Reforming Republicanism: Alexander Hamilton's Theory of Republican Citizenship and Press Liberty

  title={Reforming Republicanism: Alexander Hamilton's Theory of Republican Citizenship and Press Liberty},
  author={Robert W. T. Martin},
  journal={Journal of the Early Republic},
  pages={21 - 46}
During his life and ever since, Alexander Hamilton has been criticized as an opponent of republicanism, even a closet monarchist. Recent scholarly efforts to rescue Hamilton from these interpretations have succeeded perhaps too well, making him out to be a moderate, mainstream republican of his day. This essay assesses Hamilton's public performance during the late 1780s and 1790s as a defender of a particular federalist vision of republicanism. Drawing on a central conceptual divide over the… 
8 Citations
Alexander Hamilton and the Sedition Act: A Founder’s Ambivalence on Freedom of the Press
ABSTRACT More than two centuries since his death, Alexander Hamilton has become the most popular and misunderstood Founding Father. At least partly because of Ron Chernow’s biography and Lin-Manuel
Aristocratic and Confederate Republicanism in Hamiltonian Thought and Practice
This article identifies and explores the presence of republican thought in the intellectual and policy writings of Alexander Hamilton, particularly as it applied to his theoretical understanding of
The Mask of Publius: Alexander Hamilton and the Politics of Expediency
A careful reading of his Federalist essays points to something far more complex and nuanced than a simple act of concealing his actual views or putting the best face on a plan he discountenanced: the creative act of construing the document in such a way as to stretch its meaning to accord more closely with the high-toned plan of government he outlined in the Federal Convention.
Between Consensus and Conflict: Habermas, Post-Modern Agonism and the Early American Public Sphere
Efforts thus far to bridge the distance between Habermasian public sphere theory and post-modernism have failed, and recent studies only reify the bifurcation. Some theorists trace this problem to
Delivering unpalatable truths: Lessons learned from Alexander Hamilton and the Jay Treaty debate
Alexander Hamilton believed that political leaders should address the public with candor and confront them with unpalatable truths when passion led them to favor policies that betrayed their true
Rethinking People v. Croswell: Alexander Hamilton and the Nature and Scope of “Common Law” in the Early Republic
  • K. Brown
  • Law, History
    Law and History Review
  • 2014
While serving in the New York Assembly in 1787, Alexander Hamilton identified a problematic clause in New York's constitution. Remarking on an act for settling intestate estates, Hamilton asked, “The
The Radical Democratic Thought of Thomas Jefferson: Politics, Space, & Action
ing verifiable conclusions concerning indigenous peoples in North America. According to Jefferson, a proper theorization always requires more collection of data, more facts that can be aided in the
James Madison and the Spirit of Republican Self-Government
1. Republican opposition 2. The Federalist agenda 3. Madison and the French Enlightenment 4. The commerce of ideas 5. Madison and Jefferson: an appeal to the people 6. The spirit of republican


Republican Empire: Alexander Hamilton on War and Free Government
The republics of Greece and Rome proved incapable of waging war effectively and remaining free at the same time. The record of modern republics is not much more encouraging. How, then, did the United
Hamilton's Republic: Readings in the American Democratic Nationalist Tradition
Nationalism has long been regarded as a specter of far-right ideology. Hitler, Mussolini, and Milosevic have been some of its most destructive practitioners. But do these dictators and their
Alexander Hamilton, the Alien Law, and Seditious Libels
The biographers of Alexander Hamilton have been almost unanimous in absolving him from any complicity in the enactment and enforcement of the Alien and Sedition Laws of 1798. Most of them deny that
Madison and the French Enlightenment: The Authority of Public Opinion
N 1791-1792 James Madison published at least nineteen unsigned articles in Philip Freneau's National Gazette, a Philadelphia newspaper that he and Thomas Jefferson had recently helped to establish in
Emergence of a Free Press
Leonard W. Levy's Legacy of Suppression so disturbed Supreme Court Justice Hugo L. Black that he called it "one of the mosts devastating blows that has been delivered against civil liberty for a long
The Other Founders: Anti-Federalism and the Dissenting Tradition in America, 1788-1828
The Other Founders: Anti-Federalism and the Dissenting Tradition in America, 1788-1828. By Saul Cornell. (Chapel Hill: Published for the Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture,
Printers and Press Freedom: The Ideology of Early American Journalism
This book seeks to challenge the view that the eighteenth century understanding of the meaning of freedom of the press and the First Amendment was a narrow or limited one. The author examines the
The Free and Open Press: The Founding of American Democratic Press Liberty, 1640-1800
The current, heated debates over hate speech and pornography were preceded by the equally contentious debates over the "free and open press" in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Thus far
The Presidency of George Washington
In this volume, Forrest McDonald admits that George Washington was no executive genius, and notes that a number of his advisers and cabinet members were considerably more important in formulating
The Age of Federalism
When Thomas Jefferson took the oath of office for the presidency in 1801, America had just passed through twelve critical years, years dominated by some of the towering figures of our history and by