Raising the bar: Encouraging high level thinking in online discussion forums

@article{Christopher2004RaisingTB,
  title={Raising the bar: Encouraging high level thinking in online discussion forums},
  author={Mary Marable Christopher and Julie A. Thomas and Mary K. Tallent-Runnels},
  journal={Roeper Review},
  year={2004},
  volume={26},
  pages={166 - 171}
}
More universities are offering online instruction for students though we know little about effective online learning. Some have found online instruction increases student participation while others have reported that students prefer the traditional face‐to‐face format This study of gifted education graduate students follows the expectation that online students ought to have time to be more thoughtful with online course interactions as compared to the time‐constrained interactions in a face‐to… 
Facilitating Students ’ Critical Thinking in Online Discussion : An Instructor ’ s Experience
This paper reported using the practical inquiry model as discourse guide to facilitate students’ critical thinking in online discussion. It was found that almost all the postings of the students who
Facilitating Students' Critical Thinking in Online Discussion: An Instructor's Experience
This paper reported using the practical inquiry model as discourse guide to facilitate students’ critical thinking in online discussion. It was found that almost all the postings of the students who
An examination of the relationships of interaction, learner styles, and course content on student satisfaction and outcomes in online learning
TLDR
The outcomes of this study showed that Participant and Independent learner styles were important factors contributing to the success of online learners, and the ability to demonstrate, analyze, and apply course content was of benefit to learners.
Effects of discussion postings in online elementary statistics community college classes
Online learning in community colleges has grown from experimental status to a reality. In California community colleges, the number of online course sections has been increasing and is expected to
Pre-Service Teachers’ Perceptions of Asynchronous Online Discussion on Blackboard
The purpose of this phenomenological study was to understand students’ perceptions of using asynchronous online discussion as a learning tool. Six pre-service teachers who took a course in
"It's all about conversation"
TLDR
A mixed-methods study with university instructors and students identified five critical pedagogical elements that distinguish the teaching and learning experiences in an open-ended course from that in a non-open-ending course and uncovered open challenges and opportunities.
Student Moderators in Asynchronous Online Discussion: A Question of Questions
Much current research exalts the benefits of having students facilitate weekly discussions in asynchronous online courses. This study seeks to add to what is known about student moderation through an
Analyzing Responses, Moves, and Roles in Online Discussions
There is much debate regarding the value and utility of grading discussions to ensure and assess full participation in the online classroom. Proponents of threaded discussions view it as an integral
Facilitation prompts and rubrics on higher-order thinking skill performance found in undergraduate asynchronous discussion boards
TLDR
Students who were given a scaffold demonstrated higher-level thinking skills more frequently than did students who received no scaffold, and no significant differences in learning achievement associated with test performance were found in test results.
TARGETED INSTRUCTION FOR PRESERVICE TEACHERS: DEVELOPING HIGHER ORDER THINKING SKILLS WITH ONLINE DISCUSSIONS
The purpose of this study was to develop higher order reflective thinking skills and application abilities in preservice teachers, through the use of online asynchronous discussions based on tasks
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 33 REFERENCES
Computer‐mediated communication in the university classroom: An experiment with on‐line discussions
This study examines whether supplementing face‐to‐face discussion with computer‐mediated discussion (CMD) enhances the academic performance of undergraduate students in large lecture courses. It also
Increasing Access to Teacher Preparation: The Effectiveness of Traditional Instructional Methods in an Online Learning Environment
TLDR
Student academic outcomes were the same when instruction was delivered in a traditional classroom or through an online learning environment, and some advantage was found to online discussions in contrast to face-to-face discussions.
Diversity, Discussion, and Participation: Comparing Web-Based and Campus-Based Adolescent Literature Classes.
Professional proliferated during the past few years. Kaplan (1997) reports Web-based courses to be one of the more explosive growth areas on the World Wide Web. For example, the World Lecture Hall
Teaching Online: A Practical Guide
From the Publisher: Suitable for courses in online teaching, web-based instruction, teaching with the Internet, or the online classroom, this book answers the most common questions and concerns of
'Let's You and Me Have a Little Discussion': Computer mediated communication in support of campus-based university courses
Computer mediated communication (CMC) is increasingly used in support of campus-based university courses. This study focuses upon student-student interaction via CMC in the context of an
Teaching Students to Write Literature Reviews: A Meta-Analytic Model
We present an integrated model for teaching students to write psychology literature reviews. Students receive instruction in a sophomore-level research methods class about 5 writing tasks: (a)
On-Line Forums: New Platforms for Professional Development and Group Collaboration
TLDR
The on-line forum was found to be observable, trialable and relatively easy to use (compared with existing tools), indicating that this innovation has potential to become a widespread medium for continuing professional education.
A Course to Develop Competence in Critical Reading of Empirical Research in Psychology
A course designed to train students to read original empirical articles independently and critically is described. The course, conducted as a seminar, uses a case-study approach to help students
Online Social Interchange, Discord, and Knowledge Construction
Online forums provide potential for new forms of collaborative work, study, and community that reduce barriers of time and distance. Yet the types of interaction and means by which individuals create
...
...