Psychology: a Giant with Feet of Clay.

@article{Zagaria2020PsychologyAG,
  title={Psychology: a Giant with Feet of Clay.},
  author={Andrea Zagaria and Agata Ando' and Alessandro Zennaro},
  journal={Integrative psychological \& behavioral science},
  year={2020}
}
The aim of the current study has been to highlight the theoretical precariousness of Psychology. The theoretical precariousness has been evidenced through a review of psychological "core-constructs" whose definitions were thoroughly searched in 11 popular introductory textbooks of psychology edited between 2012 and 2019 and in an APA dictionary of Psychology (VandeBos 2015). This analysis has shown unsatisfactory or discordant definitions of psychological "core-constructs". A further… Expand
Concerning Paradigmatic Status of Psychological Science: For a Flexible and Flowing Psychology in the Face of Practical and Theoretical Challenges
TLDR
It is argued that poly paradigmatic structure of psychology is a virtue, not weakness, and thanks to such a structure, modular, like a Swiss knife, psychology may offer the most effective solutions for a variety of problems. Expand
Moving On Our Feet: For a Nomadic Psychology
  • S. Brinkmann
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2020
TLDR
It is argued that although evolutionary psychology provides many interesting perspectives on the mental life of human beings, it is much too soon to jump to a unifying conclusion for psychology on its basis. Expand
Inching Toward a Unified Metatheory for Psychology
  • M. Mascolo
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2020
TLDR
A unified metatheory must establish a shared psychological lexicon, elaborate a methodology that coordinates first-, second- and third-person modes of inquiry, and develop a process model that describes psychological functioning at the biological, psychological and socio-cultural levels of analysis. Expand
On the Foundations of Psychology: the Problem Is Grammatical, Not Theoretical
  • Martin B Smedlund
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2020
TLDR
Following Wittgenstein, it is argued that the disorganised state of psychology is due to an insufficient sensitivity to the meaning of psychological terms in ordinary language and that the approach best suited to administer this principle is that of cultural psychology. Expand
Is Psychology an ‘Abysmal’ Science? A Review of Rewriting Psychology
  • J. Christensen
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2020
TLDR
This review includes a summary of the main points David Ho states in his new book and moves further into the discussion of ‘successful science' and further elaboration of three main themes: ‘abysmal’ science, the gap between theoretical and applied psychology, and the aim of psychology. Expand
Musings about Metaphors and Models: the Need to Put Psychology Together Again
TLDR
This commentary examines the metaphors and models invoked in the article and suggests alternative perspectives on the grounds that a grand singular solution and consistency in definitions are not urgent requirements for understanding the complexity, diversity, and nuances of the human condition. Expand
Psychology Today: Still in Denial, Still Outdated
  • A. Toomela
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Integrative psychological & behavioral science
  • 2020
TLDR
This paper suggests the psychology misses unifying psychology of a specific kind, which basic principles were outlined by Vygotsky almost a century ago, and is not the best candidate to ground the future of psychology. Expand
The Game of Science and Puzzles of Paradigm
TLDR
This commentary suggests that psychology must step out of its need to follow the acultural Euro-American vision of positivist science, and instead build an enterprise that can be plural, contextually sensitive and incorporate the complexity and interdisciplinarity needed to be truly successful at approaching the human condition. Expand
One Step Further: Where to Put the Subjectivity of Human Mind in Efforts of Integrating Psychology?
TLDR
It is proposed that Karl Marx's thinking on the subjectivity of objective faculties can be the first principle for different schools and sub-disciplines, as it conceptualizes human beings as natural beings but with its consciousness of being from its social praxis, which provides a starting point of humanized psychology. Expand
A Wittgensteinian Comment on “Psychology: A Giant with Feet of Clay” A Question from Research on Creativity
The present comment of the paper by Zagaria, Andò and Zennaro (2020) invests in the possible pragmatic entry of language in the problem of Psychology as a scientific enterprise, concerning theExpand
...
1
2
3
4
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 236 REFERENCES
Unifying psychology: A European view
In this article the vital importance of attempts at unifying psychology is emphasized, the obstacles are analyzed, and an initial strategy is proposed for the treatment of minor “schisms” as well asExpand
From computers to cultivation: reconceptualizing evolutionary psychology
TLDR
It is argued that evolutionary psychology is a mainstream computational theory, and that its arguments for domain-specificity often rest on shaky premises, and it is suggested that the various forms of e-cognition represent a true alternative to standard computational approaches. Expand
Putting the theory before the data: is “massive modularity” a necessary foundation of evolutionary psychology?
TLDR
This volume expands upon Burke's point to argue that the focus on massive modularity as one of the foundational principles of evolutionary psychology is “putting the theory before the data,” and opens the discipline to criticism that is unwarranted for many of its researchers. Expand
Evolutionary Psychology: A New Paradigm for Psychological Science
Psychological science is currently in conceptual disarray, characterized by unconnected mini-theories and isolated empirical findings. We lack a theory of the functional properties of the human mindExpand
Unity in psychology: Possibility or pipedream?
Psychology is becoming an increasingly specialized but fragmented field. Forces within psychology and society at-large have tended to push psychologists apart. It will take a concerted belief in theExpand
“Psychology” or “The Psychological Studies”?
Although I have long focused on the ubiquitous evidences of increasing differentiation and fractionation within psychology (e. g. Koch 1959; 1961; 1964; 1965; 1969a;b; 1971; 1973; 1976; 1985;Expand
Is a Scientific Revolution Taking Place in Psychology?—Doubts and Reservations
We were introduced by Kuhn’ to the notion of scientific progress as a series of qualitative changes, each involving the overthrow of a prevailing paradigm of thought by a new paradigm which altersExpand
Evolutionary psychology. Controversies, questions, prospects, and limitations.
TLDR
This article identifies some of the most common concerns of evolutionary psychology and attempts to elucidate evolutionary psychology's stance pertaining to them, and concludes with a discussion of the limitations of current evolutionary psychology. Expand
Psychoanalysis and cognitive-evolutionary psychology: an attempt at integration.
TLDR
The authors suggest that today the authors are facing a second trauma in the history of psychoanalysis that they might call the 'abandonment of drive theory', i.e. the notion that human beings strive not primarily to reduce sexual and aggressive drives but rather seek objects, assign meanings, test previous beliefs and assimilate new schemes. Expand
Psychology among the Sciences: Comparisons of Numbers of Theories and Laws Cited in Textbooks
A measure called “theories-to-laws ratio” (number of cited theories divided by number of cited laws in textbooks) was used to assess hypotheses concerning the concept of an “hierarchy of sciences”Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...