Prosecutorial Charging Decisions in Sexual Assault Cases: Examining the Impact of a Specialized Prosecution Unit

  title={Prosecutorial Charging Decisions in Sexual Assault Cases: Examining the Impact of a Specialized Prosecution Unit},
  author={Dawn Beichner and Cassia C. Spohn},
  journal={Criminal Justice Policy Review},
  pages={461 - 498}
Although the criminal justice system has undergone reform to eliminate sexual assault case attrition and to improve the overall treatment of sexual assault victims, few studies have examined the effect of these reforms. In this study, the authors examine prosecutorial charging decisions across two unique jurisdictions: Kansas City, Missouri, which utilizes a specialized unit for sexual assault cases, and Miami, Florida, which does not use a specialized unit to determine the effect of… 

Tables from this paper

Policing and prosecuting sexual assault: an examination of arrest and initial filing decisions in cases involving adolescent complainants

Abstract Sexual assault case processing has steadily received increased attention from scholars, with promising implications for the criminal justice system. Despite this increase in attention,

Examining Charging Agreement Between Police and Prosecutors in Rape Cases

Although prior research has contributed to understanding of the factors that influence sexual assault case processing, it has primarily been viewed through the prosecutorial lens. The authors assert

Prosecuting Intimate Partner Sexual Assault

Findings suggest that prosecutors consider both legal and extralegal factors when making charging decisions and that various cultural, legal, and rape myths surrounding IPSA influence these decisions.

Factors Affecting Sexual Assault Case Processing: Charging Through Sentencing in a Large Southern County

Analysis of prosecutorial case files of a large, southern district attorney's office regarding all adult sexual assault cases received over a three-year period indicates that cases with older or Latino defendants, as well as cases involving injury to the victim, were significantly more likely to be charged.

Arrest and Referral Decisions in Sexual Assault Cases: The Influence of Police Discretion on Case Attrition

Research on sexual assault case attrition spans from the decision of victims to report the incidents and cooperate with police during investigations through the final case disposition in the

The impact of race and extra-legal factors in charging defendants with serious sexual assault: Findings from a five-year study of one Pennsylvania court jurisdiction

ABSTRACT Research on sexual assault case processing remains mixed regarding how extra-legal factors such as the racial-ethnic composition of the defendant-victim dyad may impact prosecutorial

Police Reporting Practices for Sexual Assault Cases in Which “The Victim Does Not Wish to Pursue Charges”

Results of this study call for more standardized police reporting practices for cases in which the officer reported the victim chose to drop the case and point to the need for future research into the initial stage of law enforcement involvement in adult sexual assault cases.

Identification, Corroboration, and Charging: Examining the Use of DNA Evidence by Prosecutors in Sexual Assault Cases

This study examines the influence of DNA evidence on prosecutorial decisions in sexual assault cases. Thirty-eight prosecutors experienced with prosecuting sexual violence cases were surveyed

Victim Does Not Wish to Pursue Charges'' Police Reporting Practices for Sexual Assault Cases in Which ''The

Prior research examining sexual assault case attrition has focused on the processing of cases across the justice system. Studies have examined arrest decision making and prosecutorial decision making

When the Perpetrator Is a Partner

This work develops an alternative conceptualization and operationalization of the focal concerns perspective that is more appropriate to IPSA cases and suggests that arrest decisions are motivated by suspect blameworthiness, community protection, and practical constraints and organizational consequences.



Prosecutorial justifications for sexual assault case rejection: Guarding the "gateway to justice"

The decision to charge is a critical stage in the processing of sexual assault cases, as many cases do not proceed beyond this stage. Frohmann (1991) examined prosecutorial justifications for case

The effect of evidence factors and victim characteristics on prosecutors' charging decisions in sexual assault cases

Feminists contend that legally irrelevant victim characteristics determine the outcome of sexual assault cases. They argue that criminal justice officials base their decisions on stereotypes of rape,

Prosecuting sexual assault: A comparison of charging decisions in sexual assault cases involving strangers, acquaintances, and intimate partners

In this study of prosecutors' charging decisions in sexual assault cases, we test the hypothesis that the effect of victim characteristics is conditioned by the relationship between the victim and

Official Reactions to Social Problems: Police Decisions in Sexual Assault Cases

Responsibility for arrest and charging makes police influential agents in the offical processing of sexual-assault cases. Recent research offers three competing models of police decisions: the legal

Sexual assault: The role of prior relationship and victim characteristics in case processing

Using a sample of 467 sexual assault cases, this study analyzes the role of prior relationship and “negative” victim characteristics in accounting for case outcomes from prosecutorial intake to final

The effect of offender and victim characteristics on sexual assault case processing decisions

Previous research testing the sexual stratification hypothesis has demonstrated that the defendant's race interacts with the victim's race to produce harsher sentences for blacks who sexually assault

Prosecutorial discretion in requesting the death penalty: A case of victim-based racial discrimination.

Data from 300 homicides involving an aggravating felony were examined to determine what factors influence the prosecutor's decision to seek the death penalty. It was found that the race of the victim


While social scientists have long been interested in the issue of racial and sexual discrimination within the criminal justice system, they have concentrated on the decisions to convict and sentence