Personal construct psychology and social constructionism are not incompatible: Implications of a reframing

@article{Pavlovi2011PersonalCP,
  title={Personal construct psychology and social constructionism are not incompatible: Implications of a reframing},
  author={Jelena Pavlovi{\'c}},
  journal={Theory \& Psychology},
  year={2011},
  volume={21},
  pages={396 - 411}
}
A usual way of thinking about the relationship between personal construct psychology (PCP) and social constructionism (SC) is treating them as two separate entities that are similar in some aspects, but also very different in others. This paper aims at exploring some of the possible implications of reframing the relationship between PCP and SC. I point to two important implications: treating PCP as a discourse and adding a new metaphor of the person. Finally, I argue that the invitation to… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Qualitative Grids, the Relationality Corollary and the Levels of Interpersonal Construing
Qualitative grids are powerful tools for mapping interpersonal construing and provide a new method of interviewing, research and intervention into social situations. This article introduces some of
Contrasts and synergies: A comment on Jones (2022)
In response to Jones’s (2022) article, we argue that if we understand personal construct psychology as being less rationalistic and more holistic than is often assumed, important synergies between it
Thinking in opposites: The psychologies of Carl Gustav Jung and George Kelly
The psychologies independently founded by Jung and by Kelly exemplify traditional approaches to personality and the self. Both assume a primacy of the private world and posit “opposites” as a
Contradictory regimes of practice: Constructs and discourses in an open prison
Using concepts from Kelly and Foucault, analysis of interviews in the mid-1990s with staff in an English open prison explores how contrasting discourses are reconciled. Two superficially antagonistic
Implicit Theories of Creativity in Higher Education: A Constructivist Study
A qualitative constructivist study was conducted to explore university teachers’ implicit theories of creativity. The aim of the study was to understand how university teachers (NL = 46) define
Towards a dignified food security? : discourses of dignity, development and culture in New York City and Bogotá
In light of a severe, changing and globally implicative New Food Equation marked perhaps above all else by the dynamics of a new, bimodal food insecurity and the simultaneous rising importance of
Reasons to Randomize: Sort-Specific Effects on Construct Content in Cross-Sectional Repertory Grid Studies
Several articles have discussed the effect of variations in the repertory grid procedure on measures derived from the data it generates. Largely unexplored, in contrast, is the effect of a more
A Psychological Perspective on City Brand Positioning: The Dimensional Organization of Sensemaking Data
Today the competition between cities is no longer a national game, but global, pitting emerging markets against traditional Western centers of economic power and decision makers have wholeheartedly
Competencies that Educators Need in Order to Manage Inclusive Classrooms: The Case of One High School in Alice
Abstract This paper aims to ascertain the kind of competencies needed by educators to enable them identify learner’s needs in diverse classrooms. The study attempts to identify the challenges
Within-person variation in personality and psychological well-being
II
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 15 REFERENCES
Personal-construct theory and social constructionism: Difference and dialogue
Abstract In psychology there are at least as many varieties of social constructionism (SC) as there are of constructivism. Many of these versions of SC share a number of crucial properties with
Social and Personal Constructs
Mancuso's (1996) article is to be welcomed for its attempt to bring together social constructionism, personal construct theory and narrative psychology. Whilst the underlying tendency of the three
The Situation of Social Constructionism
In a recent exchange in Theory & Psychology, in which (mostly Gergen's) social constructionism was the subject of some criticism, Gergen (2001a) remarked toward the end of his response, `I no longer
Exploring the Sphere of Between
A psychological understanding of interpersonal processes in terms of complementarity is not new. It is enough to mention Buber (the title of our paper refers to an expression of his), as well as
Psychology as a discipline of discourse
This paper begins with a discussion of various layers of meaning now associated with the term ‘discourse’. Particular attention is paid to one aspect of discourse, namely the notion of ‘dialogue’.
Introduction: Social Constructionism and its Critics
The articles in this issue signify the maturation of social constructionism. After introducing the articles, I raise two questions that have remained under-represented on these pages. First, the
Kelly Meets Foucault: Understanding School Underachievement
“Underachievement” in school is seen as a failure in traditional theories of education. An alternative construction of school underachievement is offered based on Michel Foucault's (1975) approach to
'The birth of bio-politics': Michel Foucault's lecture at the Collège de France on neo-liberal governmentality
This paper focuses on Foucault's analysis of two forms of neo-liberalism in his lecture of 1979 at the Collège de France: German post-War liberalism and the liberalism of the Chicago School. Since
The Use of Qualitative Grids to Examine the Development of the Construct Good and Evil in Byron’s Play “Cain: A Mystery”
This article grows out of a workshop conducted at the XVI International Congress on PCP, Columbus, Ohio, in July 2005. Its intention is to show how qualitative repertory grids (Procter, 2002) are
...
...