Quantification of odor quality.

@article{Wise2000QuantificationOO,
  title={Quantification of odor quality.},
  author={Paul M. Wise and Mats J. Olsson and William S. Cain},
  journal={Chemical senses},
  year={2000},
  volume={25 4},
  pages={
          429-43
        }
}
The relationship between odor quality and molecular properties is arguably the most important issue in olfaction. Despite sophistication in the chemical characterization of molecules, accompanying perceptual characterization has had little quantitative usefulness, relying mostly on enumerative description. As a result of weak interest in the topic outside industry and little agreement regarding how to measure quality, the field of olfactory psychophysics has failed to develop a substantial… 

Figures from this paper

Psychometrics of odor quality discrimination: method for threshold determination.
TLDR
The substitution-reciprocity (SURE) method defines a threshold concept for OQD, including the quantification of qualitative change of the stimulus, and suggests how to avoid perceived intensity as an unwanted cue for discrimination.
Understanding smell—The olfactory stimulus problem
  • B. Auffarth
  • Biology, Psychology
    Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews
  • 2013
Odor classification: a review of factors influencing perception-based odor arrangements.
TLDR
This work reviewed 28 perception-based classification studies and found that their outcome has been largely determined by 4 influencing factors: 1) interindividual differences in perceptual and verbal abilities of subjects, 2) stimuli characteristics, 3) approaches of data collection, and 4) methods of data analysis.
PSYCHOLOGIC DIMENSIONS IN THE PERCEPTION OF EVERYDAY ODORS: PLEASANTNESS AND EDIBILITY
ABSTRACT Different studies have reported that when a wide range of odors are assessed at a similar odor intensity, the hedonic dimension (pleasantness) is the most salient. Multivariate statistical
Applying medicinal chemistry strategies to understand odorant discrimination
TLDR
Whereas organic chemistry would have predicted the ring size and composition to be key features, this work reveals that the topological polar surface area is the key feature for the discrimination of these odorants.
Latency and accuracy of discriminations of odor quality between binary mixtures and their components.
TLDR
Latency provided better resolution among pairs of odors than did errors of discrimination, and latency-based similarities between mixtures and their components demonstrated additivity, suggesting that binary mixtures fall on straight lines connecting their components in 'odor-space'.
Hedonic Judgments of Chemical Compounds Are Correlated with Molecular Size
TLDR
The results suggest that larger molecules containing oxygen are more likely to be perceived as pleasant, while the opposite applies to carboxylic acids and sulfur compounds.
Odour concentration affects odour identity in honeybees
TLDR
It is argued that a departure from odour-concentration invariance could be a natural consequence of odour coding and suggested how an ‘intensity feature’ might be useful to the honeybee in natural odour detection and discrimination.
Understanding the underlying dimensions in perfumers’ odor perception space as a basis for developing meaningful odor maps
TLDR
It is suggested that it is possible to develop standard sensory maps of perfumery odor descriptors, if a consensus is first reached regarding which odorants best represent particular odor qualities.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 163 REFERENCES
Individual differences in the perceived intensity and quality of specific odors following self- and cross-adaptation.
TLDR
The web of interactions which give rise to individual differences in perceived odor quality by evaluating the effects of self- and cross-adaptation on the intensity and quality reports elicited by pemenone, androstenone and four other odors in 18 human subjects suggests that the odor quality reports engendered by these substances are multidimensional and that compounds which share the same odor quality label may interact with different perceptual channels.
Psychometrics of odor quality discrimination: method for threshold determination.
TLDR
The substitution-reciprocity (SURE) method defines a threshold concept for OQD, including the quantification of qualitative change of the stimulus, and suggests how to avoid perceived intensity as an unwanted cue for discrimination.
A BUILDING‐BLOCK MODEL FOR THE CHARACTERIZATION OF ODORANT MOLECULES AND THEIR ODORS
  • A. Dravnieks
  • Biology
    Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
  • 1974
TLDR
The present study was conducted to determine if simple paperplane structural formulas, useful as a shorthand for chemical deductions, may contain sufficient information for positive correlations with the principal odor properties, and named models based on this approach were termed building-block models.
DIMENSIONAL SALIENCE OF ODORS
TLDR
Because profile procedures require that the observer relate a test odorant to several different preassigned attributes, the profile itself comes to represent an operational definition of odor quality (although its validity and generality can be severely curtailed by an improper selection of descriptor terms).
Semantic-free scaling of odor quality
A MATCHING‐STANDARDS METHOD FOR CHARACTERIZING ODOR QUALITIES *
  • H. Schutz
  • Psychology
    Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
  • 1964
TLDR
The use of the Crocker-Henderson system, in which it is posited that there are four fundamental odors, is considered, which leaves something to be desired in terms of fatiguing the odor subject and there is no strong evidence of the reliability or validity of the method.
Latency and accuracy of discriminations of odor quality between binary mixtures and their components.
TLDR
Latency provided better resolution among pairs of odors than did errors of discrimination, and latency-based similarities between mixtures and their components demonstrated additivity, suggesting that binary mixtures fall on straight lines connecting their components in 'odor-space'.
EVALUATION OF FAR INFRARED RELATIONS TO ODOR BY A STANDARDS SIMILARITY METHOD *
TLDR
The literature evaluation provided support for Wright’s ( 1954) proposal of a relationship between odor and low-frequency molecular vibrations, and the problems of the literature evaluation concerned the paraffin hydrocarbons for which it was found difficult to make any conclusion.
Odor identification: perceptual and semantic dimensions.
TLDR
Five studies exploring identification of odors as an aspect of semantic memory suggest a research agenda that could include supplemental use of confidence judgments both retrospectively and prospectively in the same subjects to indicate the amount of accessible semantic information.
Perceptual Separability and Integrality in Odor Discrimination a
Sensory characterization of commercial products often requires subjects to analyze odors of mixtures into components, insofar as possible. Subjects presumably accomplish this task more or less
...
...