Problems with the concept of capitalism in the social sciences

  title={Problems with the concept of capitalism in the social sciences},
  author={Fred L. Block},
  journal={Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space},
  pages={1166 - 1177}
  • F. Block
  • Published 19 March 2019
  • Economics
  • Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
The paper argues that the term “capitalism” carries with it baggage that interferes with our ability to understand contemporary market economies. The evolution of work in the “varieties of capitalism” literature is used to make the argument that more essentialist modes of analysis win out over those that emphasize variation and contingency. It is argued that analysts should instead use the terminology of variegated societies operating within a capitalist world economy in order to develop a… 

Remodeling capitalism: A return to scale

  • Jennifer Clark
  • Economics
    Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
  • 2019
Fred Block’s proposal, in both the book Capitalism: The Future of an Illusion and his accompanying article in this issue of Environment and Planning A, “Problems with the concept of capitalism in the

Defining capitalism: The case for (relational) abstraction

  • S. Potts
  • Economics
    Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
  • 2019
Fred Block’s book Capitalism: The Future of an Illusion and accompanying commentary in Environment and Planning A push back against the tendency to see “the economy” as fixed, static and separate

Advancing Universalism in Neoliberal Times? Basic Income, Workfare and the Politics of Conditionality

Workfare is an exemplar of neoliberal welfare reform generating precarity. In response, critics have sought to advance a politics of universalism, through either a return to social democracy or the

Problematizing capitalism(s): Big difference?

  • J. Peck
  • Economics
    Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
  • 2019
I have been reading and learning from Fred Block’s work for just about as long as I can remember. Starting when I was a graduate student, his trenchant critiques of Reagan-era social policy occupied

Fred Block, capitalist illusions, inhabiting post-capitalist desires

We welcome Fred Block’s close interrogation of the term ‘capitalism’. Since writing The End of Capitalism (As We Knew It) and initiating what has become the Diverse Economies school of thought, we

Climate Change and Work: Politics and Power

Climate warming is the fundamental challenge of our time, not only because it will radically transform our natural environment but also because it will redefine jobs and livelihoods. This article

Magnetic capitalism

  • G. Mann
  • Education
    Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
  • 2019
As someone who has organized their intellectual life around the study of capitalism, it is an honor to get to respond to a paper by Fred Block. I have been reading Block’s work for more than 20

Book review: Tom McDonald, DARE to DREAM: The memoirs of Tom and Audrey McDonald

There is a tension in analysing the origins of neoliberalism as diverse while implying its outcomes are uniform. There are certainly common elements: declining union membership, rising inequality,

Book review: Elizabeth Humphrys, How Labour Built Neoliberalism: Australia’s Accord, the Labour Movement and the Neoliberal Project

The snapshot of the pervasive exploitation provided in this book might well be confronting for the reader who finds it likely that they are indeed a purchaser and consumer of goods produced by

Geography and the theory of uneven and combined development: Theorizing uniqueness and the return of China

As societal interaction and combination play a vital role in shaping spatio-temporal development paths, meta-theories of uneven development should give way to a relational meta-theory of uneven and



Variegated capitalism

The article critically engages with the `varieties of capitalism' school, which since its origins in the early 1990s has been consolidated into one of the most influential strands in comparative and


As a conceptual apparatus for the analysis of complex historical phenomena, “capitalism” has been a powerful tool for historians of the Atlantic World. Capitalism, used as a concept in the sense

Varieties of Capitalism

Scholarship on varieties of capitalism (VofC) explores the ways in which the institutions structuring the political economy affect patterns of economic performance or policy making and the

The Cultural Contradictions Of Capitalism

* Foreword: 1978 * Introduction/The Disjunction of Realms: A Statement of Themes The Double Bind Of Modernity * The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism * The Disjunctions of Cultural Discourse *

Models of capitalism

Shonfield’s work, 2 which examined the role of various institutions surrounding the economy – various branches of the state, banks, stock exchanges – in a number of Western European countries, the

Behemoth: The Structure and Practice of National Socialism, 1933-1944

Franz Neumann's classic account of the governmental workings of Nazi Germany, first published in 1942, is reprinted in a new paperback edition with an introduction by the distinguished historian

Building Capitalism: The Transformation of the Former Soviet Bloc

Building Capitalism: The Transformation of the Former Soviet Bloc, Anders Aslund. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2002. 508 pp. $27.00 paperback.Since the collapse of the Soviet empire in 1989,

Relational Work and the Law: Recapturing the Legal Realist Critique of Market Fundamentalism

A global financial crisis seems a propitious time to renew a dialogue between legal scholarship and the field of economic sociology. In the 1920s and 1930s, legal realist scholars developed

Same as it Never Was: Temporality and Typology in the Varieties of Capitalism

Perhaps it is simply a generational artifact, but every 10 years or so certain positions in the field of comparative political economy become canonical. I suspect that The Varieties of Capitalism

National diversity and global capitalism

How does globalization change national economies and politics? Are rising levels of trade, capital flows, new communication technologies, and deregulation forcing all societies to converge toward the