Realism v. Idealism

  title={Realism v. Idealism},
  author={J. J. C. Smart},
  pages={295 - 312}
  • J. Smart
  • Published 1 July 1986
  • Philosophy
  • Philosophy
It is characteristic of realists to separate ontology from epistemology and of idealists to mix the two things up. By ‘idealists’ here I am mainly referring to the British neo-Hegelians (‘objective idealists’) but the charge of mixing up ontology and epistemology can be made against at least one ‘subjective idealist’, namely Bishop Berkeley, as his wellknown dictum ‘esse ispercipi’ testifies. The objective idealists rejected the correspondence theory of truth and on the whole accepted a… 

Charles Peirce's limit concept of truth

This entry explores Charles Peirce's account of truth in terms of the end or ‘limit’ of inquiry. This account is distinct from – and arguably more objectivist than – views of truth found in other

Regulative Assumptions, Hinge Propositions and the Peircean Conception of Truth

This paper defends a key aspect of the Peircean conception of truth—the idea that truth is in some sense epistemically-constrained. It does so by exploring parallels between Peirce’s epistemology of

On a Dogma Concerning Realism and Incommensurability

It is widely held that realists must accept a strong version of the commensurability of theories, and anti-realists a strong version of the incommensurability of theories. It is the purpose of this

Antirealism and Holes in the World

In the final paragraph of his 'Realism and Idealism',1 J. J. C. Smart suggests that a consequence of the doctrine of semantic (or Dummettian) antirealism is that the universe 'has a lot of fuzzy

Meaning and Metaphysical Realism

In his insightful and erudite 'Realism v. Idealism', Professor Smart argues for an uncompromising metaphysical realism.1 Truth, he believes, may transcend what can be warranted. That is, some

Methodology and Ontology

In a conference in memory of Imre Lakatos it seems appropriate to try to relate my own ontological concerns to the methodological concerns of Lakatos, Popper, and other members of what might loosely

Partial Interpretation, Meaning Variance, and Incommensurability

According to philosophical folklore the thesis that theories partially define their own terms entails the thesis of meaning-variance. Meaning variance in turn is supposed to lead to the thesis of

A Traveller's Guide to Putnam's “Narrow Path”

It is now over 15 years since Hilary Putnam first urged that we take the “narrow path” of internal realism as a way of navigating between “the swamps of metaphysics and the quicksands of cultural

HIV, Employment and the Law: a Socio-Legal Analysis of the Legal Framework

This thesis is an attempt to make a sustained and critical contribution to a particular area of legal scholarship in the field of HIV and AIDS, namely the protection of People Living with HIV or with



Realism and Truth.

Preface to the Second Edition Preface to the First Edition Part I Introduction 1 Introduction Part II Proposals 2 What is Realism? 3 What is Truth? 4 What has Truth to do with Realism? 5 Why be a

The coherence theory of truth

The third well-known theory of truth is the coherence theory which is absolutely irreconcileable with ours, since it holds that the truth of a belief that A is B depends not on whether A is B, but on

Models and reality

  • H. Putnam
  • Philosophy
    Journal of Symbolic Logic
  • 1980
It is argued that the resolution of the antinomy—the only resolution that I myself can see as making sense— has profound implications for the great metaphysical dispute about realism which has always been the central dispute in the philosophy of language.

Essays on Truth and Reality

Preface 1. Introductory 2. Faith 3. On floating ideas and the imaginary 4. On truth and practice 5. On truth and copying 6. On our knowledge or immediate experience 7. On truth and coherence 8.

An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth

Bertrand Russell is concerned in this book with the foundations of knowledge. He approaches his subject through a discussion of language, the relationships of truth to experience and an investigation

Nomological statements and admissible operations

R EV IEW S Nomological Statements and Admissible Operation. By H ans R e ic h en bac h . Pp. 140. 27s. 1954. (North-Holland Publishing Company, A m ster­ dam) In formalised logics the relation of

The Philosophy of F. H. Bradley

This collection of specially written papers on F. H. Bradley's philosophy, newly available in paperback, at last makes accessible the writings of one of England's greatest philosophers. The

The web of belief

Introduction Belief and Change of Belief Observation Self-Evidence Testimony Hypothesis Induction, Analogy, and Intuition Confirmation and Refutation Explanation Persuasion and Evaluation Suggested