Principles Behind Definitions of Diseases – a Criticism of the Principle of Disease Mechanism and the Development of a Pragmatic Alternative

@article{Severinsen2001PrinciplesBD,
  title={Principles Behind Definitions of Diseases – a Criticism of the Principle of Disease Mechanism and the Development of a Pragmatic Alternative},
  author={M. Severinsen},
  journal={Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics},
  year={2001},
  volume={22},
  pages={319-336}
}
  • M. Severinsen
  • Published 2001
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics
  • Many philosophers and medical scientists assume thatdisease categories or entities used to classify concrete cases ofdisease, are often defined by disease mechanisms or causalprocesses. Others suggest that diseases should always be definedin this manner. This paper discusses these standpoints criticallyand concludes that they are untenable, not only when `diseasemechanism' refers to an objective mechanism, but also when`mechanism' refers to a pragmatically demarcated part of thetotal… CONTINUE READING
    17 Citations

    Topics from this paper

    The Naturalization of the Concept of Disease
    • 14
    What are chronic diseases?
    • 9
    On the reconceptualization of Alzheimer’s disease
    • 12
    Genetics, Neuroscience and Psychiatric Classification
    • 13
    Advertisement for the ontology for medicine
    • J. Simon
    • Philosophy, Medicine
    • Theoretical medicine and bioethics
    • 2010
    • 9

    References

    SHOWING 1-10 OF 24 REFERENCES
    Causation in Medicine: The Disease Entity Model
    • 68
    • Highly Influential
    Definition and classification of cancer: Monothetic or polythetic?
    • P. Vineis
    • Biology, Medicine
    • Theoretical medicine
    • 1993
    • 15
    What is diagnosis? Some critical reflections
    • 17
    • Highly Influential
    Hematopathology: integration of morphologic features and biologic markers for diagnosis.
    • E. Jaffe
    • Medicine
    • Modern pathology : an official journal of the United States and Canadian Academy of Pathology, Inc
    • 1999
    • 41
    World Health Organization Classification of lymphomas: a work in progress.
    • 104
    Dis-ease about kinds: reply to D'Amico.
    • L. Reznek
    • Philosophy, Medicine
    • The Journal of medicine and philosophy
    • 1995
    • 13
    Is disease a natural kind?
    • R. D'Amico
    • Philosophy, Medicine
    • The Journal of medicine and philosophy
    • 1995
    • 27
    Molecular genetics, reductionism, and disease concepts in psychiatry.
    • 16