Reflections on the Ethics of Social Experimentation

@article{Humphreys2015ReflectionsOT,
  title={Reflections on the Ethics of Social Experimentation},
  author={Macartan Humphreys},
  journal={Journal of Globalization and Development},
  year={2015},
  volume={6},
  pages={112 - 87}
}
  • M. Humphreys
  • Published 1 June 2015
  • Sociology
  • Journal of Globalization and Development
Abstract Social scientists are increasingly engaging in experimental research projects of importance for public policy in developing areas. While this research holds the possibility of producing major social benefits, it may also involve manipulating populations, often without consent, sometimes with potentially adverse effects, and often in settings with obvious power differentials between researcher and subject. Such research is currently conducted with few clear ethical guidelines. In this… 

Subjects and Scholars’ Views on the Ethics of Political Science Field Experiments

Recent controversies raise questions regarding the ethics of political science field experiments. I present here results from a public opinion survey in which subjects and scholars evaluated the

Harm, change and unpredictability: the ethics of interviews in conflict research

Conceiving of interviews as relationships of knowledge creation involving a researcher and a research participant, we engage with the ethical implications of the unpredictabilities of this

Ethics, Integrity and the Scientific Method

Experimental design is one aspect of a scientific method. A well-designed, properly conducted experiment aims to control variables in order to isolate and manipulate causal effects and thereby

Experiments in the Court: The Legal and Ethical Challenges of Running Randomized Field Experiments in the Courtroom

Although legal scholars have been utilizing experimental methodologies for over 60 years, they have only recently begun to design and implement field experiments, an empirical method in which

Beyond the Field: Ethics after Fieldwork in Politically Dynamic Contexts

As researchers, when do our ethical obligations end? How should our ethical obligations respond to dynamic and unstable political contexts? Political scientists frequently work in dynamic political

Towards ethical good practice in cash transfer trials and their evaluation.

Over the past 20 years, cash transfers have become increasingly widespread within international development and global social policy. Often, their roll out is preceded by a trial or pilot phase

The ethics of security research. An ethics framework for contemporary security studies

TLDR
This effort brings together an existing but fragmented literature and builds upon the authors’ own experiences in several subfields and schools of “hands-on” research on security and political violence to offer a framework for ethical assessment.

Bartleby: Procedural and Substantive Ethics in the Design of Research Ethics Systems

The lack of consent or debriefing in online research has attracted widespread public distrust. How can designers create systems to earn and maintain public trust in large-scale online research?

A systematic review on ethical challenges of ‘field’ research in low-income and middle-income countries: respect, justice and beneficence for research staff?

TLDR
Nine different types of ethical challenges that research staff may be exposed to during field research, including role conflicts that can emerge from participants’ help requests and the high level of deprivation found in certain study settings, are identified.

What Can Experiments Tell Us About How to Improve Government Performance?

Abstract In recent years, experimental methods have been both highly celebrated, and roundly criticized, as a means of addressing core questions in the social sciences. They have received particular

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 26 REFERENCES

Conducting Ethical Economic Research: Complications from the Field

This essay discusses practical issues confronted when conducting surveys as well as designing appropriate field trials. First, it looks at the challenge of ensuring transparency while maintaining

The ethics of New Development Economics: is the Experimental Approach to Development Economics morally wrong?

The 2000s have witnessed the arrival and growing popularity of randomized controlled experiments (RCTs) in Development Economics. Whilst this new way of conducting research on development has

Public involvement in medical ethics. A model for government action.

TLDR
This article argues for a government role of limited scope and evaluates the mechanism Congress chose, the independent advisory commission, against others recently proposed to conclude that the alternatives will not fulfill a proper government role and that the temporary independent Advisory Commission is the most appropriate model.

Public involvement in medical ethics.

TLDR
This article argues for a government role of limited scope and evaluates the mechanism Congress chose, the independent advisory commission, against others recently proposed, concluding that the alternatives will not fulfill a proper government role and that the temporary independent Advisory Commission is the most appropriate model.

Informed consent in human experimentation before the Nuremberg code

TLDR
New research indicates that ethical issues of informed consent in guidelines for human experimentation were recognised as early as the nineteenth century, which shed light on the still contentious issue of when the concepts of autonomy, informed consent, and therapeutic and non-therapeutic research first emerged.

Clarifying the concepts of research ethics.

  • R. Levine
  • Psychology
    The Hastings Center report
  • 1979
TLDR
The National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research began the process of correcting the conceptual and semantic errors that had undermined virtually all previous attempts to develop rational public policy on research involving human subjects.

The Belmont Report. Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research.

  • J. BradyA. Jonsen
  • Medicine, Political Science
    The Journal of the American College of Dentists
  • 2014
TLDR
The Belmont Report is a statement of basic ethical principles and guidelines that should assist in resolving the ethical problems that surround the conduct of research with human subjects that were identified by the Commission in the course of its deliberations.

Where the Rubber Meets the Road: Aligning IRBs and Research Practice

In recent years, there has been increased discussion and even debate about how to reconcile a commitment to the ethical conduct of research in the social and behavioral sciences with a regulatory

The problem of consent in emergency medicine research.

TLDR
The Canadian Tri-Council Policy Statement guidelines for emergency medicine research are compared to the US Food and Drug Administration rules, and the former is assessed and critiqued.

Informed consent -- why are its goals imperfectly realized?

TLDR
Although most thought that consent forms were necessary and comprehensible and that they contained worthwhile information, the legalistic connotations of the forms appeared to lead to cursory reading and inadequate recall.