Reflections on the general theory of second best at its golden jubilee

  title={Reflections on the general theory of second best at its golden jubilee},
  author={R. Lipsey},
  journal={International Tax and Public Finance},
  • R. Lipsey
  • Published 2007
  • Economics
  • International Tax and Public Finance
Abstract The origin of the second best article is described and criticisms assessed. Distortions making impossible the achievement of either first or second best optima are outlined. Attempts to establish the applicability of first best rules are criticised, as are general rules for making piecemeal efficiency improvements. Both often use models containing empirically invalid assumptions and a selected few of the full set of distortions. Practical policy advice requires more parochial objective… Expand
Theory of Third Best: How to Interpret and Apply
Six decades after the formulation of his (Lipsey & Lancaster, [Lipsey R. G., 1956]) celebrated general theory of the second best, Richard Lipsey has written on the important issue of second‐best andExpand
The Way We Teach Public Economics: A Rationalization Using the Theory of Third Best
The devastating implications of the theory of second best, despite being well recognized a half century ago, do not have much influence on the current way we teach public economics at undergraduateExpand
Assessing ideal theories
Numerous philosophers allege that the “general theory of second best” poses a challenge to the Target View, which asserts that real-world reform efforts should aim to establish arrangements thatExpand
A critique of Ng's third-best theory
The theory of second best established that the effect on community welfare of any one policy change varies with the specific context in which that change occurs. In paper that has been frequentlyExpand
Welfare Economics and Second-Best Theory: Filling Imaginary Economic Boxes
The economic theory of the second best has been an analytical staple of welfare economics and policy analysis since Lipsey and Lancaster (1956) set forth the idea. That theory challenged the thenExpand
The Economics Profession’s Responses to The General Theory of Second Best: Descriptions and Critiques
This chapter argues that the economics profession has not responded appropriately to The General Theory of Second Best (Lipsey and Lancaster in Rev Econ Stud 24:11–32, 1956). Section 2.1 explains theExpand
Introduction to The General Theory of Second Best, Its Central Implications, and the Appropriate Way to Respond to It
Section 1.1 explains that, when the optimum is “maximizing economic efficiency”1 and the set of sufficient conditions for that optimum’s achievement is the Pareto-optimal conditions,2 The GeneralExpand
Some Legacies of Robbins' an Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science
This paper criticizes three Robbinsian positions still often found in modern economics: (1) the methodology of intuitively obvious assumptions; (2) treating facts as illustrations rather than asExpand
Generality versus Context Specificity: First, Second and Third Best in Theory and Policy
Second-best theory established that a policy's effect on community welfare (or any other objective function) varies with its specific context. In contrast, Ng argues that fulfilling first-bestExpand
Consensus and Liberal Legitimacy: From First to Second Best?
In this article, consensus, defined as the consent of all citizens, is argued to be the first best for part of the liberal tradition on political legitimacy. Consensus would be the foundation of theExpand


The General Theory of Second Best
There is an important basic similarity underlying a number of recent works in apparently widely separated fields of economic theory. Upon examination, it would appear that the authors have beenExpand
A Paradox in the Theory of Second Best
This paper first develops a political model rationalizing conventional second-best constraints on the controllability of certain sectors despite the perfect governmental information assumptionsExpand
Successes and failures in the transformation of economics
While acknowledging the successes of modern economics, this paper concentrates on some shortcomings. Many are traced to a single source: the great insights of economics are all qualitative. EconomicsExpand
Towards a Theory of Third‐Best
The theory of second best (Lipsey & Lancaster [Lipsey R. G., 1956]) shows that the presence of irremovable distortions renders the second‐best conditions exceedingly complicated; by satisfying someExpand
The Role of Second-Best Theory in Public Economics
This paper surveys the evolution of the use of the theory of second best in public economics. It argues that much of modern normative public economics can be interpreted as simply applied second-bestExpand
A critique of welfare economics
A Critique of Welfare Economics was first published in 1950. It was concerned with the exposition, criticism, and appreciation of the theory of economic welfare as it had been developed to that date.Expand
Comments on “The General Theory of Second Best”
Lipsey and Lancaster [5] have performed a valuable service in collating and comparing various well-known non-Pareto optimal situations and suggesting that they are all special cases of what they callExpand
Three Basic Postulates for Applied Welfare Economics: An Interpretive Essay
I would like to extend my thanks to my colleague, Harry G. Johnson, for hi8 helpful comments, to Daniel Wisecarver, for help extending well beyond the normal call of duty for a research assistant,Expand
IF we add further constraints to a maximum problem, then according to the mathematical theory of constrained maxima, the first-order conditions must be expected to be different from what they wereExpand
Welfare Economics and the Theory of Second Best
Abstract : Conditions are demonstrated under which a violation of one Pareto condition means that it is socially desirable that certain other of the Paretian conditions be violated. The commonly heldExpand