# Proof and pedagogy in ancient China: Examples from Liu Hui's commentary on JIU ZHANG SUAN SHU

@article{Siu1993ProofAP, title={Proof and pedagogy in ancient China: Examples from Liu Hui's commentary on JIU ZHANG SUAN SHU}, author={Man-Keung Siu}, journal={Educational Studies in Mathematics}, year={1993}, volume={24}, pages={345-357} }

Through the discussion of several examples from Liu Hui's commentary on the ancient Chinese mathematical classics JIU ZHANG SUAN SHU this article attempts to illustrate the pedagogical implications embodied therein, mainly the aspects of proof in ancient Chinese mathematics and more generally the role of proofs in mathematics.

## 39 Citations

### Primary sources in the elementary school

- Mathematics
- 2015

The historical texts belong to Liu Hui, a renowned Chinese mathematician of the 3rd century CE. The first one is his commentary (Lay-Yong & Tian-Se, 1986) on a problem of a circular field which is…

### Official Curriculum in Mathematics in Ancient China: How did Candidates Study for the Examination?

- Education
- 2009

This chapter starts with a brief general account of mathematics education in ancient China, then discusses in detail the official curriculum and the state examination system in mathematics in the…

### The Critics and Contributions of Mathematical Philosophy in Hong Kong Secondary Education

- Philosophy, Education
- 2020

Teachers should explain the connectivity between mathematics subjects and others like physics so that lessons will become more interesting rather than a technical one.

### Proof in the Western and Eastern Traditions: Implications for Mathematics Education

- Art
- 2011

As one of the three panellists on the topic of proof within the Western and the Eastern cultural traditions, the author focuses on the ‘algorithmic’ and ‘dialectic’ aspects of doing mathematics with…

### Liu Hui Shares His Views with Young Students

- Education
- 2018

This study reports on the integration of original sources from the history of Chinese mathematics in a class of Greek sixth-grade students. The aims were: to (1) support students’ learning of…

### 1607, a year of (some) significance: Translation of the first European text in mathematics - Elements - into Chinese

- History
- 2011

This paper attempts to look at the historical context that made Elements the first European text in mathematics to be translated in China, and how the translation was received at the time as well as what influence the translated text exerted in various domains in subsequent years, if any, up to the first part of the 20 century.

### When “Mr. Ou (Euclid)” came to China …

- History
- 2012

The Italian Jesuit Matteo Ricci and the Chinese scholar-official XU Guang-qi of the Ming Dynasty collaborated to produce a translation of the first six books of Elements (more precisely, the…

### Mathematics Education in Oriental Antiquity and Middle Ages

- Education
- 2014

Mathematics Education in East and Southeast Asia
Alexei Volkov
This section focuses on the history of mathematics education in China, Taiwan, Korea, and Vietnam, as well as in the political…

### Elements of Ancient Chinese Mathematics for Pre-university Students

- Education
- 2010

The purpose of this study is to investigate the effects of an Ancient Chinese Mathematics Enrichment Programme (ACMEP) on pre-university students' attitudes towards mathematics. A total of 37…

## References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES

### China in the sixteenth century: the journals of Matthew Ricci; 1583 - 1610

- Art
- 1954

period. Out of these tz'u-hua emerged Shui-bu-chuan at the turn of the YuanMing period. The problem of authorship is also touched on in chapter III. After presenting divergent views of various…

### Chinese Mathematics: A Concise History

- Economics
- 1987

The beginnings of mathematics in ancient China (before the Q 'in Dynasty (before 221 BC)). The formation of mathematical systems in ancient China (H `an Dynasty, 206 BC-220 AD). The development of…

### Right-angled triangles in ancient China

- Mathematics
- 1984

The properties associated with the sides of a right-angled triangle had always been a subject of intriguing interest among mathematicians of ancient civilisations. The first and most outstanding of…

### The Mathematical Experience

- Education
- 1981

This edition of the book should find a new generation of general readers and students who would like to know what mathematics is all about and will prove invaluable as a course text for a general mathematics appreciation course, one in which the student can combine an appreciation for the esthetics with some satisfying and revealing applications.

### Neun Bücher arithmetischer Technik

- Philosophy
- 1968

1.
Jetzt hat man ein Feld; 15 Schritt breit 16 Schritt lang. Die Frage ist: Wie gros ist das Feld? Die Antwort sagt: 1 Mou.
2.
Man hat ein anderes Feld; 12 Schritt breit 14 Schritt…

### How to Solve It

- Education
- 1945

Here is a familiar problem having the same or similar unknwn form and here is a problem similar to yours and solved before.