Quantum Logic, Realism, and Value Definiteness

@article{Stairs1983QuantumLR,
  title={Quantum Logic, Realism, and Value Definiteness},
  author={Allen Stairs},
  journal={Philosophy of Science},
  year={1983},
  volume={50},
  pages={578 - 602}
}
  • Allen Stairs
  • Published 1 December 1983
  • Philosophy
  • Philosophy of Science
One of the most interesting programs in the foundations of quantum mechanics is the realist quantum logic approach associated with Putnam, Bub, Demopoulos and Friedman (and which is the focus of my own research.) I believe that realist quantum logic is our best hope for making sense of quantum mechanics, but I have come to suspect that the usual version may not be the correct one. In this paper, I would like to say why and to propose an alternative. 
Weakly Intuitionistic Quantum Logic
TLDR
Von Neumann’s proposal that in quantum mechanics projections can be seen as propositions is followed and the result is a weakly Heyting algebra for describing the language of quantum mechanics.
Speakable in quantum mechanics: babbling on
This paper consists of a short version of the derivation of the intuitionistic quantum logic L_QM (which was originally introduced by Caspers, Heunen, Landsman and Spitters). The elaboration consists
Hermens Weakly Intuitionistic Quantum Logic
In this article von Neumann’s proposal that in quantum mechanics projections can be seen as propositions is followed. However, the quantum logic derived by Birkhoff and von Neumann is rejected due to
Critique of Putnam's quantum logic
Putnam gives a strongly realist account of quantum logic. This has been criticised as suggesting a hidden variable interpretation for quantum mechanics. Friedman and Glymour have done this in the
Quantum Mechanics: From Realism to Intuitionism
The interpretation of quantum mechanics has been a problem since its founding days. A large contribution to the discussion of possible interpretations of quantum mechanics is given by the so-called
Quantum logic as a dynamic logic
TLDR
It is concluded that there is no contradiction between classical logic and (the authors' dynamic reinterpretation of) quantum logic, and that the Dynamic-Logical perspective leads to a better and deeper understanding of the “non-classicality” of quantum behavior than any perspective based on static Propositional Logic.
Individuality, supervenience and Bell's theorem
Some recent work in the philosophy of quantum mechanics has suggested that quantum systems can be thought of as non-separable and therefore non-individual, in some sense, in Bell and E.P.R. type
Speakable in quantum mechanics
TLDR
This paper takes Bohr’s motto seriously and develops a quantum logic that avoids assuming any form of realism as much as possible and discusses how some realist interpretations relate to these logics.
Is logic empirical
The Influence of Quantum Physics on Philosophy
  • F. Muller
  • Philosophy, Physics
    Foundations of Science
  • 2021
We ponder the question whether quantum physics has had any influence on philosophy, and if not, whether it ought to have had any. Answers to these questions are provided, and they turn out to depend
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 28 REFERENCES
On the Problem of Hidden Variables in Quantum Mechanics
The demonstrations of von Neumann and others, that quantum mechanics does not permit a hidden variable interpretation, are reconsidered. It is shown that their essential axioms are unreasonable. It
Quantum Logic, Conditional Probability, and Interference
  • J. Bub
  • Philosophy
    Philosophy of Science
  • 1982
Friedman and Putnam have argued (Friedman and Putnam 1978) that the quantum logical interpretation of quantum mechanics gives us an explanation of interference that the Copenhagen interpretation
Nonlocality and the Kochen-Specker paradox
A new proof of the impossibility of reconciling realism and locality in quantum mechanics is given. Unlike proofs based on Bell's inequality, the present work makes minimal and transparent use of
Quantum Logic and the Luders Rule
In a recent paper, Michael Friedman and Hilary Putnam argued that the Luders rule is ad hoc from the point of view of the Copenhagen interpretation but that it receives a natural explanation within
The Projection Postulate as a Fortuitous Approximation
If we take the state function of quantum mechanics to describe belief states, arguments by Stairs and Friedman-Putnam show that the projection postulate may be justified as a kind of minimal change.
Probability in Quantum Mechanics and in Other Statistical Theories
In the ongoing investigation of the conceptual basis of quantum physics a certain tradition has developed concerning the use of probabilistic concepts. While the necessity for these concepts is
The Projection Postulate: A New Perspective
  • P. Teller
  • Computer Science
    Philosophy of Science
  • 1984
TLDR
It is shown that how to understand the nature of the change of quantum mechanical state on measurement depends very sensitively on the interpretation of the state function, and how attention to this dependence can greatly sharpen the problems and relations between them.
The Possibility Structure of Physical Systems
This paper develops the logical interpretation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics initially proposed by Hilary Putnam [11]. (See also [1] and [2].) The main features of this interpretation are
Metaphysical Problems in the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics
L'exemple de la theorie des quanta montre que les possibilites theoriques developpees par l'imagination pour comprendre les problemes sont depassees par la realite. Les donnees internes du monde reel
Is Logic Empirical
I want to begin by considering a case in which ‘necessary’ truths (or rather ‘truths’, turned out to be falsehoods: the case of Euclidean geometry. I then want to raise the question: could some of
...
...