Plan S in Latin America: A Precautionary Note

@article{Debat2019PlanSI,
  title={Plan S in Latin America: A Precautionary Note},
  author={Humberto Julio Debat and Dominique Babini},
  journal={Scholarly and Research Communication},
  year={2019}
}
  • H. Debat, D. Babini
  • Published 1 July 2019
  • Political Science
  • Scholarly and Research Communication
Background  Latin America has historically led a vital and open access movement and leads the worldwide region with the adoption of wider open access practices. Argentina has expressed its commitment to join Plan S, an initiative from a European consortium of research funders with a mandate to promote the open access publishing of scientific outputs. Analysis  This opinion article suggests that the potential adhesion of Argentina or other Latin American nations to Plan S ignores the reality… 

Evaluating institutional open access performance: Methodology, challenges and assessment

TLDR
A minimum reporting standard is proposed and a large-scale analysis of open access progress across 1,207 institutions world-wide that shows substantial progress being made is presented, detects responses that coincide with policy and funding interventions and presents a top-100 of global universities.

Ciencia abierta: un modelo con piezas por encajar

TLDR
Despite the excellent progress in open access and remarkable sharing of research data and respectable use of preprints, little progress has been made in defining and establishing new metrics and new evaluation models, even though they are a key element to incentivize the expansion of Open Science in all disciplines.

Evaluating the impact of open access policies on research institutions

TLDR
It was found that, in 2017, the top-performing universities published around 80–90% of their research open access, and that publisher-mediated (gold) open access was popular in Latin American and African universities, whereas the growth of open access in Europe and North America has mostly been driven by repositories.

Government AI Readiness Meta-Analysis for Latin America And The Caribbean

TLDR
Current issues with existing evaluation criteria for AI readiness are discussed and factors and considerations essential to LAC countries as they embrace the AI revolution are expanded.

Cobrar por publicar en revistas académicas, una amenaza al ecosistema latinoamericano no comercial

The characteristics of the 123 Latin American journals that charge for publishing found in DOAJ are shown in this study. These characteristics are country of origin, languages ​​of publication, group

Plan S en América Latina: una nota de precaución

El Plan S es una iniciativa de un consorcio europeo de financiadores de investigacion orientada a exigir la publicacion en acceso abierto de los resultados de la investigacion financiados por fondos

Opening the record of science: making scholarly publishing work for science in the digital era

  • G. Boulton
  • Education
    Septentrio Conference Series
  • 2020
There is increasing concern about the extent to which the modern system of scientific and scholarly publishing serves the best interests of science. The International Science Council, as the global

Transformative agreements: Six myths, busted: Lessons learned

Transformative agreement (TA) is an umbrella term used to describe contracts between institutions and publishers intended to transform the current, primarily subscription-based, journal publishing

Journal editors and journal indexes: Internationalization pressures in the semi‐periphery of the world of science

TLDR
The article highlights the current tensions that indexation brings for the journals and some strategies to cope with them, the negotiation processes with their traditional audiences, and the conflicts that emerge in the current internationalization processes led by international scientific indexes.

On the geopolitics of academic publishing: the mislocated centers of scholarly communication

ABSTRACT Knowledge production is an important factor in establishing the geopolitical position of countries. In the recent heated discussion on predatory publishing, the geopolitical dimension of

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 84 REFERENCES

Open Access in Latin America: a Paragon for the Rest of the World

SciELO is a remarkable decentralized publishing platform harboring over 1,200 peer-reviewed journals from fifteen countries located in four continents South America. Central-North America, Europe and

The End of a Centralized Open Access Project and the Beginning of a Community-Based Sustainable Infrastructure for Latin America: Redalyc.org after Fifteen Years

The Latin American region has an ecosystem where the nature of publication is conceived as the act of making public, of sharing and not as the publishing industry. International, national and

Will Plan S put learned societies in jeopardy?

TLDR
The European Union and European Research Council, together with 13 European research funding organizations and 3 charitable foundations, have now accelerated the pace of change, with their Plan S, which will require researchers receiving funds from these organizations from 2020 to publish their work in open access journals and on platforms that are compliant with the rules of Plan S.

Latin American science is meant to be open access

TLDR
The reasons behind the emergence of OA in the region are summarized, details and data about the most relevant initiatives are offered and some of the current challenges to keep advancing in this arena are discussed.

Plan S: Unrealistic capped fee structure

TLDR
The developers of Plan S should seek closer relations with scientific societies and help to strengthen society-backed publication venues to achieve truly affordable and open scientific publication strategies.

Plan S en América Latina: una nota de precaución

El Plan S es una iniciativa de un consorcio europeo de financiadores de investigacion orientada a exigir la publicacion en acceso abierto de los resultados de la investigacion financiados por fondos

Opinion: “Plan S” falls short for society publishers—and for the researchers they serve

  • M. McNutt
  • Education
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
  • 2019
TLDR
The chief executive of a membership organization that publishes a highly regarded society journal and sees merit in redirecting publishing profits to enhance the welfare of the research community through the variety of society programs that support students, underrepresented minorities, community engagement, and other worthy causes.

Scientific societies worry about threat from Plan S.

TLDR
Nonprofit societies worry that an alternative supported by Plan S—allowing grantees to publish in journals that offer immediate open access and charge authors to publish there—will force them to publish more articles to maintain income, potentially lowering quality.

Assessing the size of the affordability problem in scholarly publishing

For many decades, the hyperinflation of subscription prices for scholarly journals have concerned scholarly institutions. After years of fruitless efforts to solve this “serials crisis”, open access

Few Open Access Journals Are Compliant with Plan S

TLDR
It is concluded that a large majority of open access journals are not Plan S-compliant, and that it is small publishers in the humanities and social sciences not charging article processing charges (APC) that will face the largest challenge with becoming compliant.
...