Post-Post-Truth: An Adaptationist Theory of Journalistic Verism

  title={Post-Post-Truth: An Adaptationist Theory of Journalistic Verism},
  author={Yigal Godler},
  journal={Communication Theory},
  • Yigal Godler
  • Published 1 May 2020
  • Sociology
  • Communication Theory
In the age of post-truth, media studies find themselves trapped between the desire to restore journalism’s authority as a veristic (truth-seeking) institution and the lack of a coherent, applicable and consensual theory of truth. In order to develop such a theory of truth, this study bases itself on a detailed picture of how a sample of mainstream Israeli journalists covered 20 cases of factual controversies, drawing on journalists’ own accounts of their work, an independent analysis of… Expand
1 Citations
On post-truth and correctness over the Web
The extension of previous work done on “the Web as a tool for proving” is proposed to suggest a basis for a meta-theory for post-truth, which cannot be based on the current philosophical theories about truth such as the correspondence theory, the coherence theories, the pragmatic theory or the consensus theory. Expand


How Journalists “Realize” Facts
The degree to which journalists realize their most basic societal role and provide fact-based accounts has been a point of contestation between several camps. While adherents to the notion of theExpand
News Cultures or “Epistemic Cultures”?
In order to gain an understanding of journalists’ conceptions of what being factual means, the present work supplements the existing insights of journalism studies and the sociology of knowledge andExpand
Since the nineteenth century, the theory of objectivity has been considered a cornerstone principle of journalism. However, during the last decades of the twentieth century, both communicationExpand
How Journalists Visualize Fact
Fact is a product of the communication practices of journalists. Journalists rarely have the resources or access to penetrate their sources' informational worlds to establish facts independently.Expand
When facts, truth, and reality are God‐terms: on journalism's uneasy place in cultural studies
This article tracks the uneasy coexistence of journalism and cultural studies, arguing that the tensions between the two fields have worked to mutual disadvantage. The article suggests thatExpand
On the Relevance of Standpoint Epistemology to the Practice of Journalism: The Case for “Strong Objectivity”
This paper interrogates traditional notions of journalistic “objectivity” and its interpretation in conventional news reporting. I argue here that the underlying principles of objectivity devolve inExpand
Between Rhetoric and Practice
A large body of research in journalism studies has analyzed which social and political roles news professionals consider they must fulfill in society. These studies are based on the assumption thatExpand
A realist point of view on news journalism
This article confronts the antirealist analysis of news journalism by introducing a realist perspective based on an application and an extension of some of John Searle's ideas on the subject. ThisExpand
This article builds on initial arguments about the advantages of using Critical Realism as an underpinning ontology in Journalism Studies, by discussing its compatibility with practical journalisticExpand
Custodians of Conscience: Investigative Journalism and Public Virtue
This book is the culmination of more than a decade of research and writing on the nature of investigative journalism as a form of social and moral inquiry. Focusing on the work of a number ofExpand