Preference versus performance: Investigating the dissociation between objective measures and subjective ratings of usability for schematic metro maps and intuitive theories of design

  title={Preference versus performance: Investigating the dissociation between objective measures and subjective ratings of usability for schematic metro maps and intuitive theories of design},
  author={Maxwell J. Roberts and Hannah Gray and Jennifer Lesnik},
  journal={Int. J. Hum. Comput. Stud.},

Tables from this paper

Us Versus Them: Ensuring Practical and Psychological Utility of Measurements of Schematic Map Usability

Measures of schematic map usability should have practical utility – i.e. connection with real-world issues – and psychological utility – i.e. connection with aspects of usability that users consider

Effect of Compositions of MRT System Route Maps on Cognitive Mapping

The results indicated that the route map composed of all curves resulted in higher user performance than maps using a hybrid system and the conventional octilinear system, and adding travel time information to a route map effectively enhances users’ decision-making during route planning.

How Usability Can Save the Day - Methodological Considerations for Making Automated Driving a Success Story

The present paper gives impetus to the process of developing robust methods for evaluating Human-Machine Interfaces (HMI) for L3 ADS and recommends multi-method approach in user research.

A Survey on Computing Schematic Network Maps: The Challenge to Interactivity

This study surveys up-to-date algorithmic approaches in schematic network mapping to give an overview of the state of the art and investigates the hypothesis that the choice of algorithmic approach is often guided by the requirements of the mapping application.

Automated generation of concentric circles metro maps using mixed-integer optimization

This article develops an automatic CC map drawing method by adopting map design criteria as a mixed-integer programming problem and offers new insights into the schematic drawing of metro systems that can improve map readability and engagement.

Metro Map Colour-Coding: Effect on Usability in Route Tracing

Overall, it was found that route colouring was significantly more accurate than the trunk- and shaded-colouring schemes, but a planned subset analysis revealed major differences between specific navigational hazards.

Evaluating schematic route maps in wayfinding tasks for in-car navigation

The experimental data shows that participants using the schematic route maps require fewer map interactions to complete the tasks, orientation information is more visible and leads to more accurate spatial knowledge acquisition, which contributes to a better understanding of schematic route visualizations’ benefits to support users in wayfinding and orientation tasks.

The Decade of Diagrams

Schematisation techniques have been applied to maps for centuries, but came to the fore with designs for urban rail networks. Here, the dual role of maps as both wayfinding aids and also publicity

Preference-Performance Dissociation in Golf Putting

The findings suggest that while providing autonomy – that is, when the participant is able to choose for him/herself – can improve motor learning, there may be a dissociation between an individual’s subjective assessment and the actual helpfulness of a visual aid.

East or West ? Map Design and Passenger Path Decisions on Mass Transit Networks

Working on the south part of the RER D line in Paris suburbs, the objective is to understand how network maps can benefit from incorporating travellers’ mental mapping of space and time independently of objective measures of spatial and durational properties.



From reasoning and intelligence research to information design: Understanding and optimising the usability and acceptability of schematic transit maps

In this chapter, it is argued that schematic maps are misunderstood by many designers, leading to poorly optimised results, and that the situation is exacerbated by a low correlation between subjective evaluations of design effectiveness, and objective measures of actual usability.

Radi(c)al Departures: Comparing Conventional Octolinear Versus Concentric Circles Schematic Maps for the Berlin U-Bahn/S-Bahn Networks Using Objective and Subjective Measures of Effectiveness

An experiment is reported in which two designs of Berlin U-/S-Bahn network maps were compared for usability, and performance was worse for the concentric circles map, and it received poor ratings.

Mind the Gap

This paper explores the effects of iconic, abstract representations of complex objects on our interactions with those objects through an ethnographic study of the use of the London Underground Map to

A comparison of spatial knowledge acquisition with maps and mobile maps

Do People Prefer Curved Objects? Angularity, Expertise, and Aesthetic Preference

Do people prefer curved lines, shapes, and objects over angular lines, shapes, and objects? Angularity is one of the oldest variables in the psychology of aesthetics, but past research has not always

Visual aesthetics and human preference.

The results of the review support the conclusion that aesthetic response can be studied rigorously and meaningfully within the framework of scientific psychology.

Becksploitation: The Over-use of a Cartographic Icon

Abstract When one thinks of a map depicting London, generally the image that appears is that of the map designed by Henry (Harry) Beck (1902–1974). It has become a design icon despite the fact that