Reexamining the Effect of Gustatory Disgust on Moral Judgment: A Multilab Direct Replication of Eskine, Kacinik, and Prinz (2011)

  title={Reexamining the Effect of Gustatory Disgust on Moral Judgment: A Multilab Direct Replication of Eskine, Kacinik, and Prinz (2011)},
  author={Eric Ghelfi and Cody Daniel Christopherson and Heather L. Urry and Richie L. Lenne and Nicole Legate and Mary Ann Fischer and Fieke Maria Antoinet Wagemans and Brady Wiggins and Tamara Barrett and Michelle Bornstein and Bianca de Haan and Joshua Guberman and Nada Issa and Joan Kim and Elim Na and Justin O'brien and Aidan Paulk and Tayler Peck and Marissa Sashihara and Karen Sheelar and Justin Song and Hannah Sinja Steinberg and Dasan Sullivan},
  journal={Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science},
  pages={23 - 3}
Eskine, Kacinik, and Prinz’s (2011) influential experiment demonstrated that gustatory disgust triggers a heightened sense of moral wrongness. We report a large-scale multisite direct replication of this study conducted by labs in the Collaborative Replications and Education Project. Subjects in each sample were randomly assigned to one of three beverage conditions: bitter (disgusting), control (neutral), or sweet. Then, subjects made a series of judgments about the moral wrongness of the… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Gross values: Investigating the role of disgust in bioethics

What is the role of disgust in moral judgements? Previous research found that disgust increases the severity of judgments; but other more recent work has cast doubt on these findings. Here we

Does inappropriate behavior hurt or stink? The interplay between neural representations of somatic experiences and moral decisions

It is found that moral scenarios enhanced physiological and neural activity to subsequent disgust (but not pain), as further supported by an independently validated whole-brain signature of olfaction.

Yikes! The Effect of Incidental Disgust and Information on Public Attitudes During the COVID ‐19 Pandemic

Existing research has focused extensively on the role of emotions such as anger, fear, and enthusiasm in explaining public opinion, but less is known about the importance of disgust, an innate

What is the link between personality and food behavior?

Teaching Research in Principle and in Practice: What Do Psychology Instructors Think of Research Projects in Their Courses?

Psychology majors typically conduct at least one research project during their undergraduate studies, yet these projects rarely make a scientific contribution beyond the classroom. In this study, we

Thought experiments and experimental ethics

Experimental ethicists investigate traditional ethical questions with non-traditional means, namely with the methods of the empirical sciences. Studies in this area have made heavy use of philosoph...

How disgust affects social judgments



Does Cleanliness Influence Moral Judgments

Schnall, Benton, and Harvey (2008) hypothesized that physical cleanliness reduces the severity of moral judgments. In support of this idea, they found that individuals make less severe judgments when

Does Incidental Disgust Amplify Moral Judgment? A Meta-Analytic Review of Experimental Evidence

  • J. LandyGeoffrey P. Goodwin
  • Psychology
    Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2015
A meta-analysis of all available studies in which incidental disgust was manipulated prior to or concurrent with a moral judgment task found evidence for a small amplification effect of disgust, which is strongest for gustatory/olfactory modes of disgust induction.

Our Conclusions Were Tentative, But Appropriate

  • J. LandyGeoffrey P. Goodwin
  • Psychology
    Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2015
The metaanalysis clarifies the state of the evidence regarding social intuitionism’s most fundamental theoretical claim and responds to concerns raised by Schnall et al. themselves.

Landy and Goodwin (2015) Confirmed Most of Our Findings Then Drew the Wrong Conclusions

A robust amplification effect of olfactory disgust on moral judgment even in the absence of important moderator variables is found, including a clear and robust effect for studies that used taste or smell to induce disgust.

The Effects of Disgust on Moral Judgments

There is evidence that inducing feelings of disgust increases the severity of moral judgments, but the size of this association has been questioned by a recent meta-analysis. Based on prior research

Disgust selectively modulates reciprocal fairness in economic interactions.

Results showed that relative to being in a sad or neutral mood, induced feelings of disgust significantly increased rejection rates of unfair offers, and the hypothesis that disgust and social norm violations may share common computational components is focused on.

Disgust and the moralization of purity.

It is proposed that disgust moralizes--that is, amplifies the moral significance of--protecting the purity of the body and soul, and that individuals of lower socioeconomic status were more likely than individuals of higher SES to moralize purity but not justice or harm/care.

The Sweet Taste of Revenge: Gustatory Experience Induces Metaphor-Consistent Judgments of a Harmful Act

Metaphors are common transfer devices that map concrete experiences onto abstract target concepts. We investigated whether a specific gustatory sensation (sweet taste) affects social judgments (here,

A Component Process Model of Disgust, Anger and Moral Judgment

What is the role of disgust in morality? The Component Process Model of morality proposed in this chapter suggests that moral disgust is driven primarily by negative character evaluations, explaining

On the Role of Attention and Emotion in Morality: Attentional Control Modulates Unrelated Disgust in Moral Judgments

The emotion of disgust can influence people’s moral judgments, even if this emotion objectively is unrelated to the moral judgment in question. The present work demonstrates that attentional control