Public Goods, Private Goods: The American Struggle Over Educational Goals

  title={Public Goods, Private Goods: The American Struggle Over Educational Goals},
  author={David Labaree},
  journal={American Educational Research Journal},
  pages={39 - 81}
  • David Labaree
  • Published 1997
  • Sociology
  • American Educational Research Journal
This article explores three alternative goals for American education that have been at the root of educational conflicts over the years: democratic equality (schools should focus on preparing citizens), social efficiency (they should focus on training workers), and social mobility (they should prepare individuals to compete for social positions). These goals represent, respectively, the educational perspective of the citizen, the taxpayer, and the consumer. Whereas the first two look on… Expand
Educational Governance and Democratic Practice
A preoccupation with academic quality has guided contemporary education reforms in the United States. This is hardly surprising, because political and business elites recognize that well-trained,Expand
Whither the Common Good? A Critique of Home Schooling
This analysis shows home schooling to be part of a general trend of elevating private goods over public goods. The discourse around home schooling centers on issues of individual rights and privateExpand
Whither the Common Good? A Critique of Home Schooling
This analysis shows home schooling to be part of a general trend of elevating private goods over public goods. The discourse around home schooling centers on issues of individual rights and privateExpand
Public education unbounded
  • Ruth Boyask
  • Political Science
  • The New Zealand Annual Review of Education
  • 2021
Green School New Zealand is a private school whose school fees confirm for critics the inequity of private education, but the school may contribute to an alternative vision of public education if itsExpand
The Presidential Platform on Twenty-First Century Education Goals.
As social and economic problems change, so do the goals of education reformers. This content analysis of presidential debates transcripts, state of the union addresses, and education budgets fromExpand
Public Good, Private Good, Positional Good: Globalization and Paradigms of Purposes in U.S. Higher Education
Higher education in the United States historically has been both a public and a private good. Recently, the notion of higher education as a positional good—one that confers status because of itsExpand
Educational Inequality: An Impediment to True Democracy in the United States
Many people believe that democracy is something that can lead everyone toward a better nation and a free and fair society. In 1954, Brown v. Board of Education fundamentally changed the educationExpand
Dissection of a truth regime: the narrowing effects on the public good of neoliberal discourse in the Virginia performance-based funding policy
A major role of all public higher education institutions is to foster the public good. In democratic societies, the public good emphasizes the more collective activities and benefits and howExpand
Education for citizenship in for-profit charter schools?
Most Americans and many residents of other democratic countries hold public schools to the social and political goal of preparing children to be good citizens. This goal is being challenged by someExpand
Politics and school education in Australia : a case of shifting purposes
Purpose – The paper aims to argue that there has been a privileging of the private (social mobility) and economic (social efficiency) purposes of schooling at the expense of the public (democraticExpand


Schooling and Work in the Democratic State.
A new explanation of the relation between schooling and work in the democratic, advanced industrial state emerges from this study that rejects both traditional views and the more recent MarxianExpand
"... the silent compulsions of economic relations": Markets and the Demand for Education
Some recent analyses have argued that public education in the United States has been isolated from market processes and pressures, that the institutional environment of public education has beenExpand
Politics, Markets, and America's Schools
During the 1980s, widespread dissatisfaction with America's schools gave rise to a powerful movement for educational change, and the nation's political institutions responded with aggressive reforms.Expand
An Aristocracy of Everyone: The Politics of Education and the Future of America
In this book, Benjamin Barber sets a new agenda for the debate over education in America. He argues that both sides of the current debate: the elistist, anti-democratic conservatives and the radicalExpand
Reconstructing American Education.
One of the leading historians of education in the United States here develops a powerful interpretation of the uses of history in educational reform and of the relations among democracy, education,Expand
Public Education as Nation-Building in America: Enrollments and Bureaucratization in the American States, 1870-1930
Current discussions of the effects of urbanization and industrialization on the bureaucratization of American public education in the later 19th century do not offer effective explanations of theExpand
The Diverted Dream: Community Colleges and the Promise of Educational Opportunity in America, 1900-1985
In the twentieth century, Americans have increasingly looked to the schools-and, in particular, to the nation's colleges and universities-as guardians of the cherished national ideal of equality ofExpand
The Failure of High Schools and the Progress of Education.
For many Americans, the verdict is in: the high schools are failing. Americans are better educated and have higher standards of living than ever, but popular magazines and academic journals attackExpand
American higher education—Past, present and future
ABSTRACT American higher education is unique in its size and diversity and in its openness to all who gain a high school diploma. This paper describes current trends in enrolments and finance inExpand