Reference Rot: An Emerging Threat to Transparency in Political Science

@article{Gertler2017ReferenceRA,
  title={Reference Rot: An Emerging Threat to Transparency in Political Science},
  author={Aaron L. Gertler and John G. Bullock},
  journal={PS: Political Science \& Politics},
  year={2017},
  volume={50},
  pages={166 - 171}
}
ABSTRACT Transparency of research is a large concern in political science, and the practice of publishing links to datasets and other online resources is one of the main methods by which political scientists promote transparency. But the method cannot work if the links don’t, and very often, they don’t. We show that most of the URLs ever published in the American Political Science Review no longer work as intended. The problem is severe in recent as well as in older articles; for example, more… 
View on Cambridge Press
johnbullock.org
34 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
1
Background Citations
4
Results Citations
1

34 Citations

Why too many political science findings cannot be trusted and what we can do about it: A review of meta-scientific research and a call for institutional reform

While other scientific disciplines are currently undergoing “credibility revolutions”, also political science should also face the uncomfortable question of how much we can trust the findings that…

Transparency in Practice in Qualitative Research

The discipline of political science has been engaged in discussion about when, why, and how to make scholarship more transparent for at least three decades. This piece argues that qualitative…

Why Too Many Political Science Findings Cannot Be Trusted and What We Can Do About It: A Review of Meta-Scientific Research and a Call for Academic Reform

Witnessing the ongoing “credibility revolutions” in other disciplines, political science should also engage in meta-scientific introspection. Theoretically, this commentary describes why scientists…

A practical guide for transparency in psychological science

A practical guide to help researchers navigate the process of preparing and sharing the products of their research (e.g., choosing a repository, preparing their research products for sharing, structuring folders, etc.).

Transparency for Text-Based Sources: From Principles to Practice

Debates about transparency standards in social science research often lack specificity, mischaracterize the status quo, or stress the value of replication. These debates frequently talk past each…

Active Maintenance: A Proposal for the Long-Term Computational Reproducibility of Scientific Results

It is proposed that researchers dedicated to computational reproducibility should have a plan in place for “active maintenance” of their analysis code, and suggestions for how data archives, journals, and research communities could encourage and reward the active maintenance of scientific code and data are offered.

FAIR national election studies: How well are we doing?

This work outlines data reuse quality criteria pertaining to data accessibility, metadata provision, and data documentation using the FAIR Principles of research data management as a framework and investigates the extent to which a selection of election studies fulfils these criteria.

Availability and Audit of Links in Altmetric Data Providers: Link Checking of Blogs and News in Altmetric.com, Crossref Event Data and PlumX

These aggregators need to develop a specific policy to improve the audit of these data for research evaluation processes (saving a copy of the event, employing more frequently crawls, avoiding external providers, etc.).

Beyond Mill: Why Cross-Case Qualitative Causal Inference Is Weak, and Why We Should Still Compare

ions. They inveighed against equating particular practices or institutions that have superficial similarities, yet actually work in profoundly different ways. Sartori’s taxonomical metaphor, with its…

The Problem of Reference Rot in Spatial Metadata Catalogues

This paper evaluates the presence of Reference Rot and its impact on the 22,738 distribution URIs of 18,054 metadata records from 26 European INSPIRE spatial data catalogues and uses the data format used in the metadata as an indicator.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 24 REFERENCES

Data Access and Research Transparency (DA-RT): A Joint Statement by Political Science Journal Editors

  • Economics
    Italian Political Science Review/Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica
  • 2015
In this joint statement, leading journals commit to greater data access and research transparency, and to implementing policies requiring authors to make as accessible as possible the empirical…

Openness in Political Science: Data Access and Research Transparency

In 2012, the American Political Science Association (APSA) Council adopted new policies guiding data access and research transparency in political science. The policies appear as a revision to APSA's…

Research Preregistration in Political Science: The Case, Counterarguments, and a Response to Critiques

ABSTRACT This article describes the current debate on the practice of preregistration in political science—that is, publicly releasing a research design before observing outcome data. The case in…

Science Deserves Better: The Imperative to Share Complete Replication Files

  • A. Dafoe
  • Computer Science
    PS: Political Science & Politics
  • 2013
It took three years for this error and other issues to be discovered because replication files were not publicly available, nor were they provided to scholars when asked, so discussions about austerity policies would have been based on a more clear-sighted appraisal of the evidence.

Data Preservation Alliance for the Social Sciences: A Model for Collaboration

This paper will discuss three of the significant products that have emerged from the Data Preservation Alliance for the Social Science, including procedures for identifying and selecting “at risk” digital materials identified by the Partnership, and the design and implementation of a shared catalog describing the data holdings of all partners.

Copyright Issues Relevant to the Creation of a Digital Archive: A Preliminary Assessment

Copyright rights and exceptions are described and issues potentially involved in the creation of a nonprofit digital archive are highlighted, to provide basic information about the copyright law for those developing such an archive and thereby enable them to recognize areas in which it could impinge on copyright rights and to plan accordingly.

A Proposed Standard for the Scholarly Citation of Quantitative Data

A similar universal standard for citing quantitative data is proposed that retains the advantages of print citations, adds other components made possible by, and needed due to, the digital form and systematic nature of quantitative data sets, and is consistent with most existing subfield-specific approaches.

An Introduction to the Dataverse Network as an Infrastructure for Data Sharing

The author introduces a set of integrated developments in Web application software, networking, data citation standards, and statistical methods designed to increase scholarly recognition for data contributions to benefit both the scientific community and the sometimes apparently contradictory goals of individual researchers.

The half-life of internet references cited in communication journals

The results show that only 61 percent of the online citations remain accessible in 2004 and 39 percent do not, and the content analysis shows that .org and .gov are the most stable domains.

Disappearing act: decay of uniform resource locators in health care management journals.

In addition to using website archiving tools like WebCite, publishers should require authors to both keep copies of Internet-based information they used and deposit copies of data with the publishers.