Referees Often Miss Obvious Errors in Computer and Electronic Publications

  title={Referees Often Miss Obvious Errors in Computer and Electronic Publications},
  author={Paul Colin de Gloucester},
  journal={Accountability in Research},
  pages={143 - 166}
Misconduct is extensive and damaging. So-called science is prevalent. Articles resulting from so-called science are often cited in other publications. This can have damaging consequences for society and for science. The present work includes a scientometric study of 350 articles (published by the Association for Computing Machinery; Elsevier; The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.; John Wiley; Springer; Taylor & Francis; and World Scientific Publishing Co.). A lower bound… Expand

Topics from this paper

Letter to the Editor: A Commentary on “Referees Often Miss Obvious Errors in Computer and Electronic Publications” (de Gloucester, 2013)
In an otherwise good and relevant issue of Accountability in Research, de Gloucester’s (2013) paper on peer-review failures does not live up to the expectations set forth by its provocative title, “Referees Often Miss Obvious Errors in Computer and Electronic Publications. Expand
Commentary: Peer Review and Incomplete Reference Lists
  • H. Rivera
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Accountability in research
  • 2014
A greater transparency in both original and review articles would be achieved inasmuch as the authors describe how they select the cited references (Mertens and Baethge, 2011); in turn, this practice may diminish. Expand


Duplicate and fake publications in the scientific literature: how many SCIgen papers in computer science?
This work demonstrates a software method of detecting duplicate and fake publications appearing in scientific conferences and, as a result, in the bibliographic services. Expand
Checking for errors in calculations and software: Dimensional balance and conformance of units
Software methods have recently become available for checking calculations, equations, algorithms and programs for dimensional soundness and can be used to check for errors in calculations and software source code in a way that is similar to using a spelling or grammar checker for text. Expand
Counting Highly Cited Papers for University Research Assessment: Conceptual and Technical Issues
This study argues that indicators for the 1% high-citation tail of the citation distribution reveal the contribution of universities to the progress of science and provide quantifiable justification for the large investments in research made by elite research universities. Expand
Betrayers of the Truth
The timeliness of Betrayers of the Truth is exemplified by the recent exposure of John Darsee's faked experimental data, and the book reads like a detective story as it chronicles the infamous career. Expand
Quality and Peer Review of Research: An Adjudicating Role for Editors
  • D. Newton
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Accountability in research
  • 2010
This study describes shortcomings of the peer review process and condenses them into an explanatory framework involving situational, personal, social, and ethical factors. Expand
Research Misconduct Policies of Social Science Journals and Impact Factor
Impact factor of the journal was the only variable significantly associated with whether a journal had a formal misconduct policy with an odds-ratio of 1.72 (p < 0.01). Expand
Lessons from the Darsee affair.
  • A. Relman
  • Medicine
  • The New England journal of medicine
  • 1983
It seems paradoxical that scientific research, in many ways one of the most questioning and skeptical of human activities, should be dependent on personal trust. But the fact is that without trustExpand
A Beauty Contest of Referee Processes of Economics Journals
Peer review influences decisively personal advancement, research opportunities, salaries, grant-funding, promotion, and tenure. It claims to exert quality control of manuscripts and improve them, toExpand
Reliable Knowledge: An exploration of the grounds for belief in science
John Ziman 1979 London: Cambridge University Press ix + 197 pp price £7.95 Professor John Ziman, as readers of Physics Bulletin well know, has an established and distinguished reputation as aExpand
Minds and machines
The emergence of electronic computers in the last thirty years has given rise to many interesting questions. Many of these questions are technical, relating to a machine’s ability to perform complexExpand