• DOI:10.1007/S11007-012-9233-X
• Corpus ID: 159715427

Potentia absoluta et potentia ordinata Dei: on the theological origins of Carl Schmitt’s theory of constitution

@article{Ojakangas2012PotentiaAE,
  title={Potentia absoluta et potentia ordinata Dei: on the theological origins of Carl Schmitt’s theory of constitution},
  author={Mika Ojakangas},
  journal={Continental Philosophy Review},
  year={2012},
  volume={45},
  pages={505-517}
}

• Mika Ojakangas
• Published 11 December 2012
• Philosophy
• Continental Philosophy Review

In line with his theory of secularization according to which all significant concepts of the modern theory of the state are secularized theological concepts, Carl Schmitt argues in Constitutional Theory that people’s (Volk) constitution-making power in modern democracy is analogical to God’s potestas constituens in medieval theology. It is also undoubtedly possible to find a resemblance between Schmitt’s constitution-making power and God’s power as it is described in medieval theology. In the same sense as the constitution-making power is absolutely free from all normative ties, God’s potestas constituens, or rather, God’s potentia absoluta is free from such ties. Yet, unlike the Schmittian constitution-making power, God’s potentia absoluta was not, in medieval theology, originally intended as a description of some form of divine action: the absolute power of God referred to the total possibilities initially open to God. However, when the canonists started to employ the term potentia absoluta in their speculations concerning the papal plenitude of power (plenitude potestatis) by the end of the thirteenth century, they used it in a different sense than the theologians previously. According to certain canonists, the pope, by his potentia absoluta, could grant de facto dispensations from divine and ecclesiastical laws. Later on, this notion became a theological notion as well, but given its origin in juridical discourse, the constitution-making power, rather than being a secularized theological notion, is a theologized juristic notion.