Quining Qualia

  title={Quining Qualia},
  author={Daniel C. Dennett},
"Qualia" is an unfamiliar term for something that could not be more familiar to each of us: the ways things seem to us. As is so often the case with philosophical jargon, it is easier to give examples than to give a definition of the term. Look at a glass of milk at sunset; the way it looks to you--the particular, personal, subjective visual quality of the glass of milk is the quale of your visual experience at the moment. The way the milk tastes to you then is another, gustatory quale, and how… 

Figures from this paper

Quining Qualia Quine's Way

Thanks largely to Daniel Dennett, I am a recent convert to what many will regard as the shocking hypothesis that qualia do not exist. This admission is not quite a confident sighting of that rarest

Dennett on qualia: The case of pain, smell and taste

Dennett has maintained that a careful examination of our intuitive notion of qualia reveals that it is a confused notion, that it is advisable to accept that experience does not have the properties


Qualia have historically been thought to stand in a very different epistemological relation to the knower than does the external furniture of the world. The ‘raw feels’ of thought were often said to

Beyond Phenomenal Naiveté

On a natural description of what a mundane visual experience is like for its subject—of its phenomenal character, of how it is phenomenally—such an experience is phenomenally a direct or immediate

On Behalf of Cognitive Qualia

Some cognitive states seem to seem some way. When I am curious about whether p is true, I am in an experiential state rather unlike the experiential state I am in when I doubt that p is true. What is

Qualia, (Private) Language and Experience

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the relationship between qualia and language. Author will begin with the explanation of the nature of qualia using the negative method (second and third


It is often argued that the existence of qualia — private mental objects — shows that physicalism is false. In this paper, I argue that to think in terms of qualia is a misleading way to develop what

Phenomenal Consciousness Must Be Sharp

Is a mosquito phenomenally conscious? This is a difficult question, and it is not clear how we would go about settling it, but one thing it seems we can say, even in our present state of knowledge,

What is it like to be Oscar?

Abstract“Oscar” is going to be the first artificial person — at any rate, he is going to be the first artificial person to be built in Tucson's Philosophy Department. Oscar's creator, John Pollock,

Introduction: QUALIA

This special issue proposes that the semiotically theorized concept of ‘qualia’ is useful for anthropologists working on problems of the senses, materiality, embodiment, aesthetics, and affect.



On the Absence of Phenomenology

We are all, I take it, unshakably sure that we are each in a special position to report, or to know, or to witness or experience a set of something-or-others we may call, as neutrally as possible,

What is it like to be a Bat

Consciousness is what makes the mind-body problem really intractable. Perhaps that is why current discussions of the problem give it little attention or get it obviously wrong. The recent wave of

An Essay concerning Human Understanding

IT is possible to appreciate the reason for this abridged edition of Locke's great Essay and at the same time to regret its appearance. If it had to be done, no living philosopher is so qualified to

The Possibility of Absent Qualia

I Q ydney Shoemaker has defended functionalism against the ab3sent qualia objection.' The purpose of the present paper is to vindicate that objection by refuting Shoemaker's case against it.

The view from nowhere

Human beings have the unique ability to view the world in a detached way: We can think about the world in terms that transcend our own experience or interest, and consider the world from a vantage

Are Dreams Experiences

T HE "received view" of dreams is that they are uperiences that occur duringshtP, experiences which we can often recall upon waking. Enlarged, the received view is that dreams consist ofsensations,

The New York Review of Books

It comes as something ofa surprise to reflect that the New York Review ofBooks is now over twenty years old. Even people of my generation (that is, old enough to remember the revolutionary 196os but

Computation and cognition - toward a foundation for cognitive science

In Computation and Cognition, Pylyshyn argues that computation must not be viewed as just a convenient metaphor for mental activity, but as a literal empirical hypothesis, which must face a number of serious challenges.

What's left of Marx?

'The liberal interpretation is not wrong. It just does not see the beam in its own eye. With the bankruptcy of state socialism, [welfare state liberalism] is the eye of the needle through which

Troubles with functionalism

One characterization of functionalism that is probably vague enough to be acceptable to most functionalists is: each type of mental state is a state consisting of a disposition to act in certain ways