Pirate open access as electronic civil disobedience: Is it ethical to breach the paywalls of monetized academic publishing?

@article{James2020PirateOA,
  title={Pirate open access as electronic civil disobedience: Is it ethical to breach the paywalls of monetized academic publishing?},
  author={Jack E. James},
  journal={Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology},
  year={2020},
  volume={71},
  pages={1500 - 1504}
}
  • J. E. James
  • Published 24 February 2020
  • Education
  • Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology
Open access has long been an ideal of academic publishing. Yet, contrary to initial expectations, cost of access to published scientific knowledge increased following the advent of the Internet and electronic processing. An analysis of the ethicality of current arrangements in academic publishing shows that monetization and the sequestering of scientific knowledge behind paywalls breach the principle of fairness and damage public interest. Following decades of failed effort to redress the… 
Transfer of Research through Academic Publishing and the Use of OA Resources: A Survey
Abstract The cycle of scholarly communication is perpetuated by those who create, evaluate, disseminate, and consume research. This paper distinguishes that the stakeholders most directly involved in
Free access to scientific literature and its influence on the publishing activity in developing countries: The effect of Sci‐Hub in the field of mathematics
This paper investigates whether free access to scientific literature increases the participation of under‐represented groups in scientific discourse. To this end, we aggregate and match data tracing
Scientists are Working Overtime and at the Weekends: Comparison of Publication Downloading from Copyrighted and Pirated Platforms
TLDR
This study track and analyze publication downloads from both copyrighted and pirated platforms to reconstruct scientists' activity patterns from a holistic perspective and finds that when scientists are working overtime, they prefer to use Sci-Hub rather than copyrighted platforms to access scholarly publications.
Analysis of requests for journals Nature Food and npj Science of Food by the data of the SCI-HUB service for the first half of 2020
  • V. Kornienko
  • Computer Science
    Theory and practice of meat processing
  • 2020
TLDR
The history of Sci-Hub service requests for two food industry journals Nature Food and npj Science of Food for the period from 1.01.2020 to 29.06.2020 is analyzed to make a conclusion that the popularity of papers related to the food industry is relatively low compared to other papers, which is a paradoxical situation.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 46 REFERENCES
Free‐to‐publish, free‐to‐read, or both? Cost, equality of access, and integrity in science publishing
  • J. E. James
  • Political Science
    J. Assoc. Inf. Sci. Technol.
  • 2017
TLDR
Emerging trends indicate the need for material and human resources to be redirected away from Gold and toward Green OA, which will reduce total publication costs, increase equality of access for authors and readers, and remove the financial incentives that have encouraged poor and corrupt publishing practices.
Rethinking Civil Disobedience as a Practice of Contestation—Beyond the Liberal Paradigm
Across the political spectrum, many people— journalists, politicians, but also activists and theorists— seem to think there is something fundamentally wrong with civil disobedience. Some consider it
Sci-Hub: What Librarians Should Know and Do about Article Piracy
  • Matthew B Hoy
  • Computer Science
    Medical reference services quarterly
  • 2017
TLDR
Sci-Hub is a “pirate” article site that offers instant access to more than 58 million journal articles but users attracted by the ease of use and breadth of the collection may not realize that these articles are often obtained using stolen credentials and downloading them may be illegal.
Plan S: A threat to quality of science?
TLDR
Using only open-access journals will negatively affect the activities of professional societies, according to members of the International Union of Basic and Clinical Pharmacology, the worldwide body for pharmacological societies.
Civil Desobedience: Litmus Test for the Democratic Constitutional State
In the introductory essay to the volume Theory and Practice (Boston, 1973), Habermas describes his intellectual project as an attempt to "develop the idea of a theory of society conceived with
Plan S: Motivations of for-profit publishers
Recent EU policies known as Plan S require researchers funded with EU grants to publish in open-access journals to make articles more publicly accessible (“European funders seek to end reign of
Scientific societies worry about threat from Plan S.
TLDR
Nonprofit societies worry that an alternative supported by Plan S—allowing grantees to publish in journals that offer immediate open access and charge authors to publish there—will force them to publish more articles to maintain income, potentially lowering quality.
Should I stay or should I go? Alternative infrastructures in scholarly publishing
For more than three-and-a-half centuries, the scholarly infrastructure—composed of commercial publishers, learned societies, libraries, and the scholars themselves—has provided the foundation
Science without publication paywalls: cOAlition S for the realisation of full and immediate Open Access
TLDR
A group of national funders, joined by the European Commission and the European Research Council, announce plans to make Open Access publishing mandatory for recipients of their agencies’ research funding.
Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone.
TLDR
The Sci-Hub data provide the first detailed view of what is becoming the world's de facto open-access research library, and among the revelations that may surprise both fans and foes alike: Sci- hub users are not limited to the developing world.
...
...