Policing the Boundaries of Sex: A Critical Examination of Gender Verification and the Caster Semenya Controversy

@article{Cooky2013PolicingTB,
  title={Policing the Boundaries of Sex: A Critical Examination of Gender Verification and the Caster Semenya Controversy},
  author={Cheryl Cooky and Shari L Dworkin},
  journal={The Journal of Sex Research},
  year={2013},
  volume={50},
  pages={103 - 111}
}
On August 19, 2009, Caster Semenya, South African track star, won a gold medal in the women's 800-meter event. According to media reports, on the same day, the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) ordered Semenya to undergo gender verification testing. This article critically assesses the main concepts and claims that undergird international sport organizations' policies regarding “gender verification” or “sex testing.” We examine the ways in which these policies operate… 

In the Halfway House of Ill Repute: Gender Verification under a Different Name, Still No Contribution to Fair Play

The aftermath of Caster Semenya’s resounding victory in the women’s 800 m at the 2009 Athletics World Championships in Berlin highlighted the ethical and scientific flaws of gender verification in

‘Preserving la difference’: the elusiveness of sex-segregated sport

  • L. Pieper
  • Sociology
    Sex Integration in Sport and Physical Culture
  • 2018
Abstract Sport is founded upon a belief in dimorphic sex, dichotomous gender and segregated competition. To uphold these binaries, sport authorities repeatedly relied upon medico-scientific

When does an advantage become unfair? Empirical and normative concerns in Semenya’s case

TLDR
The pharmacological solution put forward by IAAF to the tension between fairness and inclusivity of bodies non-conforming to two sexes is not the only possible solution/resolution to the case, as it is shown in this paper.

Hurdling Over Sex? Sport, Science, and Equity

TLDR
Recommendations are made on ways to improve justice for athletes within the bounds of the current hyperandrogenism policy, including suggestions to clarify the purpose of the policy and to ensure privacy and confidentiality.

Global injustice in sport: The Caster Semenya ordeal - prejudice, discrimination and racial bias.

  • S. MahomedA. Dhai
  • Education
    South African medical journal = Suid-Afrikaanse tydskrif vir geneeskunde
  • 2019
TLDR
In its many decades of harsh scrutiny of successful female athletes, especially those from backgrounds similar to Semenya's, the IAAF has disrespected human rights and medical ethics and allowed prejudice, discrimination and injustice to infringe on their dignity and relentlessly obstruct their international sporting careers.

To Be a Woman in the World of Sport: Global Regulation of the Gender Binary in Elite Athletics

Indian sprinter Dutee Chand made headlines and history when she successfully challenged the validity of an international rule of athletics that disqualified her from competition because of the

Reassembling sex: reconsidering sex segregation policies in sport

ABSTRACT Over the last decade, cases such as Caster Semenya’s have drawn attention to the problematic nature of sex segregation policies in elite sporting competition. Several authors have emphasised

Unwarranted and Invasive Scrutiny: Caster Semenya, Sex-Gender Testing and the Production of Woman In ‘Women’s’ Track and Field

This article discusses the imbrication of racialising and sexualising scientific practices of gender testing and verification in elite athletics competition, and their intersection with social

Liars, Cheaters, and Short-Haired Girls: Gender Identity Denial of Young Athletes

Gender-based discrimination in sport is omnipresent and manifests in various forms, including unequal pay, disparate access to facilities, and imbalanced media exposure. This discrimination also

On the Eurocentric nature of sex testing: the case of Caster Semenya

ABSTRACT Black masculinity and femininity have been read outside the normative gender sphere since plantation slavery. The construction of Black femininity, is apparent in the treatment of Caster
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 54 REFERENCES

Sport, Sex Segregation, and Sex Testing: Critical Reflections on This Unjust Marriage

TLDR
In this commentary, it is revealed how sex testing cannot be disentangled from sex segregation, and the authors inadvertently reinforce gender injustice in sport.

Sex Tested, Gender Verified: Controlling Female Sexuality in the Age of Containment

cern of this paper: the emergence and control of modern sexuality, specifically the socio-historical construction of the sexual body in sport. What follows is the history of a sport policy. The

Caster Semenya: sport, categories and the creative role of ethics

TLDR
Caster Semenya's case has implications for the ethics of sports and debates about gender and enhancement, and for the philosophical debate about the nature of categories and the classification of people.

The history and current policies on gender testing in elite athletes : review article

TLDR
The abandonment of compulsory sex verification tests of female athletes was followed by most international sports federations, and in the end also by the International Olympic Committee (IOC), although initially only provisionally.

Gender verification of female athletes

TLDR
The history and rationales for fairness in female-only sports that have led to the rise and fall of on-site, chromosome-based gender verification at international sporting events are reviewed.

Gender verification of female Olympic athletes.

TLDR
The new policy advocated by the IAAF, and conditionally adopted by the International Olympic Committee, protects the rights and privacy of athletes while safeguarding fairness of competition, and the American Medical Association recommends that it become the permanent approach.

Beyond the Caster Semenya Controversy: The Case of the Use of Genetics for Gender Testing in Sport

TLDR
The historical steps of gender verification in the Olympics, the violation of genetic counseling principles in Caster Semenya’s case, and some reflections on the complexity of the genetics of Disorders of sex development (DSD) are critically examined.

Essay: Gender verification of female athletes

An approach to the biological, historical and psychological repercussions of gender verification in top level competitions

Martinez-Patino MJ, Mateos-Padorno C, Martinez-Vidal A, Sanchez AM, Garcia JL, Diaz MP, Tourino CF. An approach to the biological, historical and psychological repercussions of gender verification in

Gender Verification in Competitive Sports

TLDR
Sex chromatin testing unfairly excludes many athletes because of the current use of urine testing to exclude doping, and still fails to address the fundamental inequities of laboratory based gender verification tests.
...