorically analyzes print news coverage surrounding the DSM-V debate about the integration of Asperger's into the autism spectrum. News coverage frames the Asperger's debate about theExpand
Using Parent-Identified Strengths of Autistic Children to Advance Strength-Based Intervention
Using Parent-Identified Strengths of Autistic Children to Advance Strength-Based Intervention by Angelique F. Trigueros, MS, CCC-SLP, CPC MS, Missouri State University, 1997 BS, Missouri StateExpand
Autism as a Natural Human Variation: Reflections on the Claims of the Neurodiversity Movement
The effects of DSM categorization and the medical model for high functioning autists, and various possible strategies for the neurodiversity movement to claim extra resources for autists as members of an underprivileged culture without being labelled disabled or as having a disorder are analyzed. Expand
Autism, sociality and friendship: a qualitative enquiry
In my thesis, I report on my qualitative enquiry into the meaning of sociality and friendship from the perspective of persons with autism. I sought to make a contribution to knowledge byExpand


Asperger Syndrome or Autistic Disorder?
The diagnosis of Asperger syndrome (AS) has been plagued with controversy and confusion since it was introduced into the psychiatric nomenclature, in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of MentalExpand
Is Asperger Syndrome Necessarily Viewed as a Disability?
This article considers whether Asperger syndrome (AS) should necessarily be viewed as a disability or, from a different perspective, as a difference. The author concludes that the term difference inExpand
The Social Construction of Asperger Syndrome: The pathologising of difference?
This article poses the question 'Is Asperger Syndrome (AS) a disorder or a neurological difference that has been socially constructed as a disorder?' AS is currently defined within the medicalExpand
What is Asperger syndrome?
  • S. Bauer
  • Medicine
  • The Journal of practical nursing
  • 2009
Students with AS are not uncommonly seen in mainstream educational settings, although often undiagnosed or misdiagnosed, so this is a topic of some importance for educational personnel, as well as for parents. Expand
Three Diagnostic Approaches to Asperger Syndrome: Implications for Research
Diagnostic assignments of AS based on three commonly used approaches have low agreement and lead to different results in comparisons of IQ profiles, patterns of comorbidity, and familial aggregation of psychiatric symptoms across the approach-specific resultant groups of HFA, AS, and PDD-NOS. Expand
Asperger's syndrome.
  • M. Leboyer
  • Medicine
  • The Harvard mental health letter
  • 2005
Asperger's syndrome is an uncommon disorder and information on prevalence is limited but it appears to be more common in males, and all the interventions are mainly symptomatic and/or rehabilitational. Expand
Asperger Syndrome: The Emerging Challenge to Special Education
This article provides a synthesis of recent literature on Asperger Syndrome (AS), a condition that has received little attention in American special education. The analysis addresses the syndrome'sExpand
Asperger's syndrome: a clinical account.
  • L. Wing
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Psychological medicine
  • 1981
The clinical features, course, aetiology, epidemiology, differential diagnosis and management of Asperger's syndrome are described. Classification is discussed and reasons are given for including theExpand
Asperger’s Syndrome: A Comparison of Clinical Diagnoses and Those Made According to the ICD-10 and DSM-IV
Results contrast with those of others who have stated that the diagnosis of AS using ICD-10/DSM-IV criteria is ‘virtually impossible’, and it is suggested that this is due to limitations inherent in these criteria. Expand
Disorder as harmful dysfunction: a conceptual critique of DSM-III-R's definition of mental disorder.
The definition of disorder operationally fails to capture the idea of "dysfunction" and so fails to validly distinguish disorders from nondisorders, leading to invalidities in many of DSM-III-R's specific diagnostic criteria. Expand