Piaget No `Remedy' for Kuhn, But the Two Should be Read Together

  title={Piaget No `Remedy' for Kuhn, But the Two Should be Read Together},
  author={J. Burman},
  journal={Theory \& Psychology},
  pages={721 - 732}
  • J. Burman
  • Published 2007
  • Philosophy
  • Theory & Psychology
In arguing that the philosophical works of Jean Piaget could be used as a `remedy' for the flaws in those of Thomas Kuhn, Tsou overlooked some crucial aspects of the problem: the early history between them, the biological foundation supporting Piaget's method, and a preexisting suggestion regarding the intended future extension of his work. There was also no mention of the existence of a `lost' manuscript by Kuhn, which supposedly presents the mature articulation of his theory. This comment… Expand
Updating the Baldwin effect ☆: The biological levels behind Piaget's new theory
Abstract In 1964, Conrad Waddington (1905–1975) presented a paper in Geneva that led to an internal reassessment of the biological underpinnings of Jean Piaget's (1896–1980) theory. This in turnExpand
On Kuhn’s case, and Piaget’s: A critical two-sited hauntology (or, On impact without reference)
  • J. Burman
  • Philosophy, Medicine
  • History of the human sciences
  • 2020
This essay complexifies the understanding of both of Thomas Kuhn and Jean Piaget's legacies by presenting two sites for that haunting, one located by engaging Forrester’s argument that the connection between KuhN and psychoanalysis was direct, and the other located by uncovering Piagets early psychoanalytic ideas uncovered through their interaction with his early biology and subsequent turn to philosophy. Expand
Constructive history: From the standard theory of stages to Piaget’s new theory
This project demonstrates how Historians of Psychology can contribute to the future of Psychology from within the Department of Psychology (rather than from departments of History, the History andExpand
Philosophical histories can be contextual without being sociological: Comment on Araujo’s historiography
The future of the History of Psychology is bright, and the recent historiographical debates in this journal play an important role in that. Yet Araujo’s recent contribution could be misunderstood:Expand
Experimenting in Relation to Piaget: Education is a Chaperoned Process of Adaptation
  • J. Burman
  • Sociology
  • Perspectives on Science
  • 2008
This essay takesas its point of departureCavicchi's (2006) argument that knowledge develops through experimentation, both in science and in educational settings. In attempting to support and extendExpand
The mobile frontiers of Piaget’s psychology. From academic tourism to interdisciplinary collaboration / Las fronteras móviles de la psicología de Piaget. Del turismo académico a la colaboración interdisciplinaria
Abstract Jean Piaget’s (1896–1980) interdisciplinarity was related to his psychology in several ways. First, he was a simple tourist of other fields: an interested outsider. But as he becameExpand
History from within? Contextualizing the new neurohistory and seeking its methods.
  • J. Burman
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • History of psychology
  • 2012
An attempt is made to clarify Smail's solution to the problem of causation, which involves an appeal to evolutionary theory, and related ideas from the recent history of philosophy are imported. Expand
Piaget ' s four stages
    According to Jean Piaget's theory of cognitive development, intelligence is the basic mechanism of ensuring equilibrium in the relations between the person and the environment. This is achievedExpand
    Schools of Innovation Thought
    This chapter aims to start a debate about the underlying assumptions of innovation schools (research traditions) in which various frameworks and models have been developed. By identifying the socialExpand
    About The Constructivist Notion Of "Epistemic Framework". A Comparison With Kuhn's "Paradigm" Notion
    Desde el constructivismo epistemológico inspirado en la obra de Piaget, se ha propuesto la noción de “marco epistémico” para el tratamiento del problema de la relación entre sociedad y conocimientoExpand


    In defense of Piaget's theory: A reply to 10 common criticisms.
    The developmental theory of Jean Piaget has been criticized on the grounds that it is conceptually limited, empirically false, or philosophically and epistemologically untenable. This study attemptsExpand
    Reconstructing Scientific Revolutions: Thomas S. Kuhn's Philosophy of Science
    Few philosophers of science have influenced as many readers as Thomas S. Kuhn. Yet no comprehensive study of his ideas has existed-until now. In this volume, Paul Hoyningen-Huene examines Kuhn's workExpand
    Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge: The Nature of a Paradigm
    1. The initial difficulty: Kuhn's multiple definitions of a paradigm . 2. The originality of Kuhn's sociological notion of a paradigm: the paradigm is something which can function when the theory isExpand
    Genetic Epistemology and Piaget's Philosophy of Science
    This paper concerns Jean Piaget's (1896–1980) philosophy of science and, in particular, the picture of scientific development suggested by his theory of genetic epistemology. The aims of the paperExpand
    Piaget's Theory : Prospects and Possibilities
    Contents: B. Inhelder, Foreword. H. Beilin, Piaget's New Theory. Part I:Understanding Self-Organizing Systems as Equilibrating Systems. R. Garcia, The Structure of Knowledge and the Knowledge ofExpand
    Piaget's Conception of Evolution: Beyond Darwin and Lamarck
    The first full-length study of Jean Piaget as a philosopher and evolutionist. Messerly traces Piaget's earliest conjectures about knowledge through its further developments to its mature formulationExpand
    Where is psychology going? Structural fault lines revealed by psychologists' use of Kuhn.
    The author argues that psychologists, uncomfortably straddling natural and social science traditions, reference Structure for 2 reasons largely overlooked: first, because it presents an intermediate, naturalistic position in the war between relativist and rationalist views of scientific truth, and second,Because it presents a psychologized model of scientific change. Expand
    Abstract The paper criticizes some epistemological presuppositions of Piaget's and of neo-Piagetian's work, in particular, the psycho-Logical principle. This principle is contrasted with a more validExpand
    Imitation and the dialectic of representation
    In this paper, we take up Kessens challenge to develop a philosophically and historically informed developmental theory by describing a theory of the understanding and use of representations thatExpand
    Epistemologie des Sciences de l'Homme
    This publication brings together three sections of Piaget's enormous study published by UNESCO, Tendances Principales de la Recherche dans les Sciences Sociales et Humaines. In this two volume workExpand