Reciprocity and the Social Contract

@article{Binmore2004ReciprocityAT,
  title={Reciprocity and the Social Contract},
  author={Ken Binmore},
  journal={Politics, Philosophy \& Economics},
  year={2004},
  volume={3},
  pages={35 - 5}
}
  • K. Binmore
  • Published 1 February 2004
  • Economics
  • Politics, Philosophy & Economics
This article is extracted from a forthcoming book, ‘Natural Justice’. It is a nontechnical introduction to the part of game theory immediately relevant to social contract theory. The latter part of the article reviews how concepts such as trust, responsibility, and authority can be seen as emergent phenomena in models that take formal account only of equilibria in indefinitely repeated games. 

Figures from this paper

A decentralized cooperative solution to the iterated pacifist’s dilemma game: notes in the margin of Pinker’s theory of Leviathan
The current paper is heavily indebted to Steven Pinker’s theory of Leviathan. He made ingenious theoretical and historical use of the one-off prisoner’s dilemma game (= the pacifist’s dilemma game)
Rationality, uncertainty, and unanimity: an epistemic critique of contractarianism
Abstract This paper considers contractarianism as a method of justification. The analysis accepts the key tenets of contractarianism: expected utility maximization, unanimity as the criteria of
Cooperation and the Globalization-Localization Dilemmas
Evolution of cooperation among self-interested agents is revisited in this paper in the context of globalization and localization. A globalized society is characterized by disentrenchment—or routine
Social Complexity and Evolved Moral Principles
A central theme in F. A. Hayek’s work is the contrast between principles and expediency, and the insistence that governments follow abstract general principles rather than pursue apparently expedient
Resolving the iterated prisoner’s dilemma: theory and reality
TLDR
It is argued that in most cases, individuals could theoretically benefit from cheating and that cooperation cannot therefore be explained with the concept of positive pseudo‐reciprocity, and that by incorporating empirical data into the theoretical framework, the authors may gain fundamental new insights into the evolution of mutual reciprocal investment in nature.
On the emergence of descriptive norms
A descriptive norm is a behavioral rule that individuals follow when their empirical expectations of others following the same rule are met. We aim to provide an account of the emergence of
The Tragedy of the AI Commons
TLDR
Stochastic evolutionary game dynamics is used to model a social dilemma where no one has an individual incentive to cooperate, though mutual cooperation would lead to the best outcome for all involved and show how stochastic effects can help make cooperation viable in such a scenario.
The long-term viability of team reasoning
TLDR
This paper investigates the robustness of team reasoning as an explanation for cooperative behavior, by assessing its long-run viability and concludes that team reasoning is an evolutionarily viable mechanism with the potential to explain behavior in a range of human interactions.
The Political Uses of Some Economic Ideas: The Trade‐Off Between Efficiency and Equality
I Introduction The notion of a trade-off between efficiency and equality is pervasive in political economic debates, fundamental to the talk about public policy evaluation, and central to certain
...
...