Pictorial Illustrations Still Improve Students' Learning from Text

@article{Carney2002PictorialIS,
  title={Pictorial Illustrations Still Improve Students' Learning from Text},
  author={Russell N. Carney and Joel R. Levin},
  journal={Educational Psychology Review},
  year={2002},
  volume={14},
  pages={5-26}
}
Research conducted primarily during the 1970s and 1980s supported the assertion that carefully constructed text illustrations generally enhance learners' performance on a variety of text-dependent cognitive outcomes. Research conducted throughout the 1990s still strongly supports that assertion. The more recent research has extended pictures-in-text conclusions to alternative media and technological formats and has begun to explore more systematically the “whys,” “whens,” and “for whoms” of… 
When Do Pictures Help Learning from Expository Text? Multimedia and Modality Effects in Primary Schools
TLDR
Overall, pictures enhanced learning but that the text should be spoken rather than written, in line with instructional design principles derived from common multimedia learning theories.
What Makes a Diagram Easy or Hard? The Impact of Diagram Design on Fourth-Grade Students’ Comprehension of Science Texts
This experimental study examined how the presence of visual diagrams in 2 science texts affected the independent reading comprehension of 213 fourth-grade students in the southeastern United States.
The Importance of Diagrams, Graphics and Other Visual Representations in STEM Teaching
TLDR
This chapter argues that schools fail to grasp the significance of the visual nature of communication and the implications for learning within STEM subjects, and provides an extensive review of the cognitive and psychological literature covering various key aspects of visualisation and how it relates to teaching STEM subjects in early secondary education.
Teachers' use of visual representations in the science classroom
In the current science education literature, most of the attention has focused on understanding the impact visual representations in textbooks and multimedia materials have on students and their
Do Pictorial Mnemonic Text-learning Aids Give Students Something Worth Writing About?
In 2 experiments, college students read a historical passage on aspects of human intelligence. Students were randomly assigned to 2 different instructional conditions to process the passage:
Cognitively demanding learning materials with texts and instructional pictures: teachers’ diagnostic skills, pedagogical beliefs and motivation
Learning materials incorporating written texts as well as instructional pictures are the basis for learning in many subjects. However, text–picture integration makes high cognitive demands of
Ebook presentation styles and their impact on the learning of children
TLDR
The results of this experiment showed that 11-year-old children attained their highest scores in both tests with the ebook that contained representational pictures and that they benefitted from the decorative style more than text only in retention test.
Young primary students making sense of text and illustrations about how refuse can become soil
Explanatory pictures and models are frequently used in teaching and learning situations. However, it seems to be simply assumed that they are always beneficial. In this article results from an
The impact of argument-based learning environments on early learners multimodal representations
TLDR
The purpose of this study is to investigate the impact of using an argument-based inquiry (ABI) approach on young children’s scientific representational competencies as indexed by their ability to effectively convey their understanding of science knowledge in a multimodal summary writing task.
Use Of Graphics In Multimedia Instructional Materials: Research Based Design Guidelines
TLDR
Current cognitive theory and the design heuristics that have been derived from it on the use of multimedia elements—especially graphics—in instructional materials are explored.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 80 REFERENCES
Increasing picture effects in learning from illustrated text
Can Questions Facilitate Learning from Illustrated Science Texts
This research examines the effectiveness of using questions to facilitate processing of diagrams in science texts. Three studies assessed college students' learning from science passages with
Systematic Thinking Fostered by Illustrations in Scientific Text
In 2 experiments, students who lacked prior knowledge about car mechanics read a passage about vehicle braking systems that either contained labeled illustrations of the systems, illustrations
Using extended captions to improve learning from instructional illustrations
This article examines two strategies for improving the effectiveness of illustrations in text. Descriptive captions repeated the contents of illustrations verbally, whereas instructive captions
SECTIONAL DRAWINGS FROM SCIENCE TEXTBOOKS: AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION INTO PUPILS' UNDERSTANDING
Summary. This paper examines aspects of children's understanding of illustrations used as an adjunct to learning. It reports an experiment designed to determine whether first-year secondary school
Is an Illustration Always Worth Ten Thousand Words? Effects of Prior Knowledge, Learning Style and Multimedia Illustrations on Text Comprehension
TLDR
Results indicate that effects of text supplementation are mediated by priorknowledge and learning style: multimedia appears more beneficial to surface learners with little prior knowledge and makes little or no difference for knowledgable achievers or deep learners.
How Picture Books Work: A Semiotically Framed Theory of Text-Picture Relationships
Lawrence R. Sipe is an assistant professor in the reading/writing/ literacy program at the University of Pennsylvania's Graduate School of education, where he teaches courses in literature for
Effects of text illustrations: A review of research
TLDR
Research in closely related fields (involving, for example, nonrepresentational pictures, graphic organizers, learner-produced drawings) is looked at, offering guidelines for practice.
Illustrations, Text, and the Child Reader: What are Pictures in Children's Storybooks for?
Picture books are profusely illustrated books in which the illustrations are, to varying degrees, essential to the en joyment and understanding of the story (Tomlinson and Lynch-Brown, 1996). As the
A Concrete Strategy for Remembering Abstract Prose
In four experiments, eighth-grade students were given short prose passages that described the distinguishing attributes of fictitious towns. Illustrations were devised to represent the designated
...
...